For myself, I’m definitely a truth person … I would rather have a person hurt me now by telling me the truth … at least I know they are being honest and are treating me with a certain level of respect.
I hate it when I either feel like a person is lying to me to spare my feelings (no matter how well-intentioned they are) as it causes me to question everything regarding them – our friendship, wondering if they have lied to me before, and will they lie again … I tend to be mistrustful and extremely skeptical to begin with (particularly when it comes to friendships/relationships), so when I feel I have been lied to in some type of capacity – even something that is designed to spare my feelings – it sets off alarm bells that this person can not be trusted… and hence I tend to emotionally retreat and avoid them …
I wonder if I’m the only person who is like this, if it’s an adaptive strategy to protect myself from those who are not truly trustworthy, or if it’s part of my attachment issue walls that I have built around myself and am keeping good people out?
It depends. I prefer someone say something negative in a positive way..i.e., instead of saying, "That outfit makes your butt look like a sofa," they could say, "It's not very flattering to your figure. Perhaps the blue outfit would be better."
I don't want people to say to me, "You've been in Thailand over seven years and that's all the better you can speak Thai?" Instead, they could say, "You've been in Thailand for over seven years? No wonder you speak Thai as well as you do!"
I prefer the unadorned truth no matter how hurtful. A true friend tells you things about yourself that you do not want to hear. As for so-called friends who want to spare my feelings, I'm inclined to think that they are more afraid of my response or reactions or they are just moral cowards.
I had omitted truth to spare feelings. I don't get into marriage or couples problems and issues. There is a time and place for Everything. I had information once that will get someone murdered, no questions asked. I kept it to myself. Sometimes you have to protect your friends from themselves. About me... I can handle the Truth, any Truth. Those who know me well know I am very well in control of my acts and feelings so I don't need to be spared. Not everyone is like that.
@evestrat I was told you tell a woman the truth... but you don't have to tell her all the truth. Sometimes I will tell you what you ask me but not all I know about what you ask me. I have a friend that if I would had told him I saw his GF in a car with her ex BF, she would had been dead within minutes. The face she put when she saw me on the passing car told me all I needed to know. And the guy would had killed her, regardless the other guy would had been dead. What you do? I did what I needed to do that saved my friend from killing someone. I had already passed judgement in that relationship but It was none of my business, sometime being a "chaotic righteous" (to use a D&D label) is not Simply said Right. I could handle the truth, any truth to not a terrible result but there are people that handle the same truth with more terrible results. You always need to measure the upshot of your actions. Always. I won't say I had never lied by omission. But I will go to sleep in peace when I do knowing it was for the better good. I will tell you when you are ready, not before time and sometimes I will make that decision base on what I know about you.
In terms of subjective stress, I narrowly vote for "hurtful truth" due to me being a conflict avoidant personality. Of course in terms of what's best for all concerned, it's honesty, so sometimes what bothers you is not a good indicator of the best route to go. The only exception would be true so-called "white lies" where there's little to be gained by being honest and maybe even things to be lost, as you can become rather a hectoring piece of shit if you insist on "tough love" in all things. Part of forebearance and acceptance is creating a zone of safety where a person can be themselves, warts and all. Pick your battles wisely. People don't need a personality workout 24/7 just so they can exactly as YOU want them to be. Also some of your requirements are simply personal preferences, not a matter of right and wrong.
As a concrete example, I'm a typical male who broods in his mental man-cave when bothered by life, and that means I'm not as selfless as I generally am. I may not pay quality attention to my wife, I may be irritable. And generally ( gasp! ) I don't want to talk about it. But if she allows me the space to work through it, and doesn't insist on taking it personally, I'm soon back to my bubbly self (hahahahaha --- sorry, just kidding).
Similarly she is approach avoidant around intimacy but paradoxically if I let her have "her space" (even though sometimes I can't help but take it personally) that is the path to getting as much intimacy as she's able to give over the long haul. Last night for example she went up early to bed, something that used to be weird to me but I've long since gotten accustomed to. She was probably fretting about her daughter, who is in the middle of a cancer scare, but I've learned not to speculate -- she's perfectly capable of telling me WTF is going on, and if she doesn't, she doesn't. Anyway, paradoxically this is part of what's great about her, which is that she doesn't put her shit on me.
Later just as I was going up to bed, she came downstairs for a snack, I said something friendly and she said words to the effect I can go up to bed now. I could have pitched a fit about "what's that supposed to mean" but I just went up to bed. Sometimes we are ships passing in the night like that. I can either accept it or get honked off about it. I'm too old to be mad all the time.
So sure I could have delivered "the hurtful truth", extemporized about my hurt feelings, and how rude and inconsiderate she was. But was that the moment to die on that particular hill? I think not. And in point of fact I doubt she meant anything about it or was particularly even thinking about it. It's no different than me grunting my way through one of my mental withdrawals. I can't expect space for me to be myself if I don't give her space to be herself.
A lie, no matter how well meant, is a cruel act. Because the truth always emerges.
Simply telling the truth at the time my be painful but nowhere near as painful and being lied to then finding the truth.
I usually don't ask a question that I do not want to hear the honest truth about. Some people give rude unsolicited statements, under the guise of being "honest" or "real". I would prefer for those people to "white lie" or keep "their truth" to themselves.