Agnostic.com

11 3

Saying 'I'll pray for you' is not black and white for me. I always, always think praying for anyone or anything is a total waste of time and mental energy so here's what I'm on about.

Later this week I have to have tests for a medical condition that seems to be getting worse. (The nature of the condition is not relevant here). My condition and the forthcoming tests are scaring me somewhat and this became apparent yesterday to a new colleague who I am guessing is 19 or 20 years old. She and I have developed a good rapport and she has given me some lovely genuine supporting comments, which she finished off with (you have guessed this) I'll pray for you. My first thought was 'please don't' but I couldn't say it because the moral support she is providing is great and this is not the right time to place any kind of barrier between us. She is helping me to get a better perspective on my situation. Yes I am still scared but she is helping me to deal with it. She's not the only one doing this but she is the only one bringing prayer in.

I think what I'm trying to say is - I should choose the time to discuss prayer and related topics very carefully and not judge a person because of their perceived relationship with a deity.

I just want to put that thought out there. Thank you for reading this.

Sandster 7 Feb 9
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

11 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

I have siblings who do the same ; I interpret as wishing me well and keeping me in thier thoughts. I do not judge others
with a simpler view of life ; at the same time I MAINTAIN
my boundries of whether to vest myself in thier beliefs
(I do not). A kind act -giving support; is a kind act.

0

Then it has become more for her benefit and not yours.

It reminds me of my young niece and nephew, they sincerely want to help with some project but end up asking a lot of questions they have no answers for and usually get in the way and cause the project to take longer.

1

Since you don't believe, what does it hurt or matter? It is obvious she cares about your welfare, and isn't that the important thing here?

1

I have some close friends who are very religious. In fact, they operate in urban Church. One of them has sat by me on more than one occasion when I've had outpatient surgeries and she has prayed for me both privately and openly. I never say a word about it. I think she does that for me in the same spirit with which she gives me rides to and from those appointments. There are probably things about me that she grits her teeth about too, But that's the way friends are.

1

Offering to pray for someone is for me, the most vainglorious and sanctimonious way of feeling good about oneself for doing fuck all.

2

You have a human being friend that cares about you. That is good! I think that is all that matters here.

2

My best friend is a Christian, and she prays for me when I'm facing any issues or problems. I don't mind that - she does it because she genuinely believes it will help, but more importantly she's there with more practical help and support too. It sounds to me like your colleague is much the same.

What I do object to is people who say "I'll pray for you" but then don't do anything else.

Jnei Level 8 Feb 9, 2020
1

This is a hard topic for me. Though I know there is no dog I allow other to believe what they want. If they offer good wishes to me I say thank you, What they are saying is I care about you and I hope all gets well with you. There is a time for religious conversation and there is a time for manners.

0

there was a time that it made me mad ... then uncomfortable ... and now just sad.

as for the prayer itself - does it help me? doubtful. but if done properly it may very well help the person praying. that's not to say they all do it properly. far from it. but it can be meditative and result in health benefits both mentally and physically.

so I just accept it for what it is - a nice, self-serving gesture on their part.

1

Many times it's sincere desire to help

3

I agree that judging someone because of their religious practices is not helpful.

I do not pray in the traditional way, as in pleading for favors from an objective god out there. However, I do engage in communion with the god within. The reason for that internal discussion is to gain peace and acceptance with respect to the world around me.

Good luck with your medical condition.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:457988
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.