Agnostic.com

4 2

Forget the symbolism of martyrdom and righteous devotion to blind faith, do you not find it utterly disgusting aesthetically to see a dead guy on a cross hanging around the necks of Christians?

This is a limp, dead guy... held up by nails... on an execution device... proudly displayed on the bodies of believers.

Am I wrong for being so repulsed?

If Jesus were hung, electrocuted, or put to sleep, do you think it would be acceptable for Christians to wear a beautiful gold necklace depicting him hung on a noose, slumped over on the electric chair, or with a needle in his arm?

August1 6 Feb 13
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

4 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

1

In my version of this Jesus would be in an electric chair hanging around my neck by silver chain. He would be fried and his skull cracked open. This execution of another time is not real to me because I do not like jewelery or necklaces. Maybe I should look into getting one and just hang it on my wall.

4

For a long time there was debate among historians over whether people were tied or nailed to the cross. It is now mainly thought that it was both, because if you just fasten them with rope their arms and legs shrink as the circulation declines and then slip out, while nails can and will pull through.

Also after a while, hanging from the ropes becomes painful, and the victim finds it hard work to breath, they could however, and did attempt to ease this by moving, which they could only do by using the nails to raise their weight, which is also painful, but it prolongs the suffering by helping breathing. The constant need to try and find ease between the pain of the ropes and the nails therefore kept the victim constantly squirming, which was regarded by the Romans as the main horror of that form of death. After a while, fluid builds up around the lungs and this could stop breathing, causing a quicker death. So it is thought that the practice of pushing a spear point into the side under the ribs, to let off the fluid, and thus further prolong suffering, grew up. By giving hydration in the form of water made unpleasant with vinegar, the victim could be kept squirming for three or four days.

I do not know if telling them this will make any difference, but you could try it.

( Some people have speculated that the idea that Jesus was lowered from the cross early after barely three days , much sooner than usual, thanks to Joseph bribing the guard. Was a sign that maybe he was not truly dead when brought down. Which could explain a lot. )

Yes what you say was the content of many priest's homily on Good Friday. They made their description as gruesome as possible.

3

In fact, it was not an acceptable adornment until rather recently. Puritans (and those types) don't believe such symbols are cool and eschew them. Not easy to chew a cross but they managed.

0

I don't know, I live in the UK and you hardly ever see that here.

@Matias There are a few, but I live in the country where being nominal Anglican is still the only option. Have not seen a cross openly round anyones neck for ages.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:650359
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.