Thank you all for your comments! Seems like my best option is to move from Bible Belt country. I'm still in college so this will take a while.

Modern America

Unless you move - it just means you'll have to search that much harder. They're out there, but few and far between !

Move to some place like Los Angeles or San Francisco.

this is a good start

On most dating sites where it asks details, some of the answers are; Agnostic, atheist, spiritual, free thinker,etc. I found when I listed my detail profile as agnostic I got a lot of women who themselves were agnostic, atheist, etc., contacting me. They are out there.

Hi, Jules, and welcome to the website,

This website has a bit of a learning curve so here is some information that might be helpful.

You earn website points, and help other members get to know you better, when you write an informational profile that includes your hobbies and interests, and answer all the profile questions, since that's the first place many people look when they see a new member.

Also, the website uses your profile to find member matches, so the more details you include, the better the match.

Then you make comments and write your own posts to earn more points and privileges; for instance, at level two you can private email people. You get different perks with each level, and when you reach level eight you get an agnostic T-shirt.

To find members near you, click on the "Meet" button at the top of the page, then on "Members," and enter your preferred search parameters.
Or click on the "About" button at the top of the page to find links to FAQ or the website tutorial.
Click on the 'Meet" button to find member matches

Levels are mostly a way to help identify and reward those who contribute to the growth of the community. The website also gives more access and benefits depending on level.[agnostic.com]

Perks for each level: [agnostic.com]

Links to FAQ: [agnostic.com],
and a website tutorial: [agnostic.com]

Have fun!