Agnostic.com

3 6

Medpage just published the results of a poll of its readers on the prickly topic of euthanasia.

Here is the link [medpagetoday.com]

last week, you voted on whether or not to euthanize a resistant dementia patient. Here are the results from more than 5,100 votes:

Do you proceed with the lethal injection?

Yes: 750

No: 4,440
Does your answer change if the patient wrote a subsequent letter, effectively nullifying her original instructions?

Yes: 1,359

No: 3,770

Do you consult with the patient's medical power of attorney?

Yes: 3,908

No: 1266


Euthanasia, "the good death" is one of the topics that I find difficult to discuss logically. I know what I would do for myself but cannot fathom having to make the decision for another in my care. Dementia is a disease that strips personality and awareness away from the patient and leaves something else behind, to be cared for until natural death occurs? I shudder to think that would be me in that hospital bed, dependent on the ethical slant of the doctor in charge of my life.

Spinliesel 9 Dec 17
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

3 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

2

I was my father's caregiver for over eight years of Alzheimer's. He was a very intelligent man (Member of Mensa), so the disease was especially cruel for him. He also believed strongly in the right to die with dignity (He was a member of the Hemlock Society), but in Kansas we do not have that right.

He was an otherwise very healthy man, so he endured long after his quality of life had dwindled away. He died alone in middle of the night in a poorly run nursing home. I sincerely wish I could have helped him find his way out.

I am so sorry to hear of your dad's long way into death. I fear something like that for me, so I have made a pact with my grandson. I hope he will still be in my life when my time runs out.

1

Its hard to find people who are willing to make the decisions but they need to be made.
We think "putting down" a suffering pet is the most loving thing to do, but we think extending the life of someone who is suffering, or has become a non-person-they-were, is wrong. Thats a part of humanity we need to overcome.

2

Wow. My dad died three years ago from complications of ALZ. We got "lucky" in that a kidney infection took hold, otherwise I can only imagine how bad it would have gotten. He had a severe case of Capgras Syndrome, which made it even more of a challenge. It led my daughter and I into many conversations of how and at what point I would want her to do something - or help me do something - should I develop it. Detailed, open and honest communication seems to be the only way to deal with it.

You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:439141
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.