I am an agnostic. In other words, I don't know if there is a God or not. I need more information to have an opinion. Why is it that everyone thinks that agnosticism and atheism are the same thing? What are you? Agnostic or Atheist? And why?
Welcome to the asylum. Enjoy your stay.
Not "everyone" thinks atheism and agnosticism are the same thing.
I am an atheist. I do not believe in ANY gods, let alone just one.
IF credible, verifiable evidence is ever shown to prove the existence of any god, I'll rethink my position.
Until such time, I will continue to believe that ALL gods are myths, ALL religion is evil, and religious faith is a deliberate mental illness.
@thaywth Religious faith is rooted in delusion.
Delusion is a symptom of mental illness.
Enough credible, verifiable evidence exists to disprove most religious claims.
There is ample scientific proof to make rejecting all religious claims the most logical path to take.
Religious faith us a deliberate mental illness.
People stubbornly cling to the shackles of their delusions when freedom of the mind is readily available.
There's nothing remotely "radical" about it.
I am defintely an Atheist, there is absolutely no evidence for any gods including the Biblical one and in fact when you read the Bible and see all of the things about our world and universe that were supposed to be fact, that we know now are scientifically impossible it makes me wonder why anyone believes in any of it.
I am right there with you!
Good job injecting Iowa common sense into the gibberjabbers for xian Webster lies....the dictionary is wrong....we are proper noun Atheists and it is the xian and his xmas that is living deluded in a a world crusading for an alleged vaginal virgin birthing an alleged baby gawd on December 25th each year IN A DIRTY DONKEY STABLE....and their are several shrines in Europe each with their alleged foreskins AMPUTATED PREPUCE flesh of their non-existent alleged baby gawd geebush jeehobah yhwh ghostholes
@GreenAtheist The Christians hijacked so many pagan holidays in order to make the locals worship their "God" and today's Christians don't even understand that if Jesus was born at all, it was not in December.
@misstuffy xians&xmas not much difference between bible believers and KKK believers burning crucifixes....burning in hell or being lynched is still terrorism
@GreenAtheist I agree, did you see where this school was letting Christians go in at lunch to preach to kids in a PUBLIC SCHOOL????
@misstuffy Pella Iowa schools have been doing this crap for 30 years....as long as no one complains or brags about it to the news.....school kids ARE NOT SAFE from Betsy deVos or any criminal theocrat
@misstuffy over in DeSoto a Jewish man won protection from Gideons forcing his daughter to sign her name in their bibles handed out to all in her class.... as soon as she graduated from elementary school the criminals came back and forced kids to do it again....1984 to 1987 only 3 years safe from these pornographic misogynistic genocidal incest anti-science "books" are shoved into kids hands
I'm an athiest.
There is outstanding clear evidence disproving any religious explanation that I have been presented.
There are reasonable explanations for all the things they try to explain backed up by evidence from multiple sources.
There is historical evidence of when and how these stories came to be and psychology and power dynamics of humans explain why.
"Why is it that everyone thinks that agnosticism and atheism are the same thing?"
No, everyone does not think that, or say that.
"I need more information to have an opinion."
No, you have already expressed an opinion. What you mean is you need more information to make a definitive statement that there is no God.
I am an atheist because despite the fact that I have no way of knowing 100% that there aren't any gods, I am 99.999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999% sure there aren't based on all available evidence (which is equal to jack shit that supports such a ridiculous concept). That .0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000001% of doubt isn't nearly enough to make me ride a fence for the rest of my entire life.
I’ve said this many times but I don’t mind repeating it for anyone who seems non hostile: I’m an agnostic atheist. The two terms aren’t mutually exclusive. They answer two different questions. Agnostic describes what I know, and atheist describes what I believe. Everyone in the world is an agnostic, meaning without knowledge, if they’re being honest with themselves. But unless there’s a form of theism you think more likely than the rest that you’re holding out hope for, you are also an atheist, meaning without theism. If you wish to not be an atheist you’ve got to pick a form of theism to believe in.
I’m not sure why everyone thinks atheist is a claim of absolute knowledge. I can say I have absolute knowledge that the gods described by man so far are logically inconsistent and impossible, but that doesn’t mean I claim to know everything period. We could be the result of alien cross breeding, or an ancestor simulation for all I know. But I know there’s no god as humans have conceived him so far.
@LimitedLight nah then it’s just time to walk away. I’ll teach elementary school if they want to pay me for it.
I am an anti-theist. Religion has always been the most destructive force that humankind has devised. It will be the death knell of our species.
I also belong to a group called the Brights (noun). [the-brights.net] This groups touts a natural world (universe) view. Gods do not exist because they work with supernaturalism. The universe does not operate by magic. There are laws and forces that control everything. There is no immortality because even the universe is mortal and we cannot outlive the universe. It only takes a bit of open-mindedness and thought to see the fallacies of religion and gods.
Maybe god IS the natural world, has no consciousness at all.
Or a Collective Consciousness.
Or Unconsciousness.
And/or maybe ther are other dimensions our five senses and the most sensitive of our instruments cannot detect.
Maybe a lot of things.
Maybe not.
Maybe what I'm saying is pure gibberish.
Maybe its pure genius.
How would you know?
@Storm1752 The 'god' we think exists works by magic. There is no magic in the universe. Just because we can't explain something doesn't mean it follows some rule.
For religious people if something can't (or hasn't yet) be explained they automatically assume it's magic from a god. Imagine if you could go back in time (which you can't) and took your cell phone to the 15th century. You would be considered a god. The people would see the phone as having magical powers. Most of us can't explain how it works but it does and it follows physical principles.
Atheist and anti-theist.
"What can be asserted without evidence can be dismissed without evidence."
I'm an agnostic atheist. This is because if I tell you with 100 percent certainty that there are no gods it is up to me to produce the evidence. I have none, but you can call yourself whatever you like.
inexistence does not need evidence, because to prove inexistence is impossible and you do not have to prove inexistence, but the existence must be proved. If you claim that something is there you need to prove it, here I don't have to prove that something is not there if you can't prove that it is there.
@David1955 It is a 50/50 argument. I use the Dawkins approach and that is also used by Matt Dillahunty on the Atheist Experience TV program. To claim something as 100 percent truth it is up to you to produce evidence. The idea of "proving a negative" shows your mind is made up already. Don't let this fool you. I do not believe in gods. You will have to show me evidence.
congratulations. i happen to be an atheist. you ask why everyone thinks agnosticism and atheism are the same thing but no one can answer that because it most certainly is not true that everyone thinks they're the same. you may as well ask why all women eat asparagus. it's not a valid premise. maybe you met someone who thinks they're the same. that doesn't mean everyone does.
i am an atheist because i don't need proof that there are no gods, and i have enough information to reject the idea of a god, which is as ridiculous as the idea of a tooth fairy or a leprechaun or a magic wand or a talking horse named mr. ed, as amusing as some of those things may be. if i am an agnostic about one i should be agnostic about all of them and more, and if i was interested enough, i would be exhausted searching for more information. there is just as much evidence of a god (or two or three) as there is of those other entities: none. if i am uncertain about god(s) then you can make up any old thing and i have to be uncertain about it instead of using my common sense and my education. i cannot be an agnostic by your description of it. some can. obviously you can. i cannot.
g
They are not "the same thing". But they are two sides of the same coin. Agnosticism is the knowledge position, atheism the belief position.
Agnosticism is not merely being unsure -- as if some day, somehow, you might become sure. It is the contention that there is no way to stake a knowledge claim concerning god's existence, as it's inherently impossible given the standard-issue interventionist supernatural deity. There will never be a day where a material being can determine the truth or falsity of an assertion about immaterial things.
As there is no scientific evidence of higher powers I’m 99.9% certain there there are no higher powers. Does that .1% make me agnostic instead of atheist?
There's no "scientific evidence" either way.
@TheMiddleWay sure give me the example to counter it. If you've got a relevant testable claim id love to see it. Until thatnis provided I'm happy to say every testable claim. Because if there actually was one theists woukd be pointing that shit out left amd right. There would be non stop news stories amd someone woukd get a novel prize. My confidence that I'm right is high.
Interesting question. I see God as something separate from religion. That makes me free to weave my own philosophy. Religion grew out of fear and is man-made and consequently, a great tool for those who wish to manipulate society for their own small, selfish ends. So I am an Agnostic. The evidence I notice is All That Is.
I am an atheist because I believe there is no God.
I agree; but be careful with that phrasing in front of believers, because they’ll immediately say “oh so it’s your belief, and that requires just as much faith without knowledge as mine does.” A more bulletproof way to phrase it might be “because I do not believe in any god.” It’s our lack of beliefs without evidence, not our belief in a negative statement that defines our position.
@Wurlitzer
You are right. I could change my statement but do not want to. Why should I worry about what others think when I do not plan to get into an argument? If I do, I will say that is my belief and I will not argue and I will not change my mind. You keep your belief and I will keep mine.
I struggle with this on a daily basis. I don’t know what I am, I have energy, and when I die that energy will go into or be absorbed by something else and the vessel where it was once stored will be gone. But I also know that when I lie on the ground in the sunshine or the rain, my body absorbs more energy, when I garden it’s barefoot and gloveless and I feel the energy and life from the earth. The universe is vast. It, in of itself, is master as we’ve no control over it....what it does controls us....so who is to say? The universe is a growing living thing....maybe it’s god, I don’t know. I do know that I connect to something so I consider myself, for lack of a better word, spiritual.
I too believe we humans are all connected. We have evolved and become more educated to know more and more about who we are and our position in the universe. Unfortunately humans are still chained to the dream of the supernatural and an immaterial existence after death. Yes, we each believe we have a human spirit, but to believe that this spirit continues to exist after we die is a delusion. And for what purpose, but to never forget our life on earth? GROG
In this universe we Atheists every human is born an Atheist with zero religion inherited into brains or sex organs.....we are localized order in an expanding cooling universe....we heat by eating or warming next to a heat source like a parent furnace or sunroof letting light in and keeping cold out....our species exerts great localized control over matter like beaver dams spiderwebs silken cocoons nesting birds or nursing moms....reality should not be telescoped or microscoped.....our perspective must always be rational not sentimental
I am atheist. I did my homework and discovered that there is NO good argument for the existence of gods in reality. They are all mythological. I spent years evaluating every book and pamphlet on apologetics that I could get my hands on. None of them has any convincing facts, reasoning, or evidence.
Sure, it is possible that there is a more convincing book that I have not yet seen, but I think it improbable. Many religious people did their best to convince me, and they all failed.
I will say that the only thing that could possibly convince me that a god exists, is god itself, no book, no preacher, no human, and to date no god has made any attempt to do that for me.
@jlynn37 Same here. I used to pray for evidence, but … crickets. Once I got so bold as to say, "God, if you exist, show me by striking me with lightening." I'm here decades later to tell you it never happened.