Agnostic.com

1 0

LINK Alien Languages May Not Be Entirely Alien to Us - WSJ

"All communication—and, eventually, all language—has evolved slowly through natural selection. The honey dance of the bees; the twittering song of the starling; the ballet dance of the male manikin bird—all achieved their impressive complexity slowly. Natural selection has no foresight and no goal in mind, so the solutions that will be favored are those that best suit the problem at hand. Making many different kinds of sounds is useful—not because they lay the basis for a language but because messages can be clear and unequivocal. Animals have large repertoires as a side effect of their communication needs, not because they actually need large repertoires.

Grammar may not be necessary in alien languages.

Perhaps grammar really distinguishes language from non-language. But many animals also have a grammar of sorts. For example, monkeys, with a fairly limited repertoire of sounds, combine those sounds in different ways to create new meanings. But as with the large repertoires of birds, this is just an evolutionarily efficient way of arranging sounds. Grammar seems to evolve as a byproduct and may not be necessary in animal or alien languages."

WilliamCharles 8 Mar 27
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

1 comment

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

There is no suh thing as an "alien" language. Foreign language, but alien language no.

Do you just respond based on the excerpts posted and not open the links? It was hypothesizing on how we might communicate with an alien species given what might have transpired in their own evolution. It also pondered what traits of each language might be similar.

@WilliamCharles We have no proof yet that there any alien languages which have ever been transmitted in the direction of earth.

@wordywalt - again, it was not citing proof. It was speculation along the lines of exobiology. We have no evidence of any alien species, but we can still imagine how different environments might shape life there.

You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:585222
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.