Agnostic.com

13 1

Just how important is it to you - if you are in the dating world - that potential suitors have the same attitudes as your own? Specifically in the arena of religion, or lack of religion? Recently I was talking to my daughter about a man with whom I had corresponded, and mentioned that he was christian. Her immediate response was "NO mother, you cannot date him!", with the explanation that eventually it would become an issue. I agreed, I feel too strongly about atheism (or whatever one wishes to call it). What do you think??

Rustee 7 Dec 30
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

13 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

1

Some days are harder than others. One of my biggest problems is not holding my hand over my own mouth as i point out the religious foundations and fallacies in everyday expressions, customs, amd items, while dating someone who is religious

1

here are couple here that have married,and it seems to work,just as in politics,never discussed in the home,my late wife and I were of the opposite parties,and got along very well,she voted for one,I did the other. Date him and see,if his views overpower yours,then move on.....

0

Charming chatter fritters away the hours while Atheists can hear uncluttered thoughts unafraid of hell fires nor rebuffed heaven briberies. ...why would any self respecting woman want 4 maybe 6 alleged holy ones in your bed AT ONCE geebush Jehobah ghostHOLES Miriam & Joseph gang banging you ?

NO ONE is gang-banging me, thank you very little!

@Rustee sex with xians declare that delusion of Mother Mary Joseph Angels Demons alleged magical beings in the bed head of believers

@Rustee the PROVERBIAL you considering love with xians in their heads

1

I could probably fake it (belief) for a really good kisser. ?

2

It would not work for me. If I can't respect his views on something as basic as whether or not a god exists, then it's unlikely we would find common ground. While I tend not to do so publicly, I do show open disdain for theism on my own turf.

Deb57 Level 8 Dec 31, 2018
1

Depends. I think it could work with an atheist and someone that is christian, but not religious. I can get along with believers and even respect their belief if they don't try to force their belief on me. But, that prolly wouldnt be the case with "holy roller bible thumper"

Yes, a bible-thumper would not fit with my life and my choices!

2

If I were interested in hookups, I wouldn't care so much about religious views or political positions or economic stances, but for anything with long-term potential I need there to be a reasonable proximity between our values. It doesn't need to be an echo chamber in our relationship, but there can't be a huge chasm.

2

I can't say impossible but yeah, incredibly unlikely for it to work out with a believer for a staunch atheist. I would have to get over a fundamental disrespect of their intelligence level and they would have to get over a firm belief that I'm damned. And one of those concerns is even valid in reality!

4

Faith, or the lack thereof, seems to be pretty central to one's identity so I would think for most of us would be hard to date someone who was devout. However, my mother was a believer and my Dad was an agnostic and as long as he was willing to put on a coat and tie and go to Church with her, she was ok about it. They were married 55 years until her death. Dad is still agnostic but enjoys going to church from time to time just because he finds a good sermon to be thought-provoking.

I like that. Nothing wrong with respecting an opinion thats different than ur own.

Your father sounds to be a good man! I could never attend a church service with someone, so anyone that 'devout' would not be a good match. Thanks for your thoughts, though!

2

When I was dating, I found that a lot of men listed their religion as "Christian" but hadn't really thought about religion in decades, it's just the religion they grew up with. Therefore, upon realizing I'm staunchly non-religious, they would admit they are not religious either.

My thought is that by listing themselves as "Christian" those men might feel they would get a more docile, subservient woman as a mate. Well, that's not me! "Next!"

I'd rather have a guy who has actually thought about whether they are religious or a free thinker or whatever, and commits to that. If really committed to Christianity, they would be trying to convert me. Never going to happen - I say that up front. So, again, "next!"

If a guy can't think for himself about whether there is a sky daddy or not, then I'd rather not waste my time.

Those men are simply taking the most convenient path and playing the %s in their profiles by listing themselves as Christian, which maybe tells you some other things about them. Like, for one thing, they haven't really looked at themselves much, and two, they are being somewhat deceptive with women on the site by labeling themselves somewhat falsely to attract the largest group of potential women.

I see what yall r saying. But, i also think theres a christian/believer and a religious person.

2

It depends on whether or not they have respect for your boundaries or 'persuasive intent' and how strongly they believe in their duty to preach or share the 'word of God'. Though I have not dated in a long time it has been 50/50 with friendships. I was surprised by mennonite and amish friends who are very christian but have never attempted to change me. Not sure you could date them however.

4

It depends how religious they are. I left a 17 year marriage because my husband found jeebus. I’m not going down that road again.

5

"Just don't try to convert me," I say. If they hassle me about my atheism, I show them the door.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:255569
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.