The basic cause of the present and past wars in Israel that seems to be ignored by everyone, Lebensraum (the excuse for WWII that is still used by all sides today).
”Whenever two differing peoples with increasing numbers are forced to share limited resources, conflict arises. Deteriorating living conditions are inevitable due to population increase, but each side blames the other for its woes. Sides are taken and grudges for past aggressions fester, regardless of the retribution already meted out.”
”When both sides decide that their security depends on more people, it becomes a pact of mutual destruction. In both Palestine and Israel, such sentiments are often voiced: the Palestinians to produce soldiers to avenge their people, the Israelis to strengthen the Zionist project and expand its territories (some still feel they need to replace Jews lost in the Holocaust).”
”Both sides are increasing in numbers far more than surrounding countries. Some groups on both sides claim to be following God’s directives. For reasons of pride, religion and nationalism, any mention of managing numbers is met with immediate dismissal and contempt by both sides, considered too ridiculous to even consider. Given the impossibility of so many people flourishing harmoniously on such a small resource base, and given the continual increase in potential grievances, an endless cycle of war, oppression and bitterness is therefore the default option.” [overpopulation-project.com]
When you educate women they stop having so many babies.
Which is why so many places try to not educate women. Unfortunately, that doesn't always work. In some ultra-paternalistic countries (like Iran) rape is not considered wrong in marriage.
@Jolanta Problem is it's not we in the developed world. In most developing countries when people are poor they tend to have more children. They feel the more they have the higher the chances one will make it and support the family. Often making it means emigrating to a wealthier country and sending money back to the family. Many do just that. This is farmer mentality.
With some good will from both sides, co-existence would be possible in this corner of the world. There is enough "Lebensraum" there for all of them. There are places on this planet which are much more densely populated where people live side by side.
The key issue is of course security. If you have neighbors who want to kill you, you need some space (or a high wall) to keep them as far away as possible.
There is not enough room. Besides it's not simply about room but resources of which both tribes are dependent on the outside world. Of course what's missing from all of this is what has happened to the biodiversity? I guess humans don't need other species (other than the edible kind) to survive which is totally wrong.
I don't know anything about the situation, but I'm sure there is some truth to that. One thing that has puzzled me lately, is why nearly 50% of the population of the Gaza Strip is reported to be children, under 18 years old. I keep hearing that on the news, and it just doesn't seem to jive with what it seems it should be, compared to other areas in the world.
there seem to an iron law in human demographics: the poorer people are, the more children they produce. Another factor is female rights: where women have no rights and get no or only little education, they have to produce babies.
This is the 4th war in 16 years. The adult male population has been decreased by war.
i just heard that it's actually 42% under age 18. i agree that many of the older generations die in conflict. however, this trend seems to apply to many countries in the region.
A report, which came out several years ago, detailed that how the Palestinians are able to keep up with the increasing numbers of Jewish immigrants was to increase their fertility. It's a common ploy still in use today especially among the developing countries.
Lebenstraum simply means "living room," or room to live. As for the children media is talking about the idea is to get us all to think"OMG, they are killing children." I agree with you that there seems to be too many children. So far some news crews have been attacked also and We have to understand that many will die in the crossfire. War is hell.
Naturally those authors will see everything through the lens of overpopulation. What percent would I assign to that being a factor in the conflict? I'd give it at most, 15%. The actual history suggests that nationalism might be 50 % for the Israelis, bigotry maybe 20%, religion the rest (15%). For the Palestinians, religion would be more like 50% and bigotry 35%. Actual Palestinian nationalism would be less than 5%; they are not serious about it and it is nothing more than a talking point, a figurative flag to wave. This is because no 'country' is or has been envisioned.
There is a direct link to all the 'other' things mentioned to the increasing demand on a limited resource base. As the numbers of us increase competition for resources often becomes divisive and then all the other things you mentioned come into play. During the UN conference on overpopulation in Cairo I kept hearing the truism that, "no matter what one's cause it will be a lost cause unless we come to grips with overpopulation.' Too bad too many people are not able to see the obvious. It's not that hard.
We all see where this is headed. We are SkyNet.
As to over-population, who will listen to the pleas not to over-populate? The cynical "You first" will always be the reply.
Except for a severe pandemic or something similar, it is another intractable problem. I've heard the wealthy are building bunkers...
A tad more complex than that. Eg what's the excuse for Israel bombing Syria? Does Syria have the right to defend itself or only Israel?
My feeling on this whole shit show is that the world had such a guilt for allowing the Holocaust to happen that they have allowed Israel to literally get away with murder with no repercussions for far too long. UN resolutions ignored so Israel continued on it's path of suppressing Palestinians; the people displaced when Israel was formed. The situation had became so bad in Gaza that they felt they had nothing to lose and lashed out. That attack on the festival was an act of desperation by some who felt they had nothing left to lose.
This in no way excuses what Hamas did, but hopefully sheds light on their motivation.
With Netanyahu openly calling Palestinians animals, I find it no surprise that an extreme faction of those "animals" should choose to be barbaric.
@rogerbenham The crazy irony of this in this fucked up world we live in, is that exactly like Bin Laden and the Taliban, Hamas is merely the result of a created group formed to weaken the PLO by Israel to encourage a bit of regime change.
"The enemy of my enemy is my friend" really is a sad way to further foreign policy.
@puff Yes, I am reading that Hamas had talks with Israel,. Are you implying that Israel let the killings of Israelis to justify wiping out the Palestinians?
@rogerbenham No, I'm saying Hamas would not exist if Israel had not promoted their creation to weaken the PLO back in the day. Just like the Taliban/ Bin laden would not exist if the US had not created the mujaahideen in Afghanistan to weaken the communist government there back in that day.
[theintercept.com]
"This in no way excuses what Hamas did...."
Oh yes... that's just that: an excuse.
It turns the Hamas terrorists into brave freedom fighters, just as the Jews did back in the Warsaw Ghetto (1943) when they made a desperate revolt against the Nazis, except that today for anti-Semites the roles are reversed: the Jews of today are Nazis, and Hamas are the Jews of yesteryear.
@Thibaud70 To understand does not mean you condone. Humans have no right to do what happened to those other humans at the festival, no excuses accepted. But even the Chinese see the response as a bit over the top. Humans have no right to do that to other humans either. Understanding Israeli motives again does not mean you condone or wish to excuse.
Agree Warsaw Ghetto seems similar to Gaza. Russians have compared imposing a blockade on Gaza to the siege on Leningrad also.
All one needs to do is look around. In Africa many countries are in constant fight mode. No one wants to limit fertility rates as another country might try and overtake them. Population (especially male) is the ultimate weapon. Access for limited resources is the prime force behind most wars which often include non-human species.