Agnostic.com

2 0

How Come Civilization? Why Creation? Part One

Modern human beings went from a relatively simple hunter-gatherer existence over a rather long-term, in fact quite lengthy time frame, then, in a rather all-of-a-sudden time frame, we settled down and acquired what we’d all accept as living as a collective civilization or as civilized societies. Why did the transition happen and so suddenly after such a long incubation period? What makes us unique? Was it just good old Mother Nature, or was there a special guiding hand – or tentacle or claw as the case may be perhaps.

Modern humans (Homo sapiens) existed as an uncultured, uncivilized nomadic entity for most of humanity’s time on Earth. Then whoosh, within an incredible short period of time, apart from isolated pockets, our nomadic days were over and we settled down to a civilized and cultured existence, which continues right through to this 21st Century. But there’s something very odd about that. Why did it take so long? Why then did the transition happen so quickly? Why do mythologies throughout the world tend to credit the gods for this transition when we all know the polytheistic gods don’t exist?

Modern humans, Homo sapiens (Latin for ‘wise man’ or ‘knowing man&rsquo😉 have existed as a separate species, originating in Africa, with all associated anatomical and related mental faculties in tact, for about 200,000 to 400,000 years. All modern behavioural characteristics have been evident in the fossil and archaeological records from about 50,000 years ago, like Palaeolithic cave art and the practice of burying the dead.

Human culture or civilization blossomed not in the heart of Africa where modern humans evolved, but in the Middle East. Why not Africa? I would have thought that at first glance Africa was a more environmentally habitat than the Middle East. There was ample enough time, yet apart from ancient Egypt, Africa isn’t associated with early civilizations. Perhaps that’s just an historical mystery that’s bound to remain a mystery.

The earliest origin of what we’d call settlement civilization happened roughly 10,000 years ago, though the first real city-states didn’t come into their own, like Mesopotamia, Egypt’s Nile Valley and the Indus Valleys until about 6000 years ago. So, for most of our time on Earth, we were hunter-gatherers going wherever the flow took us. If civilization and established communities and domestication over plants and animals were such a good idea, why did it take so long for the ‘eureka’ moment to strike? If you have an hour to complete a maths exam with one question, ‘how much is 2 + 2?’, and you only figured it out after 50 minutes, then you hardly qualify as an Einstein. Well we figured out civilization 50 minutes after the one hour time limit start button was pushed, but to add to the mystery, at 49 minutes into the test, we still hadn’t a clue. It’s almost as if we received some outside help at nearly the last minute - but outside help from whom?

According to mythologies around the world, the gods gave the gifts of culture and civilization to ancient human societies.

The Near East: There are various divine bringers of culture associated with Near East mythology. These divine gods were credited with cultural advancements, such as the development of agriculture and animal husbandry as well as the creation of sophisticated urban culture. Various myths suggested that cultural accomplishments were gifts from the gods.

The Egyptians: As a scribe of the gods, the ibis-headed god known as Thoth was viewed by the Egyptians as the inventor of all spoken and written languages.

The Greeks: The Greek goddess Demeter taught humankind agriculture. The Greek goddess Athena taught the Greeks how to cook and sew. Along with fire, the Greek god Prometheus gave people the mechanical arts, sciences, and wisdom.

China: At the centre of the world lay China, the ‘middle kingdom’ which was ruled by gods. These gods created China’s inhabitants and taught them arts and skills. The first heavenly rulers also provided their subjects with technologies essential to life. Each invention – such as cooking, writing, medicine, the wheel, the fishing net and the plow – was credited to a specific deity. The Chinese god Shennong invented the plow and taught people how to farm.

Africa: A cultural hero brings to a group of people the skills necessary for survival. Like in many cultures throughout the world, the cultural hero in African lore is a mythological figure who brings monumental change to his people, through invention and discovery. Gifts brought by these heroes were often the knowledge needed to farm, hunt, and build.

The gods are also the law givers. An obvious case in point is the monotheistic God and His Ten Commandments.

The gods gave humans all these things but we all know there are no gods (including God) so that must mean that humans came up with all these things all by themselves. But if that’s the case why doesn’t human history record this in the same way that history records Edison (for example) with lots of inventions instead of attributing human inventions, human culture, and human civilization to nonexistent gods? That makes no real sense at all.

However, while the gods might not be real, the ‘gods’ could be – ‘gods’ cleverly disguised as gods, but ultimately revealed as extraterrestrials. Extraterrestrials would just about automatically qualify as deities to primitive earthlings who had no concept of life on other planets.

Now all the extraterrestrial ‘gods’ really needed to do was just give us our first kindergarten lessons and that alone would have kick-started us on our way, eventually to land up on the Moon, hunting and gathering those rocks to take back to Earth. It’s like the child attending school. In the beginning the child is spoon-fed all knowledge, but pretty soon the ability to find things out by him (or her) self kicks in.

The question is, what’s so special about us that we and we alone as a terrestrial species have actually reached out and touched the Moon? Homo sapiens alone as a terrestrial species have advanced intelligence, technology, and overall that nebulous concept called civilization. The evolution of technology isn’t inevitable and has a lot of just-so factors attached; ditto civilization. I’ve speculated that the latter two were kick-started by the ‘gods’, the extraterrestrials. What about our intelligence? Might our intellectual abilities ultimately prove to be another gift from the ‘gods’?

IMHO, intelligence, the ability to figure things out, has evolutionary survival value and will tend to be selected for, and thus over time, there will tend to have evolved life forms with ever higher IQ’s. Here on Earth, just about all mammals and birds, and some exceptional invertebrates (the cephalopods like squid and the octopus), have reasonable IQ’s at least when compared to bacteria, plants, insects, fish, etc. Of course just as some kinds of organisms are faster than others, or have keener senses of sight or smell or hearing, not all advanced organisms are going to end up equal in the IQ stakes. But, the fact remains, the ability to think, to figure things out, can only increase your odds of survival and leaving behind more offspring.

However, if the evolution of intelligence were the be-all-and-end-all to ensuring survival and being fruitful and multiplying, then your everyday household moggy would be catching mice through pure intellectual genius and setting down mousetraps – and the mice avoiding the cat by figuring out what the cat was planning!

No, there are many evolutionary pathways to success and survival and reproducing. In the case of the moggy, evolving faster reflexes, being able to run faster for longer durations, evolving ever more acute hearing and vision – well that’s probably going to ultimately catch more mice than pure brainpower.

So, yes, intelligence will be selected for, but that trait is in serious competition with other traits in terms of ensuring that you live long and prosper. Just like there are many roles or occupations humans play and work at in society, not all roles or occupations are equal in ensuring success and longevity, yet maximizing whatever abilities you have at least give you the maximum odds that whatever role or occupation you have will ensure you have the maximum chance of living long and living in prosperity.

However, we’re not just slightly ahead in the IQ stakes, but proverbial light-years ahead. We’d be hard-pressed to imagine any other terrestrial species remotely accomplishing through sheer brain-power alone something akin to the most primitive of our cave art or even picking up and chucking rocks at an enemy.

In the time since the arrival of the ‘modern’ human, Homo sapiens, all our other primate relations, the great apes and monkeys, etc. haven’t moved one centimetre closer to reaching the Moon, or for that matter, any of the other hundreds of thousands of ‘advanced’ or complex life forms currently inhabiting Planet Earth.

If Homo sapiens vanished off the face of the Earth today, what odds would you give that our closest evolutionary cousins, the chimps and/or baboons and/or gorillas and/or any of the old or new world monkeys would be the next terrestrial species to land on the Moon, however far into the future you’d care to speculate?

johnprytz 7 Apr 13
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

2 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

I have watched a few documentaries that suggest the sudden shift from hunter-gatherer nomads to sedentary agrarians was facilitated by rapid climate change forcing people to populate the fertile crescent in the Middle East. That, and the accidental discovery of what happened to seeds when tossed into the compost pile with the rest of the waste, and experimentation with deliberately breeding only the hardiest of grains. The precursor to our modern wheat was scarcely more than overgrown grass - nothing even close to what it is today. I think it just made practical sense once agriculture was developed to a point where it could sustain fairly large populations, and humans had learned to domesticate the big 5 farm animals (cattle, sheep, pigs, horses, and goats). This occurred in a relatively short period of time over the modern human evolutionary time line.

@johnprytz Read the first part - it's critical. A rapid change in climate between 10,000 and 13,000 years ago kind of forced our ancestors to start adopting a different approach. And I am not sure where you read that constantly moving from place to place hunting and scavnging is easier and a more stable food supply that allows for larger populations and specialization, but I would love to see the sources.

@johnprytz It's pretty obvious you haven't devoted much time to learning about this development. Just from the limited reading I have done, and the documentaries I have watched, there doesn't seem to be much debate over why and when humans shifted to agriculture. I think the debate is mostly in your own head at this point.

@johnprytz Sorry for getting short. I need to work on that flaw in my character.

You raise a good question, and I don't know if the experts have decided on a theory. I studied accounting, finance, and economics, and only took a handful of science courses, so my background here is rather limited. However, I have heard of the 100th monkey effect. Perhaps it may be a partial explanation? Or maybe a transition to an agrarian society is an inevitable phase of human societal development? This would be an excellent question to pose in the anthropology & archaelogy group. Some of the members are actual scientists in the field, and may be a ble to help shed a lot more light on the topic than I ever could.

@johnprytz As I said, I really don't know. I have never studied the question - it's completely outside of my area. Everything I "know" about the topic, I either learned in school, read for myself, or saw on a documentary. Which basically means I am wholly unqualified to weigh in on how or why it happened. My best guess? It's either a natural progression in the evolution of societies, or there's the 100th monkey effect.

This would be a great question to post in this group: [agnostic.com]

Some of the memebrs are actually scholars and scientists. There's a decent chance one of them could answer authoritatively, or at least point you in the right direction for an answer.

@johnprytz There is a specific group just for them, or at least for those with more than a passing interest in anthropology and archaeology. I doubt anyone but you and I are even reading this far into the comments.

@johnprytz I still think it's worth considering posting it in the Anthropology & Archaeology group. I'm fairly certain it would get very well-informed, high quality, authoratative responses from actual scientists.

1

Why do lemmings run over cliffs ? not intentionally but because they are too successful at breeding and eat themselves out of house and home and are looking for pastures new.. Why did Homo Sapiens leave Africa ? Probably for the same reason. They probably hunted the game to extinction and moved to find pastures new.

Why did they adopt agriculture ?. Probably for the same reason

@johnprytz What? no divine GPS like Moses had. The adoption of agriculture ?, I think we have been regretting it ever since and the last remaining few hunter gatherer tribes are desperately trying to hang on to their way of life.

@johnprytz I want Washington to work for family farmers again, not just for the agribusiness executives pocketing multi-million dollar bonuses or the Wall Street traders sitting at their desks speculating on the price of commodities."

Above is a comment by Elizabeth Warren.

We are used to cheap food and to hell with the consequences.

@johnprytz Certainly during WW2 a lot more food was grown by people in their gardens and redundant land was used for crop growing. Apparently with rationing the population was healthier than ever.

Fast forward to a few years ago we had something called "setaside" in The EU where farmers were paid to leave land uncultivated because we were producing too much food.

We are now so used to buying cheap supermarket chicken and pigmeat from factory farms with dubious welfare standards and processed food which tends to be unhealthy and nearly always has palm oil as an ingredient. Palm oil grown on what was rainforest in Brazil

People are not going to give that up readily but climate change may force them to do it.

You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:330048
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.