Agnostic.com

5 4

So the first uterine transplant baby was born: [time.com]

Did you know the first full Male Re-productive system transplant has already taken place?

Full male reproductive system transplant: [nytimes.com]

[hopkinsmedicine.org]

And yes the testicles can also be transplanted.
The ethicists at John Hopkins opted against it.

But there has been more than one done - and in other countries.

I'm curious what peoples opinions are.
The drive to procreate is one that really overwhelms most people. I can understand why some people would do this.

I also wonder if there is some disparity between Men and Women choosing to repair something that isn't working?

Is there a difference between the Wounded Veteran and a Woman born without a Uterus?

RavenCT 9 July 10
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

5 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

1

We really need printed cheese... for um.... Man I am stuck! 😂

0

Wow! Is this a medical priority? Seems to me solving cancer is a much more useful endeavor of medical research. Just got done posting on twin experiments by Mengele. Such a waste of life, time and money.

The transplant (Male) has been done for a Cancer Survivor as well.

The Cancer removed his sexual organs. So you can see there is a correlation.

Mengele was evil.

@RavenCT good happy to hear that -thats worthwhile research. Yes Mengele was evil. Eugenics is evil too.

@sassygirl3869 who's practicing or expounding Eugenics?

@Charlene I was researching from WWII -don't know anyone now thsnk goodness.

@sassygirl3869 Eugenics has an extremely Long history here in the states.It was all the "Rage" in the early 1/4 of the 20th century.

3

For the record, the bioethicists opted against it because the DNA of the sperm produced by the transplanted testicles would be that of the donor (obviously), and not the recipient.

2

I think it's awesome..💓💓💓💓💓

1

One of the last things we need is yet another way to reproduce. We have a surplus of humans on this rock, not a shortage.

The drive to reproduce gets misinterpreted as a right to reproduce. It is not.

1of5 Level 8 July 10, 2019

Human's are over-reproducing. I agree.

But I think reproduction is still a strong drive for many.

Some of us just put it into pets etc.... Which totally explains the cat phenomenon.

@RavenCT for some it's apparently thier whole reason for existing. It's still not a right, though.

@1of5 in your opinion..

@Charlene how is it a right, if physically you are unable to?

@1of5 because it's Their body..

@Charlene that it is. But that doesn't make a desire a right.

@NoPlanetB science allows for everything. So what of those who can't afford it?

Actually in the US right now there is a war on reproductive rights and who controls them.

I'm not opposed to people having children they want - that they can care for.

It's the folks being forced to have children because they don't have access to birth control or abortion that worries me considerably more than this turn of events.

I don't think it will ever be an easy thing to have a Uterine transplant. Or a Testicular Transplant.

I went to a Fertility clinic when I went through my Sub Total Hysterectomy - the Doctors in Boston were some of the first who could do that surgery laproscopically.
What I heard some of those women discussing in the waiting room - just sounded rough. I was kind of glad I was at the Acceptance point in my life where I knew I wouldn't give birth to my own biological children and I was okay with it. (Mostly).

It is a very primal drive to have kids. Probably THE primal drive. People will drive themselves past the brink of reason for it.

Yes there are too many kids on this planet.

Hopefully we proceed with caution.

It also strikes me as something viable in the future for Trans folk. But that's an entirely new discussion.

If I still had a uterus I think I'd be willing to donate it like everything else when I die.
It is just an incubator.

The ethics get weird when you talk about eggs or sperm though. That's your actual biological material getting passed along. IDK that I trust any human enough to be handing them eggs. lol

@RavenCT all valid points..and thanks for bring up transpeople. This experimental Genital Transplant procedure gives hope to Transmen to able to live their lives as close to normal as possible. As to the uterine transplant, I truly hope that it becomes a reality in the future. Both of these procedures will help save the lives of many young transwomen/men.

@Charlene I hope it can help!

I had no idea we were this far along in the science of it. I have no idea if these surgeries are any more or less complex than what bottom surgery is like now. (Other than finding the right donor of course).

I obviously need to do more reading because it's pretty amazing.

@RavenCT Sweden was the 1st country to transplant a uterus, it was donated between sisters.That was 5 years ago, it's apparently being taken as a serious possibility in some cases...it's still considered experimental.
Yes bottom surgery has advanced since I first considered going for it. Until I found out they simply cut everything off and gave you a hole. No sensation at all just a hole.Today they use 95% of penile tissue in constructing a functional vagina..right down to a clitoris!..😱😀😀😀💓💓💓💓💃💃💃💃💃

@Charlene Yes! Thank goodness they've figured out what they're doing. (And of course it should have been obvious from a Biology standpoint but I'm guessing medicine had to catch up with techniques and information).

They can also use part of a person's colon to do the M to F surgery. (which becomes self-lubricating apparently). I've done a little research and viewed a M to F surgery online. (Which is when I figured out I'd never make a good surgeon). It was worth viewing - because it was amazing!

It also put my concerns to rest - should anyone I know ever do that. (Which is a possibility) I prefer to know exactly what's going to happen over misinformation any day. Way less anxiety. ❤

Not that I don't freak when someone has surgery - but less so if I know what to expect.

@NoPlanetB no, I don't live by that, but if it's a right that only those who can afford it get to have, how is that a right? Thats a privilidge.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:372191
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.