What sort of question is that to pose to a bunch of nonbelievers? We have to first assume the existence of a god or gods...that’s pretty hard to do without any evidence....thus rendering your question unanswerable!

No. There is as much chance Godzilla will punish "those".

No. And even if there was a god, why would it not punish the religious more, since all religions are involved in setting up pseudo-gods in its name.

So I guess a Plague of Frogs,or whatever, is overdue for us non-worshippers? Why don't you hold yer breath until it happens....?

Must we consider every type of nonsense that humankind invents? Of course not. That is why proof is necessary for reasonable discourse. They must first prove a god exists, then everyone can join the conversation.

This is like asking: "Is it possible that Bigfoot punishes those that shit in the woods?"

This post I wrote may explain: "Imagine for a moment that the concept of god never existed, that no one had ever heard of such an ..."

No.

Sure, it's possible in the sense that we don't know for certain and so cannot rule it out. That would be similar to saying that it's possible there's a ghost kitten that kills mice that disrespect cats by running away. But do you believe in the wrath of ghost kitten? I don't, but I can't rule out the possibility. I just have no evidence that such an entity exists and, even if it did, that it is vengeful toward mice. The claim is without sufficient support — just the same as God or gods and the punishments we're told they dole out to the blasphemous, unbelievers, apostates, etc. I feel fully justified in dismissing the claim as irrelevant unless and until such time that there is strong, credible evidence to support it.

When I was a little kid, if I fell and hurt myself and I was on my mom's shit list she'd say "God punished you!" lol

No, not possible at all. We don't get punished or rewarded by imaginary beings. There is no god, no santa claus, no easter bunny, no gremlins, fairies, or leprechauns.

Is it possible that Scooby Doo catches criminals with his four "meddling kids" friends in a van?

It’s possible that we are designed by evolutionary forces to believe in gods that we experience as punishing us when we speak out against religion. ( among other things )

Wtf?