Agnostic.com

3 1

I couldn't figure out which category to put this in, as it jumps all around the place. Si I'll just put this here.

A new tenant moved into the upstairs apartment yesterday. She is in her early 30s, and suffers from anxiety. She is the sort of person who could easily blend into a crowd: average looks, about 20 or so pounds overweight, glasses.

She has a dog named Button Gwinnet. He is a service dog for her. I'd never heard of that. I have no idea of his breed, other that that he falls squarely in the "cute little dog" variety.

He's an affectionate little guy, very willing to jump on your lap. If he gets upset, just holding him close calms him down. If only we could be like that!

I didn't get much of an impression of her. She was apologizing for every little thing, most of which I wouldn't have noticed, or for that matter even cared about. It was the usual first meeting: both sides were trying to be accomodating. Later on, of course, we'll both let the super polite masks fall away and be ourselves.

Her boyfriend was completely different from her. He too was in his early 30s, and had that slacker look to him: shaved heard, scraggly beard, thin.

I was looking over some supplies I had bought to make a couple of PVC telescope mounts. He seemed quite interested in what I was doing. We talked, sporadically, in between him helping her move in.

He has a lot of interests. But, to my mind at least, they're the wrong interests. He brought up Eric Von Daniken. "Pure crap," I said. Von Daniken was a writer who believed aliens from outer space influenced our culture, our art, and showing the Egyptians how to build the pyramids.

According to Von Daniken, there is no such thing as human imagination. People couldn't possibly have dreamed up all those weird cave drawings and such in the past on their own. And since we don't know precisely how the pyramids were built, aliens must have done it.

My take is that people in the past were just as smart as we are: they just knew different things. If you take anyone from the present and placed them at any time in the past, even if it was just 50 years, they would not survive for long.

He was into all sorts of paranormal nuttines. He trotted out the overused idea that of course UFOs are piloted by aliens, after all: "With all the stars in the universe, who are we to believe that there is no alien life?"

He was combining two different arguments: UFOs are from other planets, and that there is a high likelihood that there is other life out there. He also misused Drake's Equation, which builds conjecture on top of conjecture, coming to the conclusion that aliens exit essentially because the odds are in their favor.

And, sure as the sun rises, he trotted out "Sure, it's all wild stories, but what if some of it was true?" Well yes, maybe. But where's the evidence? "What if" is nice when writing a story, but it doesn't cut it for science.

As it always does when I meet new people, I tell them about my father's Near Death Experience. They both gave me their whole attention, but immediately lost interest when there were no angels, bright lights, and so on.

The second thing I always mention about my dad was that he fought in WW2, in the 42nd infantry, Rainbow division. I build it up with "His division captured a small German town. You might have heard of it. That town's name was Dachau." He looked confused. "The concentration camps" I said. "Oh, yeah" he replied.

Does anyone see anything wrong with this? He knew so much about stuff that didn't exist, but he had little knowledge about a very important part of our history.

The day turned into evening, and finally she was moved in. The both of them shook hands with me, giving the usual "It was nice meeting you," which everyone does when meeting new people. It means nothing, but we all feel obligated to do it. He added "I look forward to talking to you again."

Well now! If nothing else, I should have lots of material for further dispatches.

Robotbuilder 7 Nov 4
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

3 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

When someone offers conversation, it's not usually a good idea or good mannered to immediately insult them whether you think the show or it's advocates are "pure crap" or not. Just saying. There is a way to entertain people and give your opinion without pretty much telling them they're idiots. Especially when you first meet them and they did no such thing to you.

I would say the probability of aliens is in favor of them existing too. Stating it as fact isn't accurate though. People who believe we are the only beings in the universe remind me of religious people who believe the same thing because we were "created in God's image". Because of that they think that aliens existing would mean God is a lie etc.

The Drake Equation is flawed, but the Fermi Paradox is also flawed.

As to Von Daniken and Ancient Aliens, I don't remember a lot from watching the show, but a lot if not all of it is sensationalized. Who would have thought a tv show was looking for ratings, huh?

0

Now we know why she needs her comforting service dog! Seriously, though, this could be applied to many of us. I'm not one to go on and on about my atheism but I sometimes feel people perceive me the same way when I mention that I'm "good without a god". You and your neighbors have some interesting conversations ahead of you!

1

lol sad in its way.

before i forget... you may want to use the edit feature and get rid of some of the repetition! i mean like whole paragraphs and sequences of paragraphs. i know you didn't mean to do that.

just a side note, an official service dog won't be jumping in anyone's lap but casually we may refer to dogs who comfort the anxious as service dogs.

the boyfriend sounds like an idiot. i'd keep an eye on her to make sure he's not an abuser too. sound wild? maybe. just a hunch.

g

I wouldn't call him an idiot. He seemed very intelligent. He's just decided to fill his mind with crap.

They seem nice enough. People are like Polaroid photographs: over time, more details come out, until you get a complete picture. It is a strange relationship: her, quiet and nervous, and him, very outgoing.

@Robotbuilder but who fills one's own mind with crap? maybe not always but often that would be an idiot! i leave it to you to judge as i am only going by what you said. i hope they ARE nice and i hope he's NOT an idiot; maybe you can educate him. he certainly hasn't educated himself.

g

You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:215491
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.