Who on here has ever liked someone that may have been religious but never told you
So, how would you know? I mean, if they never told you, what do you mean by "may have been religious but never told you"? Do you see the problem you've created with this question? If people don't tell you how religious they are, do you assume? Can you perhaps re-think this entire post? Where's the 'thumbs down' button on this damn site?
Most folks I know and have dated are religious. I can discuss religions civilly and with respect. I enjoy a theological debate from time to time. In fact I had a friend who was a Bishop(not affiliated with roman catholic church) and we almost regularly discussed theology. He died last year from a massive heart attack.
Honestly religion seldom comes up in the early stages of dating. It's when the holidays (esp Easter) comes around, it's obvious I don't follow most traditions.