As a Democrat, I find it amusing and satisfying to see Republicans struggle with the monster they created. They brought this on themselves.
By Seth Masket, Director of the Center on American Politics at the University of Denver.
It was no small thing for the Republican Party to end up in this position, and it will be no small thing for it to get itself out of it.
In March, Sen. Lindsey Graham, R-S.C., told Axios’ Jonathan Swan that former President Donald Trump “could make the Republican Party something that nobody else I know can make it,” adding: “He can make it bigger. He can make it stronger. He can make it more diverse. And he also could destroy it.” The interview is honestly a fascinating one. Just two months before, immediately after the Capitol riot, Graham appeared to be done with then-President Trump. “Count me out,” he said, “enough is enough.”
Yet here Graham was in March basically conceding that Trump was dangerous but that he didn’t know how to quit him. Trump’s destructive demands and outbursts have continued — just last week, maybe-candidate Trump hinted that he might direct his fans to boycott voting booths — but party leaders like Graham remain loyal.
To be fair, this has been the GOP’s pattern for more than five years now. The party has slowly surrendered its agenda to Trump’s, even as Trump’s agenda has become steadily more dangerous to democracy.
It’s worth noting that the Republican Party went into 2016 with a set of democratic principles. It passed a national platform that looked fairly similar to those of previous cycles, with calls for a limited government, a robust military, reduced business regulation, lower taxes and other long-standing party commitments. And at least up until the spring of 2016, quite a few prominent party members and conservative thought leaders strongly opposed the candidacy of Donald Trump, in no small part because they questioned his commitment to this platform.
No Republican Party platform. Just support Donald Trump.
Four years later, the party, for the first time in its 166-year history, passed no platform at all. It instead issued a brief memo saying it supported Trump’s re-election and whatever policies went along with that.
But those policy demands turned out to be few and far between. He had strong opinions from the outset about immigration and border walls, but his beliefs in other areas — health care, the social safety net, tax rates, abortion, etc. — were vague and inconsistent, and he often settled on traditional Republican stances and rhetoric.
After President Joe Biden’s victory, however, Trump has been very clear and consistent about what he believes in and what he expects his party to do: overturn the 2020 presidential election. “Either a new election should immediately take place or the past election should be decertified and the Republican candidate declared a winner,” Trump said in a statement Friday.
This isn’t just some idle wish. “If we don't solve the Presidential Election Fraud of 2020 (which we have thoroughly and conclusively documented), Republicans will not be voting in ’22 or ’24,” he threatened last Wednesday. “It is the single most important thing for Republicans to do.”
So is this a realistic threat? Probably. A Washington Post analysis by political scientists Bernard L. Fraga, Zachary Peskowitz and James Szewczyk found that Trump’s questioning of the ballots in Georgia after the November election most likely suppressed Republican turnout in the January runoffs, contributing to Democrats’ picking up two Senate seats and thus control of Congress, albeit by narrow margins.
Trump could do this again. As Graham noted, Trump may not have many concrete policy ideas, but he could seriously damage the party by asking his base to stay home. To quote Frank Herbert’s "Dune,” “The power to destroy a thing is the absolute control over it.” It’s entirely plausible that control of one or both chambers of Congress could come down to just a few narrowly contested seats next year.
It is notable that a relatively normal contest for the 2024 Republican presidential nomination is going on right now. Ron DeSantis, Nikki Haley, Mike Pence and others are visiting early contest states, meeting with prospective donors and endorsers, attending traditional candidate forums and doing the other things that presidential candidates normally do at this stage of the Invisible Primary. They are also trying to figure out what the party believes in. That’s all pretty typical.
What’s not typical is a former president who makes these kinds of demands. Trump is trying to set the agenda for the party by threatening its very existence, and he has determined that the one thing it must stand for is overturning a free and fair election.
When studying politics and history, our class saw a close comparison with the use of Trump and the young Hitler during its early rise to power.
That being, a man whom provided a voice for the confused and dumb in a complex world where the strength of their nation appeared to have been stolen by 'them'.
The 'them' are better when they are lacking 'our' humanity. For the NAZIs it was the Jews, an internal enemy who has taken your jobs and spread defeatism. For the Republicans, you have Mexicans, Muslims and political correctness - a loss of the 'American way'.
The Republicans together with their Christian Right Mega Church allies have learnt the lessons of Geobbels propaganda machine and wield it with determination and zeal, while Democrats scurry around allowing them to do so.
I see Trump as the Joker (in the Nolan film). "Some men aren't looking for anything logical, like money. They can't be bought, bullied, reasoned, or negotiated with. Some men just want to watch the world burn.”
They created him, and now they can't figure out what to do about him. The few moderates are in a damned if you do, damned if you don't position. Do the right thing, the sane thing, and lose what influence or power you had in the party. Play along with the charade, and your party (and maybe the nation) burns down.
If they couldn't or wouldn't stand up to him after 1/6, then honestly it deserves to burn.
Sadly, Abraham Lincoln and even the progressive Republican, Teddy Roosevelt are turning in their graves at what is happening to their party in the 21st-century.
I have engaged with people on this website who believe that people like Liz Cheney, George W. Bush and Mitt Romney are RINOs (Republicans in name only) because they dismiss Trump. The sad fact is this: any and all Republicans who continue to support Trump are the RINOs. They are essentially a cult.
These misguided populists have turned their backs on Lincoln, TR, Ike, Barry Goldwater and even Ronald Reagan, men who would be dismayed by the popularity in their party of a lightweight phony neofascist like Donald Trump.
The sad fact is this: any and all Republicans who continue to support Trump are the RINOs.
Extremely well put.
One small (not) caveat - They brought this on all of us. Again with all the 'limited government' crap. I think one thing that is more distrusted than government are corporations yet here we are with the largest most diverse (read polarized) population than ever, resources are shrinking, the climate/environment is crashing, the murder rate from guns is hitting higher and higher numbers and on and on yet people still are willing to swallow the idea somehow we (the government) is willing to hand it over to corporations to run. Yes, we need a smaller Republican party in the government. Yes, let the republican morons stay home and let the saner voters vote.
Hopefully the Marmalade Mussolini wackjob will continue to demand his Base NOT VOTE in 22' and 24'...that would be AWESOME...AND if he would NOT RUN in 24'...THAT WOULD BE PERFECT...an incumbent Biden running against DeSantis, Haley or even better...PENCE......it would be TOTAL CARNAGE with the Democrats left standing on the smoldering Republicans political GRAVES. Trump has always been a PATHETIC LOSER...problem is he was never made to face himself...time to look in the mirror ASSHOLE. Watching this POS go down in flames is going to be a day that should be made into a NATIONAL HOLIDAY...NATIONAL LOSER DAY...
Love your reply!
I also call him Marmalade Mussolini and Orange Turd.
@LiterateHiker having been through 12 Presidents...I never thought I would actually feel hatred for any of our leaders...Nixon I felt pity...but TRUMP...I HATE...nothing would please me more than to see him unable to speak...that goes for his kids also...they are worthless scabs on our society. Oh...and I feel GOOD saying that...... Hopefully the Republican Party will destroy itself and we can get back to fixing what ails this country. I don't know about anyone else but I am sick of having to listen to the vomit that is spewed every day, day in and day out. I am really hoping all those McD's the Turd eats will cause a massive heart attack and end that POS...fingers crossed...and eyes and toes and arms and legs...you get the picture...Rant over...
@phoenixone1 could not have said it better, your entire "rant" was right on