Its so easy for persons in conservative religions to go over to the "dark side" to try to force their will onto others.
He should have his legs broken, and repeatedly so, until he finally starts to use his brain. (Or was it given to him by his non-existent god, thereby rendering it itself non-existent?)
If he wasn't joking, an ass if he was, she will run away at some point, considering her already "yes I am" stance at an early age.