Agnostic.com
1 0

A point counter point that I thought about this morning. I'm trying to refine this argument so that it has more weight in the coming debate.

Helpful input is appreciated! Here is the pro-gun point followed by a counterpoint (which isn't the argument that I hold in my mind but is something the gun tooters might understand.)

Point: "We need to arm teachers and other officials in our public schools. No gun control law would have prevented that shooting except an outright ban on guns and that will never pass.

In the Texas shooting the hero was shot because he interjected himself between the shooter and the student victims. If he had had a gun he would not have been shoot and he would have been able to immediately stop the shooting."

Aside from the obvious opportunistic nature of the argument point given above as well as the detailed discussion of how ridiculous and dangerous it is to arm our teachers and other school officials in our public schools, this is a counter-point that I think might reach some on the fence who would otherwise sucker for the simplistic argument given above:

Counterpoint: "Have we sunk so low as a society that the only answer is to arm our teachers? Do you really wish to live in such a society?"

While it is simplistic and incomplete - it strikes at the nerve. We have to think these things through in order to prevail. Believe me, the other side will.

marmot84 7 May 20
Share
You must be a member of this group before commenting. Join Group

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

1 comment

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

You are not willing to give them up. Not talking to you. I am that simple.

Not addressing or even hoping to reach those folks. I'm more seeking an argument that will fly with those on the fence who may still be swayed.

Recent Visitors 7

Photos 509 More

Posted by DruviusMake it make sense.

Posted by FrostyJim...what a sad situation.

Posted by ButtercupI doubt she said it buts it's cute.

Posted by Smurfing101

Posted by DruviusAh yes, modern America.

Posted by Tejas

Posted by SwitchcraftSandy Hook 13th sad anniversary - 12/14/12

Posted by SwitchcraftSandy Hook 13th sad anniversary - 12/14/12

Posted by MoravianSad but true.

Posted by DruviusAlways loved this one.

Posted by TejasAnti trump pistol. Do you have mixed feelings about it?

Posted by TejasLook at this scary gun!

Posted by Tejas

Posted by SeaGreenEyezThe most unaware "Awareness Day" in America was yesterday.

Posted by SeaGreenEyezThe most unaware "Awareness Day" in America was yesterday.

Posted by SeaGreenEyezThe most unaware "Awareness Day" in America was yesterday.

  • Top tags#guns #NRA #video #laws #violence #guncontrol #massshooting #god #DonaldTrump #Police #children #world #religion #reason #Texas #hell #religious #friends #republicans #rights #death #vote #kids #Atheist #hope #USA #society #teachers #church #truth #florida #government #fear #money #belief #parents #atheism #conservative #sex #Christian #agnostic #earth #community #murder #schools #culture #evidence #youtube #Christians #wife ...

    Members 924Top

    Moderator