Interesting advice for those still looking. Only posting it since throwing our lists away brought my wife and I together, YMMV.
Sigh. She specified the physical appearances of what she wanted. It wasn't until she was given a bloody great shove that she realised that she should have been looking for personality.
I don't know how to tease out the difference between "things I just don't want" and "thing i do want/prefer" but it seems like that's where the problem lies for most of us.
I see her mistake as specifying what "he" should look like rather than how he should behave.
@anglophone she was also looking for someone with a certain type of job too. Im guessing she had another huge list in her head that she wouldnt even admit to herself.
@MarkiusMahamius That makes sense. Thanks for sharing that analysis.