Lot of fossil accounts I think. Yet because it is small you really get to know people.

The site sponsor had been advertising this site for a while but no idea if that's still ongoing.

I think there just aren't all that many people for whom agnosticism is a very big part of their life, or maybe they live in a fairly openly secular community where agnostics are not shunned or looked down upon, so they don't consider themselves very different to where they need an outlet to speak freely.

Compared to...?
A lot of people come and read and think but don't say anything. They observe, like scientists a rare, exotic species.
But considering the meteotic growth in agnostic thought, the numbers could be small. So what?
Many agnostics are not activist (or even ACTIVE) by nature and simply don't care about preaching their viewpoint. Or discussing it. Or arguing about it. They:re not motivated to find support for their opinions. Why bother?
Being new, many here still have conflicts and issues within THEMSELVES and their OWN world view and are trying to sort it all out. They're not sure WHAT to think. Once they are they might fade away.
Some come harboring a deep distrust, even hatred, for religious folk and want to break them, and are here to grow a "movement," as they see it.
Some are social and interactive and like the sense of community.
Me? I like, I hate, I scoff, I applaud, I remain silent, I speak up, I stay away, I'm fueled by a self-righteous fire, gentle bemusement, or detached indifference. Depends on which hour of which day.
As an agnostic I'm usually open to new ideas expressed by open-minded people. But like most of us I'm pretty sure I have it basically right.
It's an accident I'm here, but now that I am I'll probably never leave. I'm no hero and lie to others when advisable, or convenient, or imperative.
It's a realistic, pragmatic approach--often cowardly but I don't care--it works for me.

One of the reasons I am an atheist is because I just don't give a shit about religion one way or another. That includes not really caring about not believing in gods, so I don't search out atheist stuff. If I never saw the Facebook ad, I probably would have never known.. and I am sure there are many like me.

I think people are still and also a lot of people don't care enough about the Atheist community to join sites like this.

WHAM 1180 cult radio in Rochester is brainwashing females and males 5a.m. to evenings with Bob Matthews SportsTalk....Mon-Fri Lonsberry & Rrrruussshhah dingy Crazy GREEDY LIMPboss radio cult liar spew religious bigotry hour by hour....leaving a few dozen OUT Atheists reeling from the US Sup Ct lies against Atheist women before each Greece City Council theocratic prEying.....the birthplace of the fake Mormon religion just 20 miles east of Rochester has boys 18 in white shirts knocking on every door from Lake Ontario to the Fingerlakes.....you will find more Atheist women and men in Iowa than Monroe County

@GreenAtheist "relocation and eye candy". Not enough info to reply to this. I want to.

IDK? I belong to this and one other site. I've seen 2 men from the other sight here but we do not talk much. I used to favor the other site and now I favor this one. BTW, the other site is constantly gaining members but they never post or say very much, so IDK.

I suspect that most a/a people don't have an 'axe to grind' & therefore don't seek to express their opinion.

It is possible that atheists tend to be more independent and not so inclined to be in a site per se. I found this site right away when I first searched for atheist dating sites, so, it is not like it is a big secret.

If I first realized it was a dating site I might not have joined .

This a new site, relatively. Spread the word. And they will come.

I discovered this site over a year ago but have lost much of my interest in it. Perhaps many others have, too.

Sounds like a good hypothesis.