"The U Experience" What are your thoughts on this idea, a hotel instead of dorms, for college students who are missing out on the "away from home" college experience due to classes being online only for some this year? Sounds like an interesting trade-off in these unprecedented times.
Here is the text of the article: (For those who don't like clicking links)
Two Princeton grads have come up with an idea to "unbundle" the college experience from physical colleges: having students take their remote classes from hotels in Waikiki, Hawaii & Arkansas
It's called The U Experience, and it's buying out two hotels this fall to house students from different schools in a "bubble."
Cofounders Adam Bragg and Lane Russell told Business Insider that they left their jobs to work on The U Experience full-time.
The cost is basically what room and board would cost on an actual campus, they said, with a $12,000 base rate in Arkansas and $15,000 in Hawaii.
As the coronavirus pandemic continues to temporarily — or perhaps permanently — alter the college experience, two Princeton graduates have come up with a new idea:
instead of students taking online courses from their bedrooms and couches, they'll take them from a luxe "bubble" hotel full of other students in the same boat.
It's called The U Experience; come fall, it may be hosting 150 students at hotels in Arkansas and Hawaii — and it's currently accepting applications.
The idea began, according to 24-year-old cofounder Lane Russell, when Harvard said it would shift to remote learning for the fall, but would continue to charge full tuition.
"It really made us think about, 'What is the thing that college is offering, and what are students getting out of it?" Russell said.
"And we think that, even if a college is announcing something that indicates that the experience is actually worth $0, a lot of students probably do value it much higher than that."
And in the social and extracurricular void that colleges shifting to remote learning leave behind, "disruption and unbundling is called for," according to 27-year-old cofounder Adam Bragg.
The U Experience
That "unbundling" will take the form of two bubble "campuses":
one in Waikiki, Hawaii, and the other in Fayetteville, Arkansas.
Both are in hotels that Bragg and Russell said they have bought out.
"Something like this could have never been done before — mainly because the separation of a college experience from colleges was never possible.
They held the college experience for ransom, and now that they've shifted to online learning, there is an opportunity to do something like this," Bragg said.
He added that, pre-pandemic, a complete buyout "wasn't necessarily an interesting thing for a lot of the hotels, or at least they didn't know they had the interest for this thing.
And so on both sides, the levels of coordination are a lot higher than was ever possible before."
Neither has a background in higher education, hospitality, or event-planning.
Bragg said that the duo "did go through Princeton together, and we were able to have an understanding of the college experience firsthand, and we understand the value of it."
They said that as of four weeks ago, both have left their jobs to work on The U Experience full-time.
Russell said they're funding the venture with personal savings — although he declined to share an exact figure.
"If we risk a couple of months and have to get back on our feet after this, that'll be a small price to pay for having gotten the idea out there and maybe helping people," Russell said.
Bragg said that they have partnered with people in the hospital industry and media industry — which their website identifies as:
Hotel Connections and Happi House Collective, respectively.
While Russell and Bragg would not say how many applications they've received, they said they have enough to fill a class, but need more to get the project off the ground.
"We really do want to take the time to go through these applications carefully and make sure that students are properly vetted, that they're all going to have a good time, and be safe and healthy here," Russell said.
The group's handbook says that all students must take a COVID test after they're admitted to the program;
Russell said they plan on coordinating with the students and local testing sites, or plan on "finding a way to get them to a testing site."
Students will be asked to self-quarantine between the test and their arrival on campus. Russell said, "obviously, that puts a little bit of trust in these kids. "He pointed to Hawaii's mandatory 14-day self quarantine policy, and said that students wouldn't be exposed to each other immediately.
He also said that, because they're buying out entire hotels, they can devote extra rooms and quarters to quarantining.
Here's what The U Experience campuses — if they do open in the fall — will look like.
All students will have single rooms, and the ones on the Hawaii campus will have their own bathrooms.
While food and drinks weren't originally going to be a part of the bundle, Russell said they will now be offering meal plans; they're also hoping to make arrangements with local grocery stores to deliver to the hotels.
Bragg and Russell said they may have program administrators living on-site to try and minimize the "inflow" and "outflow" of the bubble.
However, hotel staff will likely come from local communities; Russell said "we don't plan to have them actually capable of interacting directly with the students."
Russell said they're trying to price their bundles "within the range of or almost exactly" full room and board.
The Arkansas campus has a $12,000 "base rate." And the Hawaii campus has a $15,000 base.
"Most dorm buildings don't have a gym in them. Most dorm buildings don't have the bar inside. And most dorm buildings don't have a pool," Russell said.
"And so really we see this as something that, because colleges charge so much for room and board, we can offer much, much more than they're offering at about the same price."
Russell said that they hope to offer scholarships, and have set up a donation portal on their website, but haven't gotten any "major interest" in it yet.
Russell said interest has mostly been coming from students in denser urban areas, especially in places like California and New York "that have broadly based protocols in place."
"We very much believe in this idea," Bragg said. "We believe that this is something that, that students would very much enjoy and that the public as a whole needs."
I don’t see this working any better than a regular dorm. A hotel full of kids are not going to social distance anymore than a dorm full of hormone overdosing kids.
On a similar note, our local hands on science museum is offering to bring students in for all day care and classroom help. Which sounds great for the kids, but I don’t see where it is any better than just sending then to regular school. We are going to be in this virus’s grip for a very long time. 250,000 people at Sturgis this weekend should certainly put us well on the way to the new death toll expected by one source: 300,000.
The college age kids are currently gathering at beaches and parks and the virus is spreading that way, and then to the household members of those kids. I think one aspect of this experiment would be to contain them all in one place, and not interacting with community members. It might cut down on the spread, if done correctly.
The concept could work to protect the students, while allowing them to forge friendships in real life with students from other regions. I'm not for it or against it, since I have no college age kids or financial interest in this idea, just thought it was interesting.
Sounds like a good idea if they are very strict about the initial two week quarantine with testing done before and after...
Here on Kauai, we are very strict about the quarantine, and have arrested 60 quarantine breakers, but on Oahu they are not quite so passionate about enforcement. And the numbers show it.
The concept being talked about lately is that it's easier to monitor a quarantine bubble in a hotel setting, with bracelets and geo-fencing, but it's unclear to me if that's the plan for this experience/experiment. There is talk about making some visitor resorts quarantine hotels, where tested travelers can enjoy the confines of the resort only.
It's definitely a controversial but interesting concept. I'm neither for or against it, I just thought it was in interesting idea, and curious what others think about it.
Thing is, the college age students ARE going out to public spaces to gather, and bringing whatever they catch home to their household members. This might be a safer option for some.
Great idea. Lets put all the students in to a Petri dish and spread the Virus.
Well, they'll be clean when they get there, and supposedly self contained in the resort and not mingling with the community, nor passing the virus to their family members.
Interesting idea, but like you say, not sure how safe it is if some of the students sneak out and mingle with the community and become carriers or sick. We do have a 14 day quarantine for now and soon should have pre and post testing for travelers, with a quarantine in between tests.
Oahu is currently on a modified lockdown - beaches and many businesses closed anyway, so no beach parties for a while yet.
I'm just glad it's on Oahu, where they are up to 200 cases a day now, while we here 100 miles across the ocean have zero. We are pretty much open here, but all visitors must quarantine for 14 days before mingling with the residents.
@Julie808 How you can know they will be clean when they get there is not a reasonable thing to say with Asymtomatic people everywhere and not enough testing available in the US right now. If you were asked, how can I come up with an idea that would help spread the virus then it's a great idea
@dermot235 The state of Hawaii is currently working on a potential plan to pre-test travelers before they board their flights to Hawaii, and have the travelers quarantine/self isolate upon arrival for a few days until a second test is given and results received.
The hotel room idea would provide self isolation rooms between tests. The health officials here says this idea would cut down the spread of the virus immensely, but not entirely. The biggest problem is that we are currently having trouble getting enough testing supplies.
It's just an idea -- due to our tourist economy being a driving force, we are slated to open up our state to travel September 1st with testing/quarantine -- though there is pressure to wait until October or later.
Personally, I'm good with not allowing any visitors to the state until after the first of the year, but that's just me. Even though my income depends on tourism, the health of our residents is far more important. We only have 9 ICU beds on my island, and so we are super scrupulous in not spreading the virus, but on Oahu, the cases are already soaring, making most of us clamor to keep tethering travel to a quarantine, if double testing is not available.