Agnostic.com

24 18

Should schools have a Mandatory Life Skills Class?

sassygirl3869 9 June 8
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

24 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

7

Yes! "Home economics" was just an elective class in school for me, but although it was seen as basically "the cooking class"/girlie class, I took it and it was way more than just that. We were not just taught about cooking but also stuff like budget balancing, credit cards & loans, and even things like insurance and taxes.
Maybe my school had it differently than others, but it gave me a good outline of how the real world worked.

Had something very similar when I was in high school. I took it also.

7

We used to. There was Home Ec where male and female students learnt cooking and sewing, and Consumer Ec where we learnt budgeting, balancing accounts, etc.

7

Also the minor thing like read and write as this seems to be lacking in many schools today.

Also the parents job ?

6

Yes!!!!!! Actually they used to have classes like these. Was called Home Economics when I was in school.

6

I took welding and drafting... it helped for my first real job.

5

I'm uneasy at "mandatory"

5

Yes, I speak to people all day long who know nothing about contracts they sign and who feel cheated. They only hear what they want to hear.

5
5

Of course. We used to have those classes in the old days.

5

I find this interesting... The norm is that we don't want mandatory things but when it boils down to areas out of our scope (non of us would go back to school to take such classes, would we?) then it's ok to ask for mandatory stuff. Why don't we push our luck a bit further and ask for a mandatory class to be happy !! (You will be happy and you are going to like it because its mandatory !!!!) See how ridiculous that sound?

5

We actually had all that in school. Things started going into the shitter in the 80s.

5

We used to have home economics that taught you some things but only the girls took the class and a lot of it was about wearing certain clothes that made you look good and makeup. It would have been nice to learn things like writing a check or getting your driver's license.

5

How credit cards can screw you up and basic concepts of interest.

BillF Level 7 June 8, 2018

Nooo how will they trap you in constant debt if they teach you that ???

I did learn that. Now my credit score is in the shitter because I decided to be responsible and not spend money I didn't have. ?

@memorylikeasieve it's one of the craziest systems I've ever heard about

@memorylikeasieve My daughter couldn't get a credit card because she had always only used a bank debit card and had never even bought something on hire purchase - so she had a bad credit rating!
She only wanted it because some web sites only take credit cards, not debit cards.
I always pay my credit cards immediately, and always leave a small positive balance in them when I do.

4

Absolutely, and the boys especially should have to take home-ed. The big problem is that today both parents often work so information they should teach their kids is often missing. Too many kids these days get shuttled off to day care from an early age.

4

Why is this always about blaming the school for a child's failings? I thought parents were supposed to teach their children to tell the time and simple reading, then as their children grew older talk to them about morality, show them how to cook, and so forth. Perhaps schools need mandatory classes for the parents of their pupils?

I agree, but sometimes parents don't , so why not be at the very least, redundant?

@nvrnuff Thereby taking away a large amount of advanced education time from the majority for the sake of the minority. Perhaps parent / teacher organisations should be made to tackle the subject.

4

YES! I have been saying this for years! They need to have a mandatory class to teach them how to balance a checkbook, make a budget, plan a menu! A class on public services also! How to mail something at the Post Office, what does a zoning office do, what is code enforcement. I've seen college graduates that didn't know where to put a stamp on a letter!

4

Yes. cooking, bills, taxes, interviewing, paying rent...

4

Yes I 100000% agree with such a course just like I agree with your other idea, but things like changing a tire and cooking are not as important as knowing laws, knowing how to land a job, dieting, money management, etc.

The real essentials should be concentrated on the hardest.

Yes, if you get a flat tire on your way to a job interview you can call AAA and wait for them to change your tire. LOL

I'd say cooking is exceedingly important to know how to do, thus you can eat more healthily.

@memorylikeasieve

Okay but when you cook food, you lose nutrients to the air for most foods. It's better to put big checks on cooking. There is a biochemistry to cooking good food, you cannot just cook through a whole nutritional regimen, it's heavily mistaken. If someone taught you to cook by default, then they taught you wrong.

@buzz13

Changing a tire is a predominantly physical and not a mental task, so it's natural for a person to swap out a tire, okay? It's not as dire as money management, getting the right job, study skills, etc. and other things that can affect someone's quality of life directly in our social mobility-dominated world.

@DZhukovin So it doesn't take brains to change a tire is a bit of a put down on other people. You appear to have a superior attitude and are not really contributing to the community as a whole.

@buzz13

I am not making an attitude, I was making a descriptive statement, it's not meant to be taken as a normative suggestion or something. I do not create the sensitivities of other people nor do I create their mistranslations, THEY do those things. I don't, I am just telling the truth.

@DZhukovin yeah, you quit cooking your food and let me know which gets you first, the salmonella or the botulism. ?

Furthermore, 'cooking,', here, refers to meal preparation in general. Don't be pedantic.

@memorylikeasieve

Are you putting words in my mouth? I know what I am talking about, some foods are much, much better uncooked.

No, I am sorry but cooking is not food preparation, cooking involves applying heat.

4

I have advocated this for years. while teaching I frequently integrated life skills into my curriculum.

4

I grew up in Puerto Rico, public school had "domestic economy" in junior high for the girls, boys were taught how to work in wood, we were taught tools and skills. Vocational schools will get you ready with a high school diploma and a profession. Too much emphasis on computers now I guess.

3

Yes, I speak to people all day long who know nothing about contracts they sign and who feel cheated. They only hear what they want to hear.

3

No ! Thats the parents job !

Unfortunately parents often don't possess the skills either

@Kadygee
Then they shouldn't be parents ?

@VAL3941 maybe not but I don’t think they are going to stop reproducing anytime soon

@Kadygee
And that my dear is thd tradigy !

3

Apparently, this should be required.
My cul-de-sac neighborhood is comprised of guys and gals who were taught this stuff by OUR PARENTS. That's just not happening anymore. And that's a sad, sad commentary on our culture.

1

Absolutely

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:102102
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.