Agnostic.com

25 2

Has anyone else noticed a pervasive sense of social and moral collapse in modern society? School shootings once a month, terrorist groups becoming more and more powerful, a lifelong con artist becoming president, a megalomaniac being the leader of a nation with nuclear arms.

And in a more mundane way, 95% of the news is unreliable. We are very much living in a world akin to Brave New World. Society has truly collapsed and we're living in a dystopian world.

ErichZannIII 7 Apr 8
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

25 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

5

Our current societal status is really no different than how things were in the Middle Ages.
We're just as violent and "immoral". We just have more technology.
Leaders have always been varying degrees of corrupt, and they've always had access
to the latest weapons.
Things really are no different now than they've always been.

4

To say 95% of news is unreliable is a ridiculous statement that you can't back up with facts. Even Fox news is only 63% lies according to the Wall Street Journal. If the others get something wrong they will apologize and change it.

@SilverDollarJedi How do you know they are more reliable. There are independent organizations that do monitor and report on news organizations.

3

The world has always been dystopian. We are just doing it at scale now and with instantaneous news that includes video. Perspective mostly just depends on age and whether you are part of the haves or have nots, majority or minority, rich or poor, etc.

2

you should have been around in the late 60's !! -- yeah, it's tough and rough out there, but it's been worse. Doesn't make it anymore correct though. And, my parents generation reminded me of the Great Depression -- yeah, it's been worse all right. The bitter tribalism and distrust of the other viewpoints - just part how we were formed as a nation.

@ashley44 You are right about the one feature of today that I had not touched on -- the intent of those in power to destroy the government as we know/knew it. Being in DC, have chatted w/ more than a few lifer government workers -- the ones that stay no matter who's in charge. They are appalled, scared and worried -- and they've spent 40 years watching/working in the system. I concur that the genius of the Constitution MAY prevail -- but hold out more hope in the upcoming elections -- little items like the number of citizens who have participated in protest marches - WAY up. I think the apathy that has brought he who shall not be named to power is receding. OR at least I surely hope so - or I'll have to get tix for Ireland (sure won't be to Central or S. America and we are too old for Canada)

@ashley44 I've been to the Canadian website a few times -- there is a "test" w/ the implication that the immigrant will be a productive member of the society -- at our age, hardly likely. Of course, one of the items was "do you speak/write French" -- Nope and I don't want to... There was a "way" - something about $1mil invested in a Canadian business.. It wasn't clear as to whether that would be a stock purchase of an existing company - or some fly by night venture capital game... nevertheless, one can't eat stock certificates! Ireland on the other hand seemed far less restrictive (maybe because of the loss of population over the years?) -- and I like the GREEN of the country, Guiness and their history. (somewhere there are distant Irish relatives) I wonder who will be the first country to open their borders to US citizens as political refugees?

I'd thought of Spain and Portugal - I speak a bit of Spanish - but the governments are barely democratic and the wealth gap is soul crushing. I'm halfway serious in thinking of an out - always wondered what the Jews in Germany were thinking when Hitler took power - and promised myself to keep a weather eye on "how things are headed" -- I emigrated half way across the country from a dirtwater prairie town to the East coast - I can do it again.

Maybe we'll meet in Ireland!

2

People have been saying this since records began. We always feel that things are getting worse and exaggerate the downhill slide. In fact, overall things are getting better. Life expectancy and health are improving all over the world, on average, more people have access to clean water, electricity, the internet, etc., than ever before. Bad things happen and they are what fill the news channels. Nobody is interested in good news. If you feel your current news channels are unreliable, look more widely. There is lots of news available on the internet and you can check facts there too.

@SilverDollarJedi Of course I care about things like global warming and the amount of plastic in the sea etc. But human beings have a good record on dealing with things when they have to. I think there will be many problems in the future but I think there will be a lot of solutions found too. I am not denying any of your threats, but I don't think the end of the world is at hand.I think the difference is in attitude - I take a positive view and you seem to take a negative view of the same issues.School shootings are very sad, but it is an American problem that you have to solve yourselves. The rest of the world just looks on, bemused.

2

Its the beginning of humans end

That started when the first humans walked upright. We have just picked up the pace.

of course, our brain has been our most powerful weapon and our downfall. we are a dead-end species.

LeighShelton the Ultimate Doomsayer.

it's just realistic @crazycurlz

the facts don't lie.
2

Most definitely, since the beginning of human civilization.

2

It is easy to notice the negative. In the UI.S. violent crime is actually near an all time low. Which woudl suggest soem improvements are there, but just not pointed out so blatantly.

We have had far right wingers gain a lot of power in teh U.S., peopel such as Joseph McCarthy, who in the ned sel fsabotoged themselves because you canonly fool the majority of peopel for some of the time. you cant' continually do so for extended periods fo time. In the end society sees the truth and moves away from the extremists.

2

I don’t know...as a history major I think we’ve come a long way...rather grudgingly in something me cases but nonetheless.

2

I think it's always been this way. People have always been immoral, but maybe society is less.... sociable. We certainly live a safer, healthier and wealthier life than ever before (factor in war, inquisitions, burning witches, mutilations, mass dying from curable diseases, etc. etc etc - and don't even get me started on the killings or anyone remotely intelligent by the religiots) We just have access to information sooner. And we're more knowledgeable. So no, I don't think we live in a society with social and moral collapse.

2

Don't worry. It's cyclic. Babylon, Rome now us.

Agree. Don't forget the Egyptians, the Greeks, the great kingdoms of Africa, etc etc etc. "It's the circle of life" - .Simba

1

I think the tendency to be barbaric has always been there and that's why we have laws.
There are too damned many people on this spinning ball on top of the information explosion so not only is there more heinous fuckery going on, we hear about it constantly.
The printing press, hand written anything a much slower medium to disperse these sorts of happenings.

1

I do find that the more religious you are the less moral you are.

1

No I don't
You just hear about things more than the good old days because of TV, and social media. Also people are not all forced by society to follow the same moral beliefs. I find there is more morality. People just don't always agree anymore..
Despite all the fear mongering and publicity when things happen studies show violent crime is at a low (here in the US at least).

MsAl Level 8 Apr 8, 2018
1

We have 24 hour news media, competing with each other for something newsworthy at every moment.

If you actually run the statistics, most of these factors were declining sharply until the middle nineties, then abruptly turned around. Violent crime is way down, etc.

[motherjones.com]

This statistical truth ignores the fact that the move to an urban society has accellerated the isolation felt by non-urbanites. A lot of Trump's rise was an attempt by such people to be relevant again. But too many of them face the decline of "rural America" with drugs, eventually drug deaths, whether accidental or suicide is almost irrelevant in the opiod crisis.

GossG Level 2 Apr 8, 2018
1

Well technology has gotten better, so the tools in which people can use to fulfill their goals are better. We also have more coverage of the world with technology too so we can see most everything happening on the news, so it might seem like it's more rampant now. Even the school shooting issue isn't fully understood. They are doing more and more studies on it, including the role that prescription drugs plays in it. So is it social and moral collapse or just better coverage, opportunity, and/or technology etc. now? I believe this stuff has been around forever with human nature. Hitler tried building nukes, so a megalomaniac leading a nation trying to get nuclear arms is nothing new. Were/are any Russian leaders with nukes megalomaniacs? Putin? You don't think some crazy leader like Genghis Khan would have had nukes if the technology was there?

The media has definitely been corroded though.

@SilverDollarJedi When did I say we should let it continue? The OP said they notice a moral and social collapse in society NOW. All I did was point out that it was always here. Never once did I say we should let it continue or increase. Why would you infer that's what I meant or that I was apathetic?

@SilverDollarJedi I also think history disagrees with you on your other points. If you think hunter gatherers weren't greedy and violent and protected their own "properties" etc. then I have a bridge to sell you. No offense.

[theatlantic.com]

[journals.uchicago.edu]

[quillette.com] (Go to the part where they talk about sharing)

Are you going to double down?

@SilverDollarJedi At what point do we say it's "human nature"? 51% of the population? How do we even measure that? What if these characteristics are more susceptible to one sex of our species, which seems to be man?

I think things like greed and violence might be a built in defense mechanism in all humans in general and it just varies from person to person. Just because greed and violence doesn't SEEM like a built in characteristic in some people, it doesn't mean it's not in them. Sure, nurture might bring it out of them, but where did it come from in the first place? Also, what level of greed and violence qualifies for us to quantify it to the discussion?

This is probably a circular argument for both of us. If the neurological and psychological community that studies these issues can't come to a consensus, I doubt very much that we will lol

@SilverDollarJedi I do think violence AND greed are inherent and prominent in human nature. I don't think you're understanding my argument. Whoever's fault that is doesn't seem to matter. Like I said, this discussion is going to continue to be circular though, and even the people who study this stuff for a living can't agree.

@SilverDollarJedi Definitely agree to disagree. It was nice talking and exchanging ideas.

1

That's just America the rest of us are doing fine apart from England which is following suite

Disgusting human behavior didn't start in 1776, and it's not limited to the U.S even now.

@Piece2YourPuzzle no shit Sherlock ;!!!

@SimonMorgan1 Well then your original statement is bullshit.

1

i do think society as a whole has always been lacking when it comes 2 such things, but it is nothing new. i think that with our ability 2 communicate more easily, and our tendency 2 focus on the bad aspects of life, it is more common 2 hear about it now. but on a smaller more personal scale, i see good deeds and an amazing capacity for kindness every day. so i don't think so much that we are worse than before, just that we hear about it more often

Byrd Level 7 Apr 8, 2018
1

Yes, I have noticed. Not sure where it's going but its definitely going. And it is worldwide. It seems as though the world is dividing into two groups; the good or the bad (simplistic description) and there are no blurry lines either. The good truly are the good (decency) and the bad truly are bad (indecent). I think we are experiencing history in the making. Hopefully it leads to a rebirth of our social and intellectual structures/restrictions as we now know them because for sure the old rules are not being applied anymore and in most cases shouldn't be applied any more. Is it a cleansing of sorts?

1

I don't buy into the news being unreliable. I think some news sources are more in-depth and interesting (Tapper and Ari Melber) and some stations are not news (Fox except that I really admire Shep Smith). But, WOW, without our FREE PRESS, we are nothing.

As far as the social and moral collapse, it goes in cycles: think the 1920s. The KKK appeared during reconstruction, post Civil War but hate groups were around before then. We might be heading to social collapse today but right now it's just a struggle for supremacy: anti v pro gun, anti environment v pro, white power being overwhelmed by the collective minorities (including many white people), 1%wealth v 99%everyone else. If we don't figure this whole thing out, then, yes, social unrest

1

Yes, in the culture of greed infesting too much of our society, the racism and ethnocentrism, the religious hypocrisy among evangelicals, the failure of Republicans to stand up for principles of morality and eecency and against corruption and treason.

The rest of your statement is pure BS. The only media that are unreliable are Fox, Sinclair, other right wing extremist groups, and Russian planted meddling..

1

Heading in that direction - need to put a halt to it in November-vote the Pubs out so we can start impeachment.

0

You watch too much tv. stop, you'll feel better

0

If I was religious, I'd think End Times prophecy was being fulfilled. We're actually just seeing what happens when the greedy and selfish become powerful.

Deb57 Level 8 Apr 8, 2018

The greedy and selfish have always become powerful.

But it seems they have currently dispensed with the pretense of having even a shred of humanity or compassion.

@Deb57 You mean they don't pretend god told them to do it?

0

Where do you get your 95% figure? From that lifelong con-artist?

JimG Level 8 Apr 8, 2018
Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:53008
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.