Well now we know (like we didn't from the tweets) that Donald Trump watched Elon Musk on Joe Rogan: The CDC counts coronavirus deaths by tallying data from local health departments and data from a death-certificate digital coding system, according to the Daily Beast.
One official told the news outlet that Trump worried that the criteria were so broad that it could include somebody with COVID-19 who died from falling down the stairs.
A task-force official told the Daily Beast that the White House was pushing for changes because of genuine concern for the integrity of the data rather than any desire to obscure the reality.
Yeah. lmao. Can this shit get any weirder? www.businessinsider.com/trump-pressuring-cdc-change-coronavirus-toll-method-daily-beast-2020-5
Sure someone with Covid could fall down the stairs and die, but in what universe, even one in which Covid is invariably mis-counted as the cause, would that significantly skew the figures?
The actual evidence is the other way. April deaths from ALL causes shot way up. Remove the official Covid deaths and subtract the average deaths expected for April and you still haven't counted for around half of them. This strongly suggests a significant undercount. People with no (or insufficient) health coverage resisting getting care, dying at home or at the belatedly-visited ER, and the proximal cause of death, we're starting to see now, can be stroke, heart attack, silent hypoxia, kidney failure, or in the case of the elderly, natural causes ... possibly without severe or even obvious respiratory symptoms. A lot of this comes from derangement of clotting mechanisms in Covid that we're only beginning to understand, as well as from regional variations in the prevalence of particular symptoms (probably due to virus mutations).
I doubt every corpse gets a Covid test, since even living people have the very devil of a time getting tested in most areas.
This was all covered in the Washington Post, not on LiberalConspiraciesRUs.com or something.
On the whole, I agree with your assessment. The increase of death from all causes during past pandemics was how the death rate of an outbreak was calculated. It's still not a fool-proof method, but likely approximates the actual figure much better than the methods currently being used. BUT - with that said, I do agree with Musk on several fronts. First, that it is not as deadly as the current stats suggest-and this is for precisely the same reasons as you cite for an undercount. Example: people who have heart disease, kidney problems, etc. may be not getting healthcare for fear of contracting the virus. I know in my own family, my mom refused to seek treatment for an entire week while having some potentially fatal health issues. Thankfully, we finally talked her into going to the doctor. But she will likely have some long-term health issues because she did not seek immediate care. Also, the lack of testing could be skewing stats in the opposite direction. The very few statistically viable random population tests that are out there suggest a MUCH higher infection rate-which would bring the fatality percentages way down. Does that mean a lot of people won't die either as a direct consequence of infection, or from complications due to comorbidities? No, but an appropriate response cannot be developed without better data. Appropriate data collection should have been happening from the outset to ascertain the true risk, and, I argue, the mass production of N95 masks for every man, woman, & child to help slow the spread of infection as the economy MUST be reopened before supply chains completely collapse & evaporate. My exasperation comes from anyone expecting Donald Trump to accurately collect & disburse data. And Musk's not an idiot-he made a well calculated political maneuver to save his company. He knows no responsible solutions are waiting in the wings of government.
I saw a similar post -- here is what I said:
He's relentless in his quest to game the system.
A quality person, with integrity, would likely try to use the numbers that most clearly expressed the situation.
Dishonest tRump only wants to use numbers that best bamboozle his audience. It's disgusting.
In total agreement.
It will suit his narrative that the virus was the fault of the Chinese, the shitty response was Obama's fault, and the number of deaths all made up by a liberal conspiracy of fake deaths and crisis actors.
Unfortunately by November all Americans will know someone who has died of COVID-19 and won't be able to deny it is real.
Likely true.