Agnostic.com

6 20

During the time this site was dead, it actually freed up some time for me to pull out the book (manuscript) I started writing 30 years ago. I get it out from time to time to update the references and polish up the ideas. It felt good to get back to it.

I think was spurred me on to get back to it is that when I first started writing it, my daughter was about 9 years old, and now my grandson is 9 years old and is exposed to people trying to convince him to believe in God.

I had started writing this book decades ago to help me strengthen our family's humanistic values, while being attacked by neighbors and family members telling my children that they were going to hell, etc., since we didn't go to church.

My daughter, son in law, and his family are all atheists, as am I, but my grandchildren are exposed to friends and family members who are strong religious believers. My grandson, while catching me up on what's new with him recently, blurted out to me "Oh, and I believe in God." (He likely knew that might surprise me.)

I thought about replying with "which God?" or something else clever, but I figured I'd just leave it alone. I did tell him that I've studied religion quite a bit, and if he ever wanted to talk about it, I'm happy to have a conversation.

I have some reasons for not believing in gods, and others can share their reasons for believing in their god, and he's a bright boy. I think it's good for him to just think on it a bit and make up his mind as time goes by.

We'll see how it goes, but I wouldn't ever want to talk someone out of their belief. I'm more about bringing up points to help people make their own decisions.

Anyway, it gives me a good reason to get back to finishing up my book, just in case I ever want to publish it. So, now I'm back at writing my book. Not sure if I'll ever try to get it published, but it makes me feel good to write it and kind of sort out my own thoughts for conversations that might come up in the future.

Not sure if it's appropriate for me to share with him some children's books I have in my bookcase from an humanistic viewpoint -- but I might leave them out next time he visits and see if he's curious enough to read them. I just don't want to indoctrinate him or purposely dissuade him from trying to fit in with his friends, but I'm sure ready to assist him if he wants a discussion. 😉 I'm sure he knows I'm only too happy to talk about it. I'm also sure he'll come around to non-belief at some point, but I'd like him to come to that conclusion on his own.

How have you handled questions and comments from grandchildren about religion?

Julie808 8 Aug 9
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

6 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

1

Hey, that’s great! Finish the book and publish! I think you handled your grandson’s statement diplomatically, but am concerned he is being brainwashed with false logic. Absolutely have the books out when he visits and engage in conversation on the subject, without saying his current “belief” is wrong, if possible. Talk about logic and fact regarding everything is called for. My eldest grandson is atheist, my eldest granddaughter is a former cult member whose current belief about religion and a god is “meh”. Their younger sister who just finished her doctoral residency (she’s a surgeon!, brag, brag) believes in science but I’m not sure about religion, and their younger brother is a fully-brainwashed Catholic like their mother. My other grandchild is less than two years old, so isn’t cognizant of any of it yet.

Any attempts at brainwashing would be from my ex-husband's family, but I'm not worried. My own kids survived it and maintained their sense of fairness and reason.

2

You handled that very wisely with your grandson. If you ever do get published, you have a fan club started here already!

2

It sounds like you're approaching it in the best way. I don't have grandchildren, so I can only go by observations raising my girls. I was lucky in that their peer group was mostly non-religious, so the peer pressure of being religious with the "right" group wasn't a problem as it easily could have been since we live in a strongly religious area. As a grandparent I imagine it's difficult to orchestrate keeping him away from that group like you would as a parent (there were a couple of friends over the years that we were always "too busy" to see), but I would think at age 9 he's probably entering the age of rebellion and acting out from an atheist family, so not reacting negatively will defuse the shock effect. Then again, as a grandparent you're in a better position than his parents to discuss it with him as you're less an authority figure in his life.

I'm so glad you've been spurred on with your book! Publishing digitally is so much easier these days, and I look forward to reading it.

2

Your approach on the kids and their god belief is exactly correct. Confronting this in any other way will cause an unwanted backlash.

3

Glad to hear something productive came out of your down time! I on the other hand . . . . .LOL
Anyway, I think you're going about the situation as only someone like "us" can. I have no interest trying to sway a person's beliefs one way or another but am willing to discuss it.
That whole going to hell thing though does get me pretty toasty.

4

I think you’re going about things in the correct way Julie, and if he initiates the subject again at a future time, perhaps you will have the chance to engage in conversation where you can ask him why it is he believes in god, and how many other people such as you and his parents have different views.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:727594
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.