Redeeming my old xian music?! Something unexpected has happened to me the last few days. In the midst of a tough time, I've been finding comfort in my old xian music, in particular Tenth Avenue North and Abandon, if you're familiar with those bands.
No worries... I'm not suddenly irrationally believing in god again! I replace "god" with "me" and it's all about how I have the power to change myself. I am the one giving myself unconditional love. Before I can love another, I have to love myself. Facing myself is simultaneously frightening and hope-inducing.
"So you thought you had to keep this up
All the work that you do
So we think that you're good
And you can't believe it's not enough
All the walls you built up
Are just glass on the outside
So let 'em fall down
There's freedom waiting in the sound
When you let your walls fall to the ground
We're here now
This is where the healing begins, oh
This is where the healing starts
When you come to where you're broken within
The light meets the dark
The light meets the dark"
(Healing Begins, Tenth Avenue North)
Even with zero belief in god, the last few days I've been bathing myself in this music. Very healing. So surprising because not long ago this music was triggering for me, bringing back various unhealthy thoughts associated with deconversion.
The idea that we're all basically broken is false. But if there are real issues from your past that have affected you, then there are broken bits. Xianity didn't work for me - because I believed it... I trusted god to change those bits. But only those who did the hard work actually changed. It was us all along. That realization is so freeing... I'm the one with the power. It's not magic wand power... It takes time. But it's not nothing either.
Thoughts?
I sing along to all Christmas carols on the radio --secular and Gawd-Jeebus invoking...but don't tell anyone because I'll deny it.
Excellent news. Proves you have transcended the evangelical aim of the songs and now responding to your own personal understanding. The songs are merely vehicles to reveal deeper aspects of yourself. No more dogma. The same with texts that you read. A very long time ago a very respected teacher said to me, "Let the text read YOU" I didn't understand what he meant then. It took several texts and years of life experience to understand what he meant!
Whatever actual merit there is in such lyrics is where it evokes the human condition and ways of responding to it. As you suggest, any god-talk is just an overlay on that. The lyrics you quote from are really just about generic themes like being authentic and honest and transcending your "brokenness". Note, god isn't even mentioned in the lyrics you quoted -- really, not even particular Christian tropes. As usual, god is not a necessary entity to explain or express the human condition.