Who believes in second chances in romantic relationships?
From experience it has never worked for me.
I have performed several weddings for couples who were married to each other before, divorced, and then re-married each other again, after working things out.
I have performed many more weddings for divorced couples who found love with new partners, so are on their 2nd (or more) marriages. Many of the vows I hear say things like "I never thought I'd have a second chance at love, but then I found you!"
So, if the second chance is a fresh start, or the timing is right, whereas previously it was wrong, then sure!
If your question is love after a betrayal or breech of trust, a second chance is possible, but my experience is that it's going to be guarded and conditional and not nearly as happy and ecstatic as it once was, but perhaps comfortable if you like settling for something like that. The betrayal will always be there mixed into the foundation, like a body buried under the floor.
No. Once a man betrays me or acts abusive or mean, I can never trust him again. I don't care what he says.
It is foolish to fall in love with a man's potential or hope he will change. The only person I can control and change is myself.