Agnostic.com

45 6

It sometimes feels that we seldom stray far from the topic of religion on this site, so I have a question that's related to faith: what part of a holy book do you think is good or interesting? (given the understanding that self delusion is generally not a good thing in life, unless for survival).
I'll start, I actually think Jesus sounded like a pretty decent bloke. Also I'm pretty interested in the fact that the bible says, the future is written in our hands, and palm readers take this literally, what about you?

girlwithsmiles 8 Feb 26
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

45 comments (26 - 45)

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

2

I like Paul writing to the Corithians: "When I was a child, I spoke like a child, I thought like a child But when I became a man, I cast away childish things." I just include religion among those "childish things".

haha i would've argued with paul about that (and many things). for example, the more intelligent a species, the longer its members play. i don't approve of putting away all childish things. we need to retain a sense of playfulness and the ability to play and learn, as children do. but paul was a bit of a stick in the mud, wasn't he?

g

2

Let you judge for yourself

1

"be not as the hypocrites who pray in public."

I think jesus was right on that point

Yes, the idea that you get forgiven on a Sunday and go back to sinning on Monday isn’t great, is it. Jesus died for the sins of the world; so do what you like...I’m sure that’s how some people see it 🧐 I’m with you.

1

Proverbs and Ecclesiastes are pretty good.

Orbit Level 7 Feb 27, 2020
1
                                                                                                            Genesis:  The Parable of the Trees has an allegorical relevance to what has happened in history repeatedly.  Namely the weeds sometimes leading to burning everything else down.  Also the Sermon on the Plain  has rlevance to compassion.  As I have dug into scripture I have discovered there are allegorical interpretations that are more beautiful ans interresting than the literal interpretations.  I am intrigued by the "hidden" or mystical interpretations as well.  All Abrahamic religions have these three levels f understanding;  literal, allefgorical, and hidden.  These have caused major splits and conflicts, but remain relevant.  These more esotric interpretations fit more easily wirh my scientific background as well.

Mmm you just reminded me of the Good Samaritan, I like that one. It teaches us not to judge by our stereotypes amongst other things.

1

Ecclesiates - All is vanity.
Jesus - The one that you were taught maybe.
The bible is literature & not sacred scripture. Not to be taken seriously.

also: with wisdom comes sorrow. the more knowledge, the more grief.
truer now than ever.

@callmedubious Let me put a spin on that: the knowledge of birth, life & death is sad (so we believe in heaven).

@Atheist3 , that's true.
i sometimes think that the those ppl that are comfortable in their cocoon of ignorance are better off than those who try to find out what the hell is going on in this world.

@callmedubious I hear ya!

1

All of it is interesting and good..so long as you can understand it in the context of which the original texts were conceived. Don't think of it in religious terms. Once dogma entered the picture the original purpose of the texts were lost.

1

First off I don't think that there are any holy books. Unless we can consider some of the literary masterpieces holy, or the ancient hand-lettered and illustrated works of art holy. Some of those I'd give a holy label just for being irreplaceable. Religious books because they're religious? No.
I'm not really that certain that Jesus existed. The bible being holy? Meh. Palm reading🤣🤣🤣
My 2 cts..

As above, used the term to be inclusive of all texts relating to religion, the religious regard them as holy 🙂 the point of the post was never the discussion of my use of book descriptors 😂 nope I’m not sure Jesus existed either, I don’t really care, I’m happy to leave many stones unturned. I just wondered if anyone took anything away from said books, however you would describe them 😊

1

Well, although I don't take the Bible too seriously, the 10 Commandments aren't bad guidelines for life.

One does not need a religious book to not kill, steal or sleep with your neighbor or brother's wife. Common sense and don't do it to someone else if you don't want it done to you should be sufficient.

@noworry28 , true. Nevertheless, they are good guidelines. I never said they are my guidelines but I still find them good.

@Paddypereira The first 4 are bullshit to me, so I will use common sense for the other 6 and that is basically what those six are.

Which set?

@LaDizdeOdd no other gods, no idols, no blasphemy, honour your parents (no guidelines for parents to be decent), do not commit adultery, steal, misrepresent people, don’t covert your neighbours’ things, oh gosh and a couple more lols.

1

The future is in our hands but not written in our hands. The bible is not a good book. It could be if you were stranded and had no toilet paper.

1

I like "Song of Songs", a whole lot of erotic sensual love and not much god stuff.

1

The bible is a vile book. It is full of murder, rape, and slavery. Jesus was not a good bloke, he was for slavery. Jesus wanted to divide people's families.

Hmm we never did that bit in Sunday school.

1

There is a lot of smutty stuff....Abraham pimping out Sarah(several times), Lot & his daughters, etc etc....also gory stuff, like a head on a platter, lots of massacres, and a major mass drowning. But I think Netflix does it better, plus I don't have to wade through a bunch of "begats"....put that book Down, man!

1

Your initial obser vation is all too true. Many, many topics are more worthy of discussion.

1

I actually thought the book of Ruth was a good read. The story was entertaining.

1

we don't stray from the topic of religion. it's not straying. it is a site designed for us to speak of many things, not just religion. do atheists and agnostics have to discuss religion all day and all night? what a bore that would be! i certainly have not dedicated my life to not believing in any gods. there aren't any gods. so... i can't think about anything else, ever?

as for what parts of a holy book are interesting, what is a holy book? i don't accept the concept of holiness. are you talking about bibles and such? i rather like king david. he is wonderfully imperfect. i don't take anything in it to be holy or sacred, though.

i don't know the christian bible, though. i've never been christian.

g

0

imo the Bible is not holy, or at least does not profess to be anywhere. I know a guy on the hands thing, you might be interested, [biblenews1.com]

I was trying to be inclusive and so holy book as including the Koran, Torah or Book of Mormon etc. 😉
The traveller population have tradition of religion and palm reading too, but Muslims tend to read feet instead I’ve noticed, I do find it interesting that other people have more modern interpretations too, thanks.

0

I was reading 3 times that book and tried studying it with some others, none made sense enough to warrant me to keep beating my head about it. It ended a marraige and she died in it.
The future is in hand if we live another day...

0

The whole book is interesting. As long as you look at it as just a book, not a collection of religious texts. The Old Testament gives a good view of how a group of early men created answers to the questions they had none for and many sound insights into how the human mind works. They didn't consciously know they were doing the psychological study part since they couldn't see they were creating their version of God with all of the hatred and prejudices they carried in their minds though they may have known how dead on their descriptions of how we behave toward one another are. As to the New Testament the complete about face from the "an eye for an eye" philosophy for one of "turn the other cheek" and submission to higher authority is almost too great to accept, making one wonder if the claims of the stories of Jesus actually being the creation of the Flavian emperors. The observations of the writers are generally sound, it's their adding the supernatural connotation that takes things astray.

Interesting.

0

Firstly, I do not accept any book as being "holy;" but this does not mean we cannot find any words of wisdom or kindness in any of them. That said, they don't have any more wisdom, compassion, etc. than many secular writings.

About Jesus: yes, the bible has stories of his kindness, but he could also be a jerk. After all, he did believe in hell and he compared the Canaanite woman to a dog. Jesus is like the rest of the bible--you can pick out what you like and throw out the rest.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:463905
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.