We live in the worst of possible worlds.
Origins of the world can be put into at least two categories:
How about Case #2: Scenario 3? In this case, the Almighty created the universe and the laws governing it, and moved on to other things, never to be seen or heard from. In this case, the Creator never interacts, never tweaks, never inspires, never punishes. The Creator is the ultimate absentee landlord. This is the case of the Deist, which many of the Founding Fathers accepted, including my avatar. It is essentially Case #1 but with a 'superpower' first cause. And it is no more Panglossian than any of the cases you've described.