Agnostic.com

4 1

Why is person A a believer, but person B is an atheist?

I do not think that there a simple answer to that question. It is as complex as the answer to questions like "Why is A tall, and B is short?" - "Why is A intelligent, and B is not?" - "Why is A obese, but B is slim?" ... and so on.
The answer to questions like these is always a mixture of: genes, hormones, parental care, environment, peers, education.. and a lot of chance and contingent events.

It is nonsense to be proud of being, say, slim or intelligent or tall ; and being a believer or atheist is nothing to be proud of either. When some atheists say "I do not believe in God or Karma because I 'm so smart!" - it always reminds me of The Donald claiming that he is rich and famous and powerful because he is so incredibly smart and a stable genius.

I'm an atheist myself, but with some other genes, other friends, or some different twists in my life... who knows what could have happened and I would be a monk now.
Our lives are more the result of many little invisible hands working in the basement of our existence, and blind forces pushing us around, than the outcome of our conscious decisions.
And do not forget: Even our conscious decisions are the result of the machinery in the basement of our mind...

Matias 8 June 23
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

4 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

Sometimes I wonder about the nature/nurture element of it as we all have free choice if we choose to employ it - I think for myself it was the chances in my life that opened for me and others that closed - Also I was born into a family of atheists shortly after WW2 ended and it was a great time - People around me were kind especially when rationing was ending and I do remember vividly sweets coming off ration- At the time I was going to work it was a sellers market I could walk into a job on Monday and have a new one the next week . So its a lottery how old you are what society is up to who is president of the U.S and what our stinky government is up to with brexit deals - very little of it seems anything other than a lottery.

jacpod Level 8 June 23, 2018
0

Oh I would probably still be a fundamentalist if the abstraction hadn't leaked so badly. People tend to be what they were born into and tend to remain that way unless something about it really doesn't work well.

On the other hand now that I'm a couple of decades outside that particular reality distortion field I could never go back, either.

1

At some point, normally very young, we form "base beliefs". And, our world view today is a product of countless decisions made from that base. Three political philosophers, Hobbs, Locke, and Burke (not sure here), were all important in this field. They were quite different in their conclusions about the role of the government. And, to my astonishment, I found that they had all proceeded logically. They simply had different base beliefs. One was religious. One was agnostic, and one was an atheist. So, our view of the world is not governed by intelligent. I don't think we atheists are one bit more intelligent than religious people. What I am unclear about is when, and how, we form these base beliefs. I've been thinking about this, i e, why people believe what they believe, since I was eleven.

Herb43 Level 3 June 23, 2018
1

I’ve not seen Atheists brag of a higher intelligence, or better education ..though they’ll occasionally acknowledge it. As I once read the monthly editorials of Madalyn Murray O’Hair, she welcomed us as “The intellectual elite.” A grandiose proclamation? After reading her piece, I agreed, and continue to.

What I’ve witnessed among Atheists is the desire to teach, or elevate the less aware or educated, not lord over them.. There’s no prestige or economic benefit being an atheist, if anything - the opposite.

Atheists appear to make bold choices, and, they’re honest. I think we’ve all experienced situations where the decision we made at ‘that moment’ was a reflection of who we are. And yes, we’ve many to thank for such morals … perhaps as well those who provided us a template of ‘what not to be.’ Our constant individual choices, and credit when/ where credit’s due 😉

Varn Level 8 June 23, 2018
Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:113789
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.