Agnostic.com

13 1

This was a letter to the editor in our local Syracuse, NY newspaper.

To the Editor:

I'm glad you used the word "prayer" in your report on the Christian Brothers Academy student who was stricken during play.

Two people wrote to you criticizing you for this because it could not be proved that prayer helped.

However, they forget it could not be proved that it did not help, either.

Even doctors admit they do all they can, but sometimes there seems to be a higher power that seems to be there.

Perhaps more prayer would make this world a bit better.

Dorothy W. Hotaling
Sherrill

[syracuse.com]

ADKSparky 8 Oct 20
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

13 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

1

I sometimes think about what "prayer" really is. If it is petitioning a higher power to intercede on our behalf, then of course that is delusional. And often self-centered and silly. But I sometimes find myself in a state where I am not consciously thinking about anything. Some may call it meditation or self hypnosis or whatever. But in those times, unclouded by by any expectation, I feel a sense of well being. Is that something that can be called prayer? I also think our bodies have a natural ability to heal if we don't interfere. Of course not for severe injury or illness, but for common ailments just letting your immune system do its thing is sufficient. And if "prayer" helps you do that, fine. But the line is crossed when prayer is a substitute for genuine caring, or action. Or when the sick are told that they deserve their illness as part of a supreme being's plan or as punishment.

5

Well .

3

ms hotaling is, what's the polite word for it? an idiot.

g

5

I love LOVE this quote from George Carlin:

“I've begun worshipping the sun for a number of reasons. First of all, unlike some other gods I could mention, I can see the sun. It's there for me every day. And the things it brings me are quite apparent all the time: heat, light, food, and a lovely day. There's no mystery, no one asks for money, I don't have to dress up, and there's no boring pageantry. And interestingly enough, I have found that the prayers I offer to the sun and the prayers I formerly offered to 'God' are all answered at about the same 50% rate.”

2

Nothing fails like prayer. However, maybe you were not holding your tongue right inside your mouth or not holding your breath correctly. Perhaps you should try to fart but not fully. Beware of trying too hard.

@icolan Yeah, and it might result in crap too.

@Nutpoacher because they're an old fart? ?

1

Tots and pears for all!

BillF Level 7 Oct 20, 2018
2

Do they feel the same way about voo doo? I bet they don't.

2

As Annie Laurie Gaylor of FFRF says, "Nothing fails like prayer". This has been my experience with "prayer" and have to say I agree with Ms. Gaylor.

3

There is no evidence that prayer changes anything. There is plenty of evidence that prayer changes nothing. You cannot prove that unicorns do not exist. This person does not understand the scientific method.

4

So far Ricky's observation has worked for me. No vampires yet!

Ricky is right. I've had a big string of garlic for years now and I don't have vampires. Every now and then there is a bat.

3

Or perhaps people making an effort to be better would make this world a bit better.

Clearly their god has had a tremendous amount of time to make the world a bit better and has not seen fit to do so. Perhaps he's asleep or on the shitter? (I'm just using the same argument Elijah taunted the priests of Ba'al with when Ba'al didn't answer their petitions).

5

I find it sad that people resort to prayer to try to make the world a bit better. Surely it would be more effective for them to roll up their sleeves and dedicate time and effort to helping the homeless.

Your are right of course but, "roll up their sleeves and dedicate time and effort" does just that, takes time and effort and that is the one thing they are not willing to give.

1

It is just another "god of the gaps" argument. We don't know why, therefore "god did it". Since we don't know why, it would be just a logical to say "fairies with pixie dust did it" or "the agent who coded the simulation that we live in decided to change the code did it". People will believe what they believe.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:204996
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.