Agnostic.com

8 10

82% of Buddhists
68% of Hindus
52% of Historically Black Protestants
83% of Jews
60% of Mainline Protestants
55% of Muslims
53% of Orthodox Christians

say abortion should be legal.

[pewresearch.org]

.

skado 9 Apr 17
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

8 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

Which goes to prove how gullible these people are.

0

What's an "historically Black"? Someone genocidally murdered by the KKK?

0

Legal without restrictions of any type?

2

When will people learn that putting bans on things will not make them go away? We've already been down the road of total bans on abortion procedures in the past, and the evidence available would indicate that it didn't work out too well.

That aside, I have to agree with @TheInterlooper below regarding the partial birth abortion stuff, and the reactionist mentality (alt, far right) constantly is looking for an excuse to justify their radicalized views. Even if partial birth and late term abortions are rare, those few incidents will still be used as "evidence" by the reactionary types in order to promote their agenda.

I guess the question becomes… are we content to let the fact that a minority don’t like it, stop everybody else from having that freedom? I don’t think they need “an excuse” to move in the direction of their desires, and I don’t think having that excuse will ultimately withstand majority wishes. It’s a temporary effect of a conservative court.

@skado Regarding that specific issue, I sure hope you're right that it's just a temporary thing. When I hear talk from some about making Federal laws banning all abortion procedures, I'm generally inclined to take their threats seriously.

@SpikeTalon
It’s good to take those threats seriously because they certainly intend to carry them out, and that requires vigilance to resist. But I think DrMLK had it right when he said “the arc of the moral universe is long, but it bends toward justice.”
There will always be struggles, but in the long run that arc has bent toward justice.

1

I am not an expert on other religions but I believe I am on Hinduism, what people are likely to think and how the society behaves religiously and culturally.

Abortion is a rights issue, independence issue. It is an issue because progressive societies have gone beyond the struggles of basic necessities such as water, shelter, electricity, food, basic medicine and other very basic things. Most people in Hindu society in India including middle class are in the survival mode - no matter how educated you are. You will struggle with shortages, nepotism, corruption, government harassment for no faults of your own. You could obey the law, pay your taxes and still face hardships because they are built into the system.

I have lived in India and lived in progressive societies and noticed the difference. In the U.S., we have time to protest, hold civil discussions about rights, we don't struggle with daily life, we have the time to focus on a better future, progress, and overall make life and society better that we can leave for our children. We do not have income tax officers visiting homes and ask questions unannounced just to get a bribe.

This difference is huge. Hindus have not evolved into the thought of individual freedom, what it really looks like, how political leaders cannot serve for life, how leader worship and glorification is wrong. Their thinking on issues like abortion has not matured. Their opinions on abortion is not well studied, researched and well thought. India is still a place where you cannot shake hands with a woman, right wing Hindu extremists beat girls going to or coming out of pubs or clubs in streets. The saying goes.... "It's ok to piss in the streets, but not ok to kiss in the streets".

I would not value their opinions on issues like abortion, individual freedom, transparency in the government, LGBTQ, marriage equality and so on.

Hearing from first hand experience is gold dust. Thank you.

4

I did the Pew research [pewresearch.org]
And found these figures.
About three-quarters of White evangelical Protestants (74%) think abortion should be illegal in all or most cases.
By contrast, 84% of religiously unaffiliated Americans say abortion should be legal in all or most cases, as do 66% of Black Protestants, 60% of White Protestants who are not evangelical, and 56% of Catholics.

At 84% religiously unaffiliated are by far the biggest, they list here.

Clearly, conservative politicians are pandering to those who wish to be in control of other people’s lives. They have been manipulating the religious right for years, and in fact are partially responsible for “the right” moving further right.

Thanks for the updated numbers. The result is the same. More actively religious folks favor abortion than don’t, even if by a narrower margin than with the unaffiliated (many of whom are religious). My point being that it isn’t the “religious” who are responsible for the demise of Roe, but conservative judicial activism. They do not represent a majority of Americans.

@skado Religion is not Immoral or evil of itself, but neither is it naturally moral, it is simply amoral, completely neutral on issues of morality. To use the wonderful metaphor you yourself coined. ( Which I will never forget. ) It is a sauce which you can pour over anything. Which is sadly why it is so much more useful to the evil of intent, and why in this issue it is the, "conservative judicial activists" as you call them, who are getting the best use out of the smoke screen of religion.

So much so that it even seems to the casual first glance, to a crude observer that it is a religious issue.

And that is my main problem with religion on all issues, that it is not of itself, by nature, an evil thing, but it is a weapon which most readly fits the hand of the evil of intent. Especially since the "conservative judicial activists" and other conservative extremes, are so successful at promoting the false myth that religion is not merely, a source of morality, but even the 'only' source of morality, because that helps greatly to raise the calliber of their main weapon.

In fact of course, there is an exact analogue with the gun law issue. Where the pro-gun lobby love to point out that, a rifle is a useful tool, for the farmer to protect the worlds food, and for the poor to feed their families, etc., and they say that. "Guns do not kill people. It is only the shooters who do that." Neither does religion create, conservative extremism, bullying, sexism, racism, extreme nationalism, etc. but it does help them very greatly to promote themselves. And it is therefore with the same pragmatism that I think makes most pro gun control people, think that the world would be a happier and safer place if there were fewer guns. Despite the honest ones, acknowledging that they can be useful. So it is, that I think that the world would be a far happier and safer place if there was less religion. And my personal experience confirms that, having observed your country for a long while now, and coming from a country, where there is far less religion, and far fewer guns, I can almost certainly say, that we here are a far happier and safer place because of that.

@Fernapple
It can certainly appear that way to the casual observer. I haven’t seen any scientific verification of it, but lots to suggest otherwise. Evolution doesn’t “care” whether it’s methods also produce some “unintended consequences”. It just keeps doing what works.

0

You buried the lede. Catholics also say abortion should be legal by a slim margin. I think that number is higher.

2

Numbers are less important than political clout, and that's on the side of Evangelicals.

Apparently so at the moment.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:719758
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.