Agnostic.com

4 2

Oy

tallguy241 7 May 6
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

4 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

1

Ok, I think I got it.

2

And what do you call a Rabbi with no Bris kit? A rip-off!

That's a keeper

0

I know this, if you fuck up the bottom one the results could look like the top one.

1

Thats a practice that needs to bloody end. When my lads were born in the states I got no end of hassle for not having them circumscised. Sending em to hell and condemning their future wives to poor sex. Its barbaric and no baby of mine was having bits chopped off!

I think that the medical evidence indicates male circumcision is a worthwhile health measure. [pediatrics.aappublications.org]
In our family we didn't choose to do it at birth for our son, and then had to do it at a later age for medical reasons. If I ever had another son I would have it done at birth.

@doug6352 Not worldwide at all. In fact 8t is unusual in EU. It is considered a health matter in places where access to clean water is not guaranteed.

@doug6352 Plus that is a US site.

@doug6352 [nhs.uk]

There you go. This source suggests the evidence is inconclusive. This was a google search to a NHS site. II can find more academic lit if you prefer

I quoted you the American Academy of Pediatrics opinion because I am an American, and I wrote "worthwhile" not "worldwide". When our son was born I was swayed by the emotional arguments against circumcision, but actual experience has convinced me I was mistaken, purely on a health and not a religion basis. And of course we don't have dirty water here. So you will believe what you like, and I will rely on both scientific opinion and personal family experience to reach the opposite conclusion.

@doug6352 Doug, I don't believe what I like, I review evidence, seek out opinion from reputable sources and listen to advice Both my sons were born in USA and I was put under enormous pressure to have them circumscised. I reviewed the medical evidence and given the falling rates of HIV in the west, wide and sensible use of condoms and access to clean water, the need is not there. (The evidence is inconclusive even from countries were the need is greater). This practice is not universal and not necessary...so what are we left with...oh yeah...god. I was not going to mutilate my male children in the same way as I wouldn't mutilate my female child just coz I was told god expected it. I understand this is common in USA but it is just tradition. It is not necessary.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:75045
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.