Agnostic.com
4 5

Masterpiece Cakeshop is BACK in the news-this time for refusing to bake a cake for a transgender woman. The ONLY question I have is WHY choose this bakery for THIS cake and is ANYONE surprised by this...a bakery that that refused to bake a wedding cake for an LGBTQ wedding and took it all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court....sigh. Are there no other bakers nearby, preferably LGBTQ whom one could choose? Even my small town offers these options!
[washingtonpost.com]

BookDeath 8 Aug 22
Share
You must be a member of this group before commenting. Join Group

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

4 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

1

I know -- really. These days, they probably can even order one online from somewhere.

1

They did this to stir up trouble and we’ve got it. Masterpiece has filed another lawsuit claiming the state is harassing them. We are going to lose this one, also, and then we’ll have to live with the consequences. Those are not going to be fun.

rainmanjr Level 8 Aug 23, 2018
1

I also wouldn't want this bigot anywhere near a cake for me. I think, though, it should be incumbent upon any merchant who systematically restricts services to post those restrictions publicly, so that no one would accidentally walk into a situation of public refusal and potential humiliation. It also lets other consumers decide whether they want to support such a business. My hope would be that he would lose at least as many customers as he'd gain. Regardless, if forced to be open with discrimination, it improves the opportunity for other entrepreneurs to step into the void and cater to diversity.

When it comes to freedom of religious speech, I did not follow the court's reasoning. To me, if you provide a service, such as a cake, you should be able to refuse to put any message on the cake that violates your conscience, such as placing two groom figurines on top. But you should not be free to simply refuse all service to the customers you don't like.

Regardless of all that, the court ruled what it did, and I would not want that shop's cake anyway, even if you paid me. (Welllllll, ...if you paid me a LOT, sure, I'd consider being a cake whore ?)

@icolan not according to the Supreme Court ruling. You, as cake maker, are an "artist" and the cake is your artistic expression. Bleh. Stupid, but that is now law.

@icolan Well I paraphrased, but it also said that, in addition to the commission's expressed hostility, a cake maker is separate from other types of "goods and services" jobs, in that the baker is creating something that represents creative expression, marking it as akin to a clothing designer more than as a restauranteur, for example.

@icolan Not exactly. I agree, it is not clearly precedent-setting, but not meaningless, either. It did leave the question so muddled and unclarified as to invite haters to bring future suits claiming they are like the baker in terms of right to religious expression. They, however wrongly, are surely viewing the ruling as on their side.

1

If they did make it I'd be afraid to eat it

Write Comment

Recent Visitors 32

Photos 272 More

Posted by snytiger6Hundreds of love letters between two gay men during WWII ...

Posted by snytiger6All for love and ...

Posted by snytiger6Being gay is not a sin ...

Posted by snytiger6Bigot Bird ...

Posted by snytiger6Pride is important ...

Posted by snytiger6Coming out ...

Posted by snytiger6Larissa awakens Christmas morning to find ...

Posted by CliffordCook([iowafaithleadercoalition.

Posted by snytiger6Victoria's Secret model, huh ...

Posted by snytiger6I come in peace ...

Posted by snytiger6You need to find peace with your uniqueness...

Posted by snytiger6The only choice made was to be myself...

Posted by snytiger6The day you graduate from...

Posted by snytiger6Trust me. There is no other man...

Posted by snytiger6The bible belt...

Posted by snytiger6Condiment come out...

  • Top tags#gay #video #transgender #community #friends #god #sex #gender #hope #DonaldTrump #religion #LGBT #world #religious #rights #relationship #queer #Christian #nation #marriage #children #kids #money #laws #Atheist #church #parents #hello #reason #book #wife #ComingOut #dogs #Catholic #Jesus #Bible #Identity #films #Song #movies #Police #republicans #atheism #vote #death #society #culture #homosexuality #Christians #mother ...

    Members 986Top

    Moderator