I raised my kids in the church. One is flat out an atheist, one is a none married to a catholic, and one is keeping daddy happy by going to church, and I really don't know what her outlook is. But it gives her a social life and a way to keep music in her life (she is the pianist), so she keeps it up. She and her family live with Daddy so keeping him happy is kinda important.

I could not agree more. Congratulations to and your daughter! It clearly means your thinking was clear.

Raising a godless daughter (who is successful beyond my expectations) is what I consider my proudest achievement. I did that especially after coming from a very conservative background, relatives and extended family.I don't know what she will believe in later in life but so far so good.

Happy birthday to your daughter.
I taught my kids to question and critical thinking. Do not just accept what someone tells them

Happy birthday to her.

All people are different and in your quest for what I call "religious reality" you tried a different faith. Many people do this. In my case I understood that I would not be Pentecostal if I was born in Iran. Stubborn believers just do not understand this statement at all.

I’ve got ‘one of those,’ too, 25 (& 27). Raised Atheist, if unknowingly; I passed on what I knew. Also used ‘the atheist primer’ book/s to help explain religion. We’re unconditionally solid, and they definitely make life beyond worth living - worth lasting!

Happy birthday to the young lady, and my daughter had gone through a similar thing with Christianity to Judaism

Happy Birthday to your girl.