Agnostic.com
11 1

I am a therapist who is working on building his private practice. I've already studied and specialized, but I am curious to know the impressions freethinking and skeptical people like yourselves have of various types of therapy. Are there any you gravitate towards? What would you look for in a therapist? All responses appreciated.

ejbman 7 Mar 21
Share
You must be a member of this group before commenting. Join Group

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

11 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

person centred counselling was my go to so much so i did the training and became a counsellor until my all people are idiots outlook on life was overwhelmed by clients tough lesson but i realised although i liked the format i was truly to judgemental to try and help people in need what i look for is professionalism and to avoid like the plague anyone who uses terms like detox chakras etc

weeman Level 7 July 17, 2018
0

I have not used therapists extensively, I ended up switching them after two sessions.
Main reason being they didn't take notes, or do recording, and next time they see me they don't really remember what we talked about.

mander207 Level 4 June 28, 2018

Your experience sounds disappointing. However, I would like to validate your decision to keep moving along until you find someone who meets your needs. Research demonstrates that the quality of the relationship between the client and therapist accounts for at least 40% of the effectiveness of therapy.

Though you have been disappointed, I would encourage you to keep looking. I feel sure there is someone out there who can meet your needs.

By the way, I hear you say that taking notes or making a recording seems like the best way for a therapist to remember what was discussed last time. Perhaps I just have a good memory or something but I do not use those tools and I seem able to remember well enough.

I wish you the best in finding what you need.

2

a naturopath who operates as a gp/physician, thus bills via the national healthcare scheme, which is medicare in australia.

haha, i'm just realising this is all about PSYCHOtherapy. glad i could clarify that. the same as above applies in the case of any psychotherapy. i consider myself fortunate enough to have so many bulk-billing options where i live, & in australia in general.

core energetics in a group worked bestest for me.

1

I would say one that would come to my own house.
She's starting with me next week at home.

Wildgreens Level 8 Mar 21, 2018

Oh interesting. As far as I know, that service is not widely available in my area. I did hear about a family counselor that is part of a social service team in my professional network traveling to client's homes, but most of the private practice people I know have offices where clients come to us.

0

What is your opinion of transactional analysis?

FrayedBear Level 9 Mar 21, 2018

I honestly don't know a ton about TA. I know it has gone out of favor, and we were not taught about it as a serious contender in my theories of counseling class. The 5-cent overview I was given suggested TA was developed as a watered-down version of Freudian theory for the masses, but don't quote me on that.

@ejbman Certainly Berne's 366 pages of "What do you say after hello" can be condensed into one sentence - " do you want to go and try to make mutually satisfying love now or after a shower?" ? As always those who did not think of and profit from the theory will disparage it. Is this a reason for snowflakes?

3

I appreciate your inquiry. I used a form of therapy/counseling years ago through my EAP (Employee Assistance Program)at work. Many companies have a similar resource. At the time, I worked for a university. I was struggling in a new department with lots if workers (bullies) who were related. I needed help with conflict resolution and honestly, with changing my own behavior and reactions. I felt initially uncomfortable regarding the counselor's referencing religious ideology as though I certainly had the same beliefs. As time went on, and despite my religious "disagreement" with her, I began to trust and like her and I felt that I could trust her enough to inform her that I was indeed an atheist. It was shocking to watch her physical and facial reaction upon the realization that she had been counseling an atheist who was never receptive to her "Thank Jesuse's", "Thank Gods", and "prayer is powerfuls". Her body seemed to adjust in her chair to move as far from me as possible without actually getting up and moving. Her face had a subtle look of disgust. Her eyes became hard and unaccepting. When she spoke to me again after my revelation, her tone was curt and to-the-point. The session was ended soon after and I was hurried on my way. It bothered me. It hurt me. I felt intimidated to report her, and it took me months before I finally sent an email to her supervisor describing my experience with her. The supervisor responded empathetically, quickly, and apologetically expressing how unaccepatable my experience with her was and he committed to discussing matter with her. I don't know if he ever did, but I was glad to discover that she retired about a year later. This woman was an "award winning" employee. Yet, so bigoted, biased, unprofessional, and ignorant. I guess I'm just venting. I s'pose it still hurts a little.

I'm surprised that she didn't use her forefinger to make a cross and hold it up against you!
I have an effigy in the back of my car of a cadaver with red eyes, vampire teeth a pair of horns, a bits of flesh decayed or carved away. I will post a picture when I get home. Here I get two reactions - 1. the hasty Catholic crossing of the chest or the crossed forefingers and averted glance or 2. "Hey Mr can we take a photo of your grandad" ... The latter is a reference to a sign in the car window that says "If you think I'm ugly wait til you see my grandson driving!"

@FrayedBear Haha funny! Come to think of it, had she had a vial of holy water.... for Pete's sake. Jeesh!

@AtheistLatina55 Holy water burns! That would look good on the compo claim form. ???????????

I thank you so much for sharing your experience, although I'm so, so sorry that it turned out the way it did. That person was clearly violating the ethical standards of the profession. Not that I think you should have to endure any more waste of time or exposure to misery, but be aware that the statute of limitations for grievances is 7 years. I would seriously consider notifying the state board in the state where this person practiced that she was harming clients with her bigotry. You probably have grounds to sue for malpractice, even if she is retired - possibly even getting to the deep(er) pockets of the university, who should never have allowed her to practice with that kind of attitude. If it sounds like I am mad at this person, that's because I am. What horrible, unprofessional behavior on her part. Once again, I'm sorry you had to go through that betrayal of your trust by someone to whom you should be able to look to for support. It makes the job of the rest of us who are more ethical and professional that much harder when awful people like that ruin the experience of people who are going to them for help. I guess I would like to assure you that all therapists are not like that, and I hope that you have been able to seek help elsewhere. But nobody could blame you if you at least screened potential therapists in depth in the future to make sure you wouldn't get treated the same way.

4

I saw a therapist a couple of times, and seriously, cost was a major factor. Side note, we need more therapists in the US I am happy to see you building a practice. I work in disability claims and I frequently hear about long waits for an appointment with any type of counselor.

Thank you for your encouragement. I am private-pay at this time, but I hope to get on one or more insurance panels in the future so that my services are more accessible to people who need them. Having said that, it is my understanding from speaking with colleagues that relationships with insurance companies can be a major pain, and that they are always working to limit the time we can spend with clients. As with many things in life, it involves tradeoffs.

@ejbman If I get started on insurance we will be here alll day. In short insurance companies have us by the short hairs and are actively interfering with health care in the US.

@HippieChick58 Agreed on all counts.

2

Good Luck in your profession.

Thank you very much!

3

I've been interested in studying Art Therapy. I'm a potter and I see just how therapeutic an activity such as making art can be for my students. I know I didn't really contribute to your question. Sorry.

I appreciate your comment, and I disagree with your assessment: you did contribute. I have known a handful of art therapists, and I absolutely believe that such activities can have therapeutic effects. At the very least, doing something you enjoy and which feeds your emotional needs is a wonderful act of self-care, and among the better coping skills.

@ejbman I had a friend who believed that working with people who were engaged in participating in undertaking artistic endeavour were more susceptible to allowing free flow of their historis than if they were sitting face to face where conscious appraisal resulting in censorship was more likely to happen. His art endeavour was making glass jewellery, one of his more favoured pieces being a single bladed razor embedded in glass and sold as a pendant with the instruction "In desperation break glass otherwise call Lifeline number, 1-800-273-8255 (TALK) and talk to a trained counselor."

3

Cognitive worked for me. Years ago, I went to work on some things. Best thing I ever did. I also went to a support group. I made an arrangement where I didn't care if they prayed, if they didn't care if I didn't. It worked beautifully

Livinlife Level 9 Mar 21, 2018
3

My therapist just listens and comments sometimes. I talk too much. It's not therapy. It's me venting.

Sarahroo29 Level 8 Mar 21, 2018

Thats hysterical!

I do the same thing!

ejbman is a buddy of mine, and when he was going to school, he tried using me in one of his class assignments. He was supposed to video a counseling session.

The entire video was just me ranting, I don't think I took a pause to breath long enough for him to get in any counseling...

I wasn't asked to participate again. Not sure why... LoL

@Doug_in_Colorado Lol.

Now, now you two. No need to be so self-critical. Sometimes what we need is the supportive, listening ear of another person. That can be therapeutic all by itself.

Write Comment

Recent Visitors 51

Photos 22 More

Posted by HippieChick58Regardless of what you think of Oprah, she has staying power. Not necessarily slimming power. Do you remember when she was slim?

Posted by HippieChick58Regardless of what you think of Oprah, she has staying power. Not necessarily slimming power. Do you remember when she was slim?

Posted by pmar044After weeks of exercise and healthy eating, my body got a nasty shock this Fri/Sat with a blowout of rich food, sugary drinks and beer.

Posted by pmar044After weeks of exercise and healthy eating, my body got a nasty shock this Fri/Sat with a blowout of rich food, sugary drinks and beer.

Posted by pmar044After weeks of exercise and healthy eating, my body got a nasty shock this Fri/Sat with a blowout of rich food, sugary drinks and beer.

Posted by pmar044After weeks of exercise and healthy eating, my body got a nasty shock this Fri/Sat with a blowout of rich food, sugary drinks and beer.

Posted by pmar044After weeks of exercise and healthy eating, my body got a nasty shock this Fri/Sat with a blowout of rich food, sugary drinks and beer.

Posted by pmar044After weeks of exercise and healthy eating, my body got a nasty shock this Fri/Sat with a blowout of rich food, sugary drinks and beer.

Posted by pmar044After weeks of exercise and healthy eating, my body got a nasty shock this Fri/Sat with a blowout of rich food, sugary drinks and beer.

Posted by HippieChick58This is why I try to avoid prescription medications.

Posted by HippieChick58Yoga philosophy

Posted by HippieChick58I eat butter, never margarine.

Posted by walklightlyAt the annual mardigras in nimbin. natural food, healing & equality for all!

Posted by walklightlyAt the annual mardigras in nimbin. natural food, healing & equality for all!

Posted by walklightlyAt the annual mardigras in nimbin. natural food, healing & equality for all!

Posted by walklightlyAt the annual mardigras in nimbin. natural food, healing & equality for all!

  • Top tags#video #Atheist #god #books #DonaldTrump #religion #religious #Exercise #yoga #Bible #book #cults #humans #China #advice #youtube #friends #world #community #Song #alcohol #college #videos #GMO #relationship #holiday #earth #Catholic #church #Christian #religions #MikePence #evolution #ancient #created #faith #society #atheism #beliefs #reason #movies #memories #cultures #culture #weed #suicide #kids #medicine #animals #wife ...

    Members 96Top

    Moderator