I know fellow Atheists who sing professionally in churches. For them, it is a business. Personally, I feel like music only has the meaning you give to it. I plan on going to my first Messiah sing-along this Thursday because my friends and I are in a place where we really need a feeling of community and some joyful noises. I don't feel a bit bad about it.

Why not? I read fiction, why not sing it too. Besides making vibrations with my mouth organ is pleasurable.

Hell yes it is. I love gospel music, The passion and the soul . Does not affect my self at all.

okay according to whom? it's not illegal! i like all kinds of music.

g

Why not if you enjoy it! thats what the music is for: I sing christmas carols sometimes especially if the Salvation Army come round; and I have never had religious bone in my body but its nice to join in and be respectful and helpful with anyone elses causes as long as they don't hurt anyone .It certainly doesnt hurt me to have a sing song nd raises money for the right causes- I rarely think about the words, they are just partners of the music. what I say or sing doesnt necessarily equate with what i believe or not.

Sing away, my friend, as long as you have a better voice than I do

For a given definition of "sacred"...

Do what you enjoy doing! I sang in a church choir too, some excellent music in the Anglican tradition. You don't have to believe any of it to enjoy singing the music. (I did feel uncomfortable reciting the creed, though.)

Much of the music during the civil rights era germinated from the sacred. I enjoy researching the origin of music so I don't become as judgy as rightwingers.

I still like to listen to some of the praise and worship songs because I like the music, and sometimes I still sing along. Don't worry about what others might think of you enjoy singing them.

To me, music is about feeling, not believing. There are some songs I love that have religious themes.

All of the Disney songs are fairy tales. Where would we be if people only sung songs that were true. ?. Bunch of songs about physics and biology? Which would actually be a good thing.?

As for hymms and such, the words have no meaning to me. I sing along to Popeye the sailor man, doesn't mean i think he exists. the human voice is just one instrument in the band.

No, it's music. Hard to find fault in anything musical, especially if it moves you.

If you don't believe in god, why would you label any music as sacred? The word "sacred" suggests magical thinking. Just like the word "evil" suggests the supernatural. I don't believe in evil people, they are just broken mentally.

Not at all. Most sacred music is uplifting and highly motivational. That is the skill of the writers. Nothing hypocritical in enjoying, and sharing with an audience. Great art, music, literature transcends religious and cultural boundaries and speaks to whoever we really are. Just think, whenever a piece gives that chill in the spine or goosebumps, its a part of you trying to get out to touch the music.

More hum in my case, love Chopin's Ode to Joy.

Is it gonna make you fall to your knees and (gag) worship?
It's just music!

As a musician, I often mention religious themes in the songs I write. These are not to express my personal faith (because I am really cynical about all the religious clap-trap), but rather to evoke emotional associations in the listener.

I also swear via blasphemy quite a bit. And if there is a hell (doubtful!) and I go to it for THAT, well....cool beans!

It is not okay for this athiest to sing, period. Dogs yowl and babies yearn for the womb.

A big thank you to everyone who has taken the time to post replies to my question. I must admit it was largely rhetorical as nobody’s disapproval could ever make me stop singing....I think it’s in my DNA.! As all your replies have been overwhelmingly supportive of me continuing to sing music I love I’m going to reveal that I want my family to play Morten Harket’s version of I’m Ready To Go Home at my funeral (Humanist of course). It is a cover of a 10 cc hit from way back but I just love it and sing it myself often although the words do invoke God to bring me home. If when I do die and then find I’ve been entirely mistaken and come face to face with God I will just say ”sorry God, I’m sorry but your representatives on earth didn’t do a good job at selling you to me”. This of course was borrowed from the late Christopher Hitchens.

We used to do Amazing Grace occasionally when we were a country rock band. To us it was just a song we liked to do. We really kicked it in the butt the way we did it.

I think it doesn't matter. Sing what you want to sing.

Why not? One of my favorite hymns is: Near to the Heart of God. "There is a place of quiet rest | Near to the heart of God..." To me, this isn't about "God," it's about finding that place in our lives where we can be okay even amid the the struggles of life, and I've had a s$it-ton of those. They bring me hope. Not because of the lyrics per-se, but because the melody is beautiful, and the lyrics suggest that there is a place of peace.

As a writer, people ask me all the time, "Where do your ideas come from." The reality is, I don't know. But whatever it is, when I 'surrender' to it, it comes. To me, the Universe is mysterious... I don't understand it, but I don't need to. I simply need to enjoy it.

I can't see where there should be any problem. The music is beautiful and gives our brains endorphins and soothes our bodies. If you enjoy them then sing them. I don't think we have to deny our happiness to be our authentic selves...