Agnostic.com

38 3

Think about this now. How long do you think you could go without judging someone? A day? Week? Month?

HardBlues69 7 July 31
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

38 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

We rely on judgment to keep us alive so probably not very long but like everything its down to the person doing it

weeman Level 7 July 31, 2018
11

We use judgements to keep alive. How fast it that car moving, can I beat it through this intersection? It that animal threating or good food? I am going to judge everyone I see, is that person a threat or a friend? It is hardwired into us. Now judging people on superficial things, like style of dress, cleanliness, attitude. Hopefully we have filters to get rid of all that doesn't matter but it is the way we're conditioned, trained, and experience. Whether you want to admit it or not, we can't go without making judgements about people, animals or the world in general. It is a survival instinct. Judging that all orange people are bad, well hopefully we individually have filters to accept that not all orange people are bad.

Very intelligent and insightful comment!

you are wise

6

Right now, I'm judging the usefulness of this post…

@HardBlues69 My comment was neutral. You started judging right away!

6

We all judge.

6

I was doing fine until I read your post 😛

5

Two seconds after reading that i saw your profile picture ......so two seconds .....lol

Simon1 Level 7 July 31, 2018
4

It's entirely normal and automatic to judge people as soon as you see them or hear their voice. The trick is to realise your prejudices and adapt your impressions accordingly.

4

I volunteer at a homeless shelter I don't judge any one there. I know what it's like. I was homeless once myself. So I try to help as much as I can.

That being said. I do sometimes judge some people. Mainly people that are rude.

4

12 seconds

4

talk of not judging someone is such a bunch of crap. we have no choice but to judge people. our minds do it automatically in the subconscious and our bodies respond ... even before our conscious mind has time to make any evaluation. you have to dig deep deeeeeeep into the recesses of the mind and combat thoughts laid down just after birth or perhaps even before in order to curtail "all judging". judging is what our mind does. it compares and evaluates one constellation of neuron points to the last or to the known if confronted with something new. so basically you're asking when or how will we completely go against what our mind was designed to do. the answer we can't and wont. we will hide it maybe but the effects will always be there.

Agree. I think it's what we do next with the judgements that matters. Can we challenge ourselves to be more then our basic nature?

@billy11 well I am not you. you give your answer and I will give mine. we both get to think for ourselves ... isn't it a wonderful world? It would be so boring if everyone thought the same things all the time.

@Guttermoss I like your comment 'it's what we do next that matters". Snap judgements were crucial for our evolutionary survival. If it was a matter of life or death to decide if an approaching person was friend or foe we had to make a snap judgement based on what they looked like. These are highly developed neural shortcuts or heumonics. They save energy and assist for fast action. But as my friend here says, it's what we do next that matters. If we have a brain in our head we can reassess our response and see if it needs amending. Most people today aren't trying to kill us so we don't need to be on high alert, but those judgements remain. They say it takes 5 seconds.

@MsDemeanour I agree with this with the exception of the part where you act as though we can think our way out of it. 5 seconds or not doesn't change the body alterations that have already happened as the limbic system responded bypassing the PmFC. your body chemistry has been effected which changes you physically AND mentally before the executive control center even gets a swipe at it. Thats not to say you can't eventually control your actions, but your views are skewed a bit.

3

Yeah, I'm not sure that I'm "judging" people so much as that I'm "reading" them because that actually does matter in order to make a "judgement" on whether I want to associate with them or not. So yeah, I read/judge people often, but not like in a "mean girl" way. That I don't have time for.

3

I don't judge others haven't for years. I read people very well so what is the point of judging them when they are transparent.

3

My favorite movie quote You have been weighed you have been measured and you have been found wanting

Exactly

3

I judge, therefore I am.

JK666 Level 7 July 31, 2018
3

Judging isn't always a bad thing.

2

A minute?

2

A nanosecond. Goes for all of us. Our brains assess everyone and everything instantaneously in order to protect itself and maintain homeostasis.

2

I am judging your posting right now, took me few seconds. Is this a Guinness record or something? ?

2

Depends, if I play hermit with no radio or tv

2

It generally takes me about half a second to decide if I'd do anything for someone or will never like them (I've tried not to do that, but my first impression invariably turns out to be correct). So, probably not long because I do it all the time!

Jnei Level 8 July 31, 2018
2

3-7 seconds. I judge or think, or gauge someone about everything. How clean someone's shoes are. How someone parts their hair. If they carry their weight unevenly, or walk with intent or how they smell. I assess someone as a threat, as self centered or even unaware in seconds. Now, I know this may seem semantically petty but passing judgement is something different. If I don't exchanging real energy with them or converse with them, I'm making only assumptions based on observations. But I don't allow my observations to lead me toward a negative outlook.

@HardBlues69 I've had the luxury of experiencing life in varying socioeconomic positions, geographical locations and assessing a person versus passing judgement becomes easier with self comfortability. Feeling safe no matter what helps expand the understanding that not everyone has security or feels safe, and that's usually the energy that is exchanged or more honestly, transfered via transference that is usually interpretated as hostility.

2

In court or out of court?

@HardBlues69 5 minutes.... guilty anyways... 5 minutes... but my thoughts and prayers go to them.

1

That question is very condescending ..... how long was that? 10 seconds? What do I win?

1

Im not answering you nosy bastard

1

I judge all the time. But I think it's also about being aware of it, so that I'm not projecting it on to others. If someone is creating such a strong reaction in me, I have to look at where that's coming from.

1

minutes? Judge Judy is my spirit animal.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:144076
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.