Being a Globalist, I think ultimately we all need to come together with all of our diversity.

Isn't that like having a club for non-stamp-collectors?

The drawback of having an atheist country instead of a secular one is that the religiously-driven countries would have no compunctions about trying to murder everyone in that country. Just like Nazis and demons in video games are "safe" targets to kill, because they are seen as not having any redeeming qualities, they'd feel the same way about a country that was explicitly atheist.

Much better to work at educating them out of their delusions a bit more gradually, and in their own countries.

It does not really work that way. Territorial Claims have history of place and peoples. Had A/Ags to formed a people and settled a place, in the last few decades or so, such a claim could have some standing.

Yes and no. I think we need our community, but not land. I don’t like the concept of land as property. I like the idea of secular custodians of land and that land is not ours but something shared.

That's a very good point...

But why should we move.? And I predict that any contrived effort to create an atheist land would only replicate the Israel/Palestine situation.

Let's see... more than 10% of americans are decendants of african slaves.... they should demand a portion of america. And more than 10% of americans speak Spanish... they should demand their Spanish only Utopia.... You want me to continue slicing your pizza?

No.

Have we not learned from the Israeli-Palestinian conflict? Lol

Why?

No. Even if we were to get any sort of exclusive area, it certainly wouldn't
ever be any kind of "utopia".
As long as humans are involved, there's no chance of Utopia.
Too many variables to ever achieve that ideal.

AN ATHEIST HOMELAND!! Great idea.

I think we should have nukes. For defense and stuff.

Yes we could demand a large tract of land in Israel, call it the unholy land... Every few days we could annex another little tract and build a few more Athiest settlements there...Im sure they'd understand.