Agnostic.com

22 5

I'm a Blade Runner nut. I have the five DVD ultimate collection. So, I was cagey to say the least about Blade Runner 2049. I finally watched it today. It put all of my reservations to rest. Moody and beautiful. I'd still take the original every time, but 2049 is a worth sequel. And that is saying something. Thoughts?

Palindromeman 7 Mar 30
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

22 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

3

IMHO, both Blade Runner films are sci-fi classics.

3

For some reason Blade Runner was one of my favourite childhood films. An odd choice for a kid, but I got into everything; the book, the video game, the various cuts and remasters that came over the years. 2049 actually worked, I enjoyed it far more than I expected to.

3

I can only enjoy the sequel when I think it's the forerunner of a series where people buck against such a horrendously money orientated and sexist system; but there was a hint of some strong female protagonists at the end. Bladerunner 1 was so ahead of it's time and is still so excellent, I don't think anything can beat it.

3

Thank you for the endorsement. The wife and I are remorseful to not have seen it at a theater.

Dick is one of my fave authors. Good to know this was not as stupid as the total recall remake fiasco.

Are you watching The Man in the High Castle? Amazon Studio's production values are superb.

Oh, believe me, after what Ridley Scott did to the Alien franchise (thusly introducing us all to the Prometheus School of Running Away From Things, FFS) I was deathly afraid of 2049. Sure, he wasn't directing but he was EP, which had me worried. As it turns out (and quite possibly because RS was not directing), 2049 feels right. I'm a huge PKD fan, so I should check out The Man in the High Castle. I loved the novel. Ditto the novel and film A Scanner Darkly.

2

Love Blade Runner writing a team project paper fir a film genre class and turning it into a musical Just a hoot I never cared for sci- fi until a year ago love it Will now see the new Blade Runner was hesitant

Wow! Blade Runner the musical? I can imagine Roy Batty belting out "I Want to be Free" by Queen.

2

Have you played the PC game? I liked it.

My gaming enthusiasm starts and ends with RPGs and cardboard and dice. I'm very lo fi.

1

Palindromeman- I think about that for days and wonder if it wasn't a "planted" memory

"All those moments will be lost in time, like tears in rain." Gets me every time I watch that film.

1

I did watch the directors cut first and then the narrative with Ford's voice- Liked it much better. It gave us an opportunity to use key phrases and turn them into a song. One of the team members wrote a song (required) It rocked. So much fun

I like them both. They are quite different cultural artefacts. And I am a sucker for film noir, so the voiceover version always worked for me. The key difference, of course, is what Gaff's unicorn origami means.

1

I just checked out the Blade Runner 2049 movie from the library today. Hoping it's going to be good.

1

I was wondering if I had to see it. Now, you have given the little push to do so. When I heard about a new Blade Runner, I was just like you. 1st, it's nearly impossible to beat the first one. It was so well done, so intricate and thoughtful... I knew it would be a tough movie to beat. But I was not expecting a fan of the original to say it is a worthy sequal. Especially to Blade Runner. Yes, NOW I have to see it.

1

I have it, but haven't watched it for the same reason. And someone I sorta trust told me she hated it. I'm gonna go on your word...don't screw me on this...hehe

It's slow; at two and a half hours, it is long. It could have used a decent edit. But 2049 does stay true to the feel of the original. Which I think is about as much as you can hope for. I thought Ryan Gosling as Blade Runner K was suitably shut down for the character he was playing.

1

Will have to watch it!

1

What is in the 5 DVD collection?

Now you're stretching me. The theatrical version (with narration), the director's cut (without narration), a rough cut (interesting in its own right) and a couple of other versions.

@Palindromeman The original directors cut is one of my favorite movies. I will check that out. Thanks.

1

That's rare. Sequels and remakes are frequently disappointing. Have you read the original story?

Indeed re sequels/remarkes. And, yes, I've read Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep. The original novel is another separate cultural artefact again. Interestingly, Hampton Fancher was the lead writer on both the original BR and 2049, which I think helps to explain the sense of continuity between the two films.

0

Saw the original dozens of times. saw the new one twice. I liked it, but I don't think it stsnds up to the original.

0

I want to see it

0

The movies are good? I've never seen them.

0

Excellent movie, I loved it.

0

I have tried to watch the original many times as I am a fan of Ridley Schott's work, But unfortunately I can't get into it. Its slow broody and for me quite boring. Visually stunning Yes. I want to watch it as I feel I'm missing something but the film won't grab me.

Watch the directors cut.

0

Blade Runner is one of my top 3 movies. The sequel? I hated it. No, I really f-ing hated it. It ranks as my top disappointing sequel ever. Almost as worthless as Howard the Duck which rates as the worst movie of all time.

0

I've the same boxed set.
I've the Blu Ray set as well.

Can quote nearly the entire movie from memory (Final Cut or Theatrical if you want the narrative).

I hated 2049.
Empty, soulless, dull--and not in the way BR was slow.
Just overly predictable and a hackneyed reboot--same as nearly any of the rebooted franchises we've seen.

0

I totally resent the Blade Runner movie, since, from then on, all dystopian movies are dark as though at night, with trashed buildings, people preying on and killing each other, cyborgs who kill humans, etc.

It's such a dreary sameness to every sci-fi futuristic movie that I now yell at the lastest sci-fi shows on Netflix, "STOP COPYING BLADE RUNNER you imagination-deprived nut cases. The sun DOES shine sometimes, even in the future, for heaven's sake!"

Have you seen what China looks like lately?

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:46141
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.