Agnostic.com

7 2

So now the Kurds, in a desperate self-preservation move, have joined forces with the Syrian government and the Russians.
If the Russians now shoot down Turkish aircraft, does that constitute an attack on a Nato ally, forcing the USA to respond to its treaty obligations and declare war on Russia?
This is no joke. It's how the first World War was triggered.

[bbc.com]

Petter 9 Oct 14
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

7 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

1

Scary. Even reading some responses just adds to the anxieties

3

AMAZING how everything trump does is EXACTLY what favors Putin.

2

What in the world makes you think we'd uphold our commitment to NATO? This scenario would be used to get the U.S. out of NATO.

1of5 Level 8 Oct 14, 2019

It's Turkey that should be kicked out of NATO. And it should have been done as soon as they announced buying weapons from Russia.

2

WWI was between heavily armed and highly developed countries. Yes, it escalated and involved a lot of smaller countries. I, for one of many, believe that if we had stayed out of that war things would not have gotten as they had and there would not have been a 2nd war.
Unfortunately, right now NATO is having it's own problems. Our nations seems to not be as active in it as it once was.

2

The fall out from this will be huge. So disturbing.

1

Should the Turks suffer casualties from Russians in Syria/Khurdistan, then the NATO articles should not trigger war, as it is Turkey acting alone beyond their national border.
A counter attack forcing the Turks to fight on their own ground should.
As it pans out, it will be up to negotiations by civil servants on both sides as they earn their pay avoiding a world war which neither side can afford to fight. Thus, the Khurds get sold down the river yet again for the 'greater good'.

3

Fuck Trump and his whim to pull out US troops last week. He has unleashed a new conflagration which has just added a new layer of conflict to this already beleaguered part of the world. The poor refugees and Kurdish people are the ones who will suffer yet again, and already Islamic State has claimed some bombing amongst all the confusion. The Kurds were holding IS prisoners, some of whom have already managed to escape due to Turkish bombing. This is a very dangerous escalation of hostilities and it has the potential for further wholesale death and destruction. This alliance between the Kurds and Assam & the Russians is forged out of desperation, and we can see that the betrayal they feel by being sacrificed by their hitherto allies the USA must have cut them deeply.

@Druvius. Regardless of whether he should or should not have pulled out US troops...his timing was not right, but I suppose you are too busy living in safety in your bunker far away in the USA to be objective about anything, This decision of Trump’s has nothing to do with Obama and everything to do with Trump and his re-election campaign. The Kurds fought side by side with your troops in the war against IS....it’s not honourable for the USA to use them as pawns to be discarded at a whim after a phone call with the Turkish President. I didn’t think Obama had a very coherent foreign policy either, just by the way. I’m not American and am not partisan when it comes to being critical of both US political parties.

@Druvius and if Bush hadn't invaded Iraq in the first place. Or Churchill drawn national boundaries ignoring sects and tribes. But none served Vladimir Putin until now.

@Switchcraft As a British citizen I’m deeply critical of our foreign incursions and wars too. Britain and France started the whole turmoil in the Middle East by arbitrarily drawing up borders...taking no cognisance of tribal alliances and territories. I damn all of them, but that is history and can’t be changed, what we should be doing now is taking lessons from our mistakes and not repeating them. Trump is a disaster for the whole world, but it’s obvious that his followers think he can do no wrong...I worry that a large number of your countrymen support his every move. Are they really that insular that they don’t care about the countless people who will lose their lives or are left injured or orphaned in Syria by his premature actions in pulling out US troops?

@Marionville yes Americans are. They soak in a bath of "we are the greatest " every day.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:413894
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.