Agnostic.com

8 1

Hello everyone my name is sultan
I was a Muslim but now I think that I'm a agnostic for not getting the right answer to my questions from the muslims so please everyone i really need help here because if anyone tells
the muslims that I have converted to be a agnostic than they will execute me for living islam.

Sultan-Baloch 2 Nov 19
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

8 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

I am truly happy to see all these replies
But I am trying to do my best to not let anyone
Know that I am a agnostic now
And in case you all ar wandering we're I am
In Kingdom of saudi arabia !
The penalty for living islam is death by sword
And my biggest problem is that I have a family
And I am broke i can't even leave to any country
Is there any other way to solve my problem
I would really appreciate.

0

I thinnk you should try to leave to go to a country where they can't (at least legally) do that. Some countries offer asylum for people fleeing death. Unfortunately, although the U.S. was once one of those countries, with our current leadership, although it may still be possible, it would a a lot harder.

BTW, you don't actually convert to agnosticism or atheism, as neither is a religion. The correct terminology for your situation is "lost (or losing) faith".

If any Muslims question you, explain that you are have started to have doubts due to poor answers you received and withdrew so that you would not inadvertently create any doubts for other Muslims. Assure them that you are studying and praying on your own for answers (whether or not you actually are).

Please realize that the above advise comes from a position of ignorance, wher I'd have to imagine myself in similar circumstances without knowing what they actually would be. If you find any of it helpful or useful, then great, But, you know your local culture and customs better than i do, so if anything I said above is useful adapt ir appropriately to best insure your survival.

0

it's more of a realization that we are insignificant and should get on with helping others around us to enjoy life without guilt or fear. Just say nothing to them and take the prayer moment as a short meditation combined with yoga ! [ it's good for you ]

0

welcome. seems to be a fair number of people visiting this page with the same concerns.

0

People of many different religious beliefs, who we label devote, are not. Belief/religion is always changing/evolving in each individual's heart as we educate ourselves and experience life.
Your hard journey is shared by many.
Good Luck and may you find peace here.

mzee Level 7 Nov 19, 2017
1

I'd be happy to answer any questions you have.

2

Welcome! You will find we are a friendly, supportive group of people here who will help in any way we can.

0
  1. What questions? That seems like brainwashing and cult-behavior
  2. What can we do to help?
  3. I assume you mean 'leaving' [the culture of] Islam. And if you're in a place where they will hunt you down and kill you for your religion... it may not be easy, but it would likely be safest for you in the long run to... you know... move.
Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:4275
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.