Agnostic.com

25 3

Scientists get-green light to resurrect the dead with stem cells. Presuming this is true, who do you want to bring back first

[themindunleashed.com]

Slava3 7 Nov 10
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

25 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

6

This is a TERRIBLE idea. The unintended consequences are going to be swift, sure, and devastating.
Once again, just because we CAN do a thing, does not mean that we SHOULD do a thing.

We die for a reason. This planet is already over-populated as it is.
Think about it for just one minute. Think about every book, tv show, or movie, you have EVER read or seen that covers re-animation of the dead.
It NEVER ends well.
The practical applications of this "proposed research" will turn out to be a HUGE mistake.

In answer to your question. I wouldn't want to bring anyone "back".
I can guarantee you, beyond any doubt, they would not be the same person they were before they died.

Again, this is a really, REALLY BAD idea.

Ditto !!!

5

Eye-catching title for a page with an inconsequential story and a ton of clickbait. I wouldn't worry about it too much, if I were you.

Jnei Level 8 Nov 10, 2018
4

This is madness! Did these scientists learn nothing from the movie, Pet Sematary?

4

Rational Wiki reports themindunleashed.org is a pseudoscientific, woo-peddling, clickbait ... data from studies and present it as scientific fact for their own gain. [themindunleashed.org] IS also themindunleased.com

I blocked that site on facebook because so many people I know were sharing it and clogging my feed

Floriduh

As I said earlier, I didn't know that about the site. Will try to avoid it in the future.

3

All the murdered Native Americans.

3

There is not much evidence that this would work. However, in fun, I would bring back the Framers of the U.S.A. constitution so they could see what happened and interpret it for us in light of the modern world.

3

No one deserves to come back.

3

This is bunk, BUT, playing along with the premise: I would bring back my lord and savior, Genghis Khan.

After the army of your lord savior Genghis Khan burned villages one could not pass near that village for months from the stench of burning, and rotting flesh. Pick another.

@Slava3 Can’t make an omelette without breaking a few eggs. Hundreds of other villages, towns and cities enjoyed a century of peace, prosperity, stability, religious and intellectual freedom because of the empire He built.

3

Although I don't think there is anything substantiated in this.
But if I had to pick a person, it would be Carl Sagan.

3

It's a misleading article. It is really only about bringing people out of comas. People in comas are not completely dead despite what the article implies by calling them "brain dead".

2
2

Boy would that be a rude awaking!

2

This would have to be very recently dead people and thus they aren't dead yet.

MsAl Level 8 Nov 10, 2018
2

Someone recently dead. Zombiefied corpses, even thinking ones would stink. And how long, if possible, would regeneration of rotting skin, muscle, etc would it take.

2

This would be a privately funded study. No institute of higher learning would touch this or ever get approved for something this ridiculous. Obviously this is a waste of precious stem cells.

1

Hitler. Duh.

1

So how come I cannot get a reconstituted pancreas to cure my diabetes

I know a doctor that is working on just that, did gene therapy on a boy with type 1 and is growing him a pancreas now...so hopefully soon.

@Btbd keep us informed please

@Btbd a pancreas transplant into a LIVING body is one thing. a dead body would be, how to put it delicately, unreceptive.

g

@genessa It's why she is growing him a new one

@genessa, @Lucy_Fehr the diabetes was cured by the gene therapy so with the new pancreas he will be a normall kid

@Btbd yep. my only point was that this therapy would not work if he were already dead!

g

@genessabut injecting live stem cells to grow into working beta cells is not at all impossible. It has only one drawback. It causes cures and eliminates patients. You knw what I mean?

1

Mufasa. Because Simba is a dick.

1

would use it so no need to go in the first place

0

Trump's brain.

0

here is a better source and there are a LOT more reasons to doubt than to trust, especially considering that no animal tests have been done, and success would rely on blood flow to the brain, which in a dead person simply is not happening. note that the proposed subjects are brain dead but certainly on life support. nobody is digging up corpses here. still, i wouldn't, pardon any inherent pun, hold my breath. [scientificamerican.com]

b

0

If through cloning we could bring back Albert Einstein then that would be good.

0

Christopher Hitchens

0

ridiculous "announcement" and if the question were asked without it, i might be inclined to play, but no, not with even the hint of a presumption that this is true. sorry.

g

I really hope not, but it is a very long article if it is misinformation again.

@Slava3 i don't think length and veracity are related lol.

g

0

Who really thinks this would work? Birdseye pioneered the frozen vegetables picked fresh from the vine. Veggies like peas were in that group. It would be easier to un-freeze the peas and attach them back onto the vines than it would to use stem cells to bring back the dead. Frankly I don't think either idea would work.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:220226
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.