Agnostic.com

9 2

Is this why the Bible, Torah and Quran ban Bacon?
The following is the final argument that allowed me to finally drop any remaining pretense of belief.

Reality is Absolute, this is the explicit recognition of the primacy of existence. Reality is not subject to hopes wishes dreams or prayers. Contradictions don't exist in reality because reality simply is as it is and does not contradict itself. Only our evaluations of reality can contradict each other.
If the content of your knowledge contains contradictions, then some of your knowledge is in error. Because in order to be successful in reality one must know reality, success requires correct knowledge. It is therefore important to continually search for and root out contradictions in your knowledge in order to make sure that your knowledge corresponds to reality.
hmmmmm (Francis) Bacon!

Rugglesby 8 Feb 15
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

9 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

A lot of kosher dietary laws were started way back when food preparation and storage was not sanitary, or so I've heard. Over time it became doctrine. Hey, I was raised Jewish and I still don't get it. Not when one of our staple cuisines was Chinese take-out, which contains considerable amounts of [drum roll]: pork and shelfish.

1

Yes! let's get real. amen (just reclaiming language 😀 ).

0

Sorry guys, it is my warped way of thinking, the reference was to Francis Bacon, it is his quote I posted. and it is the comments re contradictions that finally freed me from my Christian upbringing, there are too many contradictions with the Bible and between it and the reality I experience. His idea that reality must be free of contradiction means the bible and therefore my religion were what was flawed.

are you calling me warped? It made since to me, probably because I came to the same conclusion in a different way.

2

I'm saying they ban pigs and hogs because they didn't know about denutting them to remove the stink from the meat. I'm sure they would be eatting pig every day if they knew this secret...

My wife had me fixed....I only oink occasionally....Is she trying to get me fat for a reason?

@DavidLaDeau. Yes.... lol.

1

The torah does not specifically ban the eating of pigs as such. Just says that animals should have cloven hooves and chew the cud. It is possible to breed a Kosher pig (a la that great film " Leon the pig farmer " ) but I doubt it would make it to any rabbis dinner table. Many have made the point about pork in hot climates as a reason for the ban. I would also look at a pigs diet. Like us they are omnivorous and are quite sentient animals. Most of us would baulk at the thought of eating dog. As Churchill said " Cats look down on us, dogs look up to us. only pigs treat us as equals ".

2

They really just want to save it all for their Hawaiian pizzas.

godef Level 7 Feb 15, 2018
0

Your thinking sounds like it's lifted at least partly from Objectivism. While I agree that most seeming contradictions reflect limits of our cognition, I do think some of those limits are inherent. The real problem is that there's no such thing as 100% certainty on any topic (though many things are 99.999% certain, and others certain enough to be of practical utility). People of good conscience are going to disagree on priorities and have different perspectives about many topics, so it's a fool's errand to try to demonstrate you're objectively "right" about most anything. You can accomplish a great deal by confining your arguments to obvious benefits and harms and facts and figures but that doesn't change that many people fear change and oppose it as a matter of course.

I agree with the other commenters, there's a basis in reality for the prohibition on pork, and at that point in history I'm willing to bet the only way to get widespread conformance to this rule was to make it a divine edict.

2

So true, a rock is more in touch with reality than any human.

you rock!

thank you xx so do you

2

Hate to be the bearer of bad news but the provision against pork IS rooted in fact. If you think about the nomadic tribes that wrote the talmud , which is the basis of our Bible, they were Nomadic Desert dwellers. If you've ever heard of trichinosis, you know eating pork in a desert is a really bad idea! Also, pigs are omnivores. They are not grazers and cannot sustain themselves on browse. So, they are actually taking food from the tribe dwellers. Sorry, but this one prohibition is very much rooted in fact.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:24639
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.