What do you say when someone sneezes? When you sneeze and they "God bless you" Is no thank you an appropriate response? ????
Saying "God bless you" after someone sneezes is a custom from beliefs thousands of years old.
But I don't think about it because I've been in Thailand since 2010, and it's not the custom here at all.
 birdingnut
                                                
                                                Level 8
                                                Feb 8, 2018
                                            
                                                
                                                    birdingnut
                                                
                                                Level 8
                                                Feb 8, 2018                                            
                                        There's a really long and recent thread on that around here somewhere. Short answer, I think "No thank you" would be a very rude and mean-spirited response. Saying nothing is better than that. But, simply saying "thanks" works for your fellow human being who really is not proselytizing in that situation. JMO.
 BlueWave
                                                
                                                Level 8
                                                Feb 8, 2018
                                            
                                                
                                                    BlueWave
                                                
                                                Level 8
                                                Feb 8, 2018                                            
                                        I usually say gesundheit or bless you. I don't have a problem with anyone saying God bless you as I know it comes from a good place. They believe and I don't and as long as I'm respected I will respect. If someone is wishing me well or thinking of me and expresses it through their faith it's fine with me. I only have a problem if they try to force their faith on me.
 Betty
                                                
                                                Level 9
                                                Feb 8, 2018
                                            
                                                
                                                    Betty
                                                
                                                Level 9
                                                Feb 8, 2018                                            
                                        Not an issue for me.
sneeze
"bless you."
sneeze
bless you
sneeze
"SHAADDAAP!!!"
Perfectly reasonable.
 Hicks66
                                                
                                                Level 7
                                                Feb 8, 2018
                                            
                                                
                                                    Hicks66
                                                
                                                Level 7
                                                Feb 8, 2018                                            
                                        I do 2 "bless you"... the third is always... "Die"
I just say bless you. I see it as being polite and to trivial too worry about...but I have thought about it.
 Fearlessfreep
                                                
                                                Level 7
                                                Feb 8, 2018
                                            
                                                
                                                    Fearlessfreep
                                                
                                                Level 7
                                                Feb 8, 2018                                            
                                        That's the way I see it, just a polite way to acknowledge. I think it has been used so much that it really has lost its original meaning.
Man, my inner grammar nazi must be off. I'm fucking up my too tos twoday
I just smile & thank them. It's just them trying to be conventionally polite & not worth a potentially negative conversation.
I'll actually say it myself (just a simple 'bless you' sans a deity statement) to others for the same reason.
Much like if someone wishes me a Merry Christmas,... it's not innately offensive or aggressive from most people.
 KurtZeller
                                                
                                                Level 5
                                                Feb 8, 2018
                                            
                                                
                                                    KurtZeller
                                                
                                                Level 5
                                                Feb 8, 2018                                            
                                        I don't get offended either. I regularly say Merry Christmas, but usually someone says it first and I just respond.
Saying, "bless you" lost it's religious significance very, very long ago. The superstition was that sneezing gave the devil an opportunity to enter the sneezer's body, so blessing them was protection against demonic possession. Today it's more a social convention than a protection against evil; a polite gesture more than anything else, therefore if someone says it to me I simply thank them for the acknowledgement. It costs nothing and avoids unnecessary conflict.
 Druthewriter
                                                
                                                Level 5
                                                Feb 8, 2018
                                            
                                                
                                                    Druthewriter
                                                
                                                Level 5
                                                Feb 8, 2018                                            
                                        Gesundheit.
It was borrowed from German, where it literally means "health"; it was formed by a combination of gesund ("healthy" ) and -heit ("-hood" ). Wishing a person good health when they sneezed was traditionally believed to forestall the illness that a sneeze often portends.
 shockwaverider
                                                
                                                Level 8
                                                Feb 8, 2018
                                            
                                                
                                                    shockwaverider
                                                
                                                Level 8
                                                Feb 8, 2018                                            
                                        I avoid participating in that ridiculous medieval superstition. No one's heart stops when they sneeze. There are no demons to take over the un-stopped heart of the sneezer.
If I feel like I'll suffer socially for not having the "good manners" to perpetuate this farce when someone else sneezes, I'll say "Gesundheit": "good health."
If I get a "God bless you" to my sneeze, I'll acknowledge it as minimally and wordlessly as possible. It's just considered manners these days, and I don't want to be seen as rude.
 stinkeye_a
                                                
                                                Level 8
                                                Feb 8, 2018
                                            
                                                
                                                    stinkeye_a
                                                
                                                Level 8
                                                Feb 8, 2018                                            
                                        I have always said "sneeze you", and passed that on to my kids; as socially there are common norms that you HAVE to say something, so i picked the most secular thing I could think of. As for someone else saying it, I think the sentiment is completely unnecessary, but like a sneeze, it's somewhat involuntary in most cultures.
 Brbaldwin
                                                
                                                Level 7
                                                Feb 8, 2018
                                            
                                                
                                                    Brbaldwin
                                                
                                                Level 7
                                                Feb 8, 2018                                            
                                        Lol. I've been told it's rude not to say bless you. I asked that person, even an atheist who doesn't believe in blessings? She didn't know how to respond, but I could tell by the look on her face that she wanted to say something she knew would be offensive. I enjoyed that moment.
I say nothing when someone sneezes, unless I have a kleenex and they need one. When someone says bless you to me, I say thanks. Their intention is good, and I take it that way.
I've been asked why I don't say it by people who don't know I'm an atheist, and I respond "I'm not superstitious"
 AuntieMame
                                                
                                                Level 6
                                                Feb 8, 2018
                                            
                                                
                                                    AuntieMame
                                                
                                                Level 6
                                                Feb 8, 2018                                            
                                        Salud or gesundheit.
I doesn't matter to me what anyone says when I sneeze. Habits are habits and I have heard staunch atheists say, "Bless you."
 evidentialist
                                                
                                                Level 8
                                                Feb 8, 2018
                                            
                                                
                                                    evidentialist
                                                
                                                Level 8
                                                Feb 8, 2018                                            
                                        I think that you have forced me to rethink that remark...I do it myself! But, it really does not express what I mean! I am wishing them, 'well,' but I think I will find another way to do that!
 Freedompath
                                                
                                                Level 9
                                                Feb 8, 2018
                                            
                                                
                                                    Freedompath
                                                
                                                Level 9
                                                Feb 8, 2018                                            
                                        I say "Excuse me." Like you would say excuse me if you had to burp, or if you were talking to someone and needed to step away or turn your body to cough, you'd say "excuse me." So when I sneeze, I say excuse me.
 Funnygir175
                                                
                                                Level 7
                                                Feb 13, 2018
                                            
                                                
                                                    Funnygir175
                                                
                                                Level 7
                                                Feb 13, 2018                                            
                                        It’s harmless, no need to meet it with harm.
 Funandfondles
                                                
                                                Level 6
                                                Feb 8, 2018
                                            
                                                
                                                    Funandfondles
                                                
                                                Level 6
                                                Feb 8, 2018                                            
                                        When someone says "God bless you", when you sneeze, or at most any other time, they are just being polite as they were taught. You can safely bet that they have no malicious intent so why become a black-eye on agnostics by saying anything other than: Thank you very much.
 msimpson9agn
                                                
                                                Level 5
                                                Feb 8, 2018
                                            
                                                
                                                    msimpson9agn
                                                
                                                Level 5
                                                Feb 8, 2018