Stolen from my friend on Facebook
Blaming all cops for the thuggish and murderous behavior of a few cops is qualitatively no different at all from blaming all black people for the actions of a few.
Did I get that right?
Well this is timely. John Oliver on the appalling lack of accountability in police departments nationwide. The issue is not a few bad apples. It is a system with next to no mechanism for removing those bad apples and, in fact, that covers for them and punishes whistleblowers, otherwise known as good cops. The system is badly badly unbelievably badly broken.
That is flawed logic.
If I have to explain it to you...
You wouldn't understand anyway.
She's done this before. She doesn't want to understand.
History has shown how many times mankind has reacted in a "herd" mentality. Blame creates no solutions. There are many variables to point out that make each factor react the way they do. A man lost his life over an alleged fake $20 bill. Good policing would've had the officer confiscate the bill, have it checked and move on with his day. I believe that anger from him being filmed escalated into a serious act of stupidity and a grand display of power that went awry. I live urban and I see that generally, police are afraid as I have been stopped for a traffic violation and approached with guns out. I'm sure that this topic could be discussed in greater detail if we were in the same room. Writing out our best critical thinking is a tough job.
I do not agree that they are murdering POC out of fear. I believe they are doing it because they believe they can get away with it. What I saw in that cop's face as he was killing George Floyd was not "fear", it was "power". I'm not buying into cops being scared. If that's the case, they should stop being a cop. That's not a reason for anyone to die.
@redbai i agree. I don’t think fear comes into it, at all.
@redbai A show last night exposed that they knew each other, worked together and that they "bumped" heads. It was personal. It brought a lot of attention to police brutality and it's frequency to POC. The media is making a huge profit by manipulating the mindset of the public by pushing buttons and getting people to jump to conclusions. Fear is the essence of all things. Fear breeds everything that we use to survive. It's just the amount of fear that tends to get noticed.
Wrong is wrong and white is not might. I hear all sorts of people speaking out saying that George Floyd was a common criminal. OK, I got it. That means it is OK for the cops to kill him? I don't think so.
Interestingly, chauvin was a criminal himself! IF we take those peoples' argument at face value and apply it, Chauvin deserves to be killed by some executioner cop himself.
No quite. Cops are an agency that is established to Protect and Serve their community. If there are bad cops and their fellow cops turn a blind eye, then they are complicit.
Blacks are not an agency, they are a population of individuals that have experienced 400 years of loathsome, atrocious, inhumane treatment. If many are angry, gee go figure. It is common for those born to white privilege, live in white privilege, and practice white privilege to lump all blacks together under one umbrella. It justifies their feeling of white privilege and unfounded superiority. It was born in European Imperialusm and is the last vestige of that system.
So cops are hired to serve all in the community regardless of ethnicity. Just like the Presidentvwas elected to represent ALL people regardless of race, color, creed or etnincity.
The Police Union makes them all complicit. The eager militarization makes them unfortunately fall under the umbrella of thugs even if they are not.
Nope wrong. People are born in to their race. People CHOOSE to be cops. One can easily choose not to be a cop or choose to take off the uniform. You cannot do the same with your skin.
Also, your friend fails to distinguish the difference between individual level racism and SYSTEMIC racism. Boiling things down to simplified versions is easy, but it misses the nuance and greater understanding systemic racism requires. The system is rotten and it's not one bad apple spoiling the busshel, it is an infected or disease ridden bush with good apples and bad apples sprouting.
That is true. However the culture of policing seems to focus on physical control of situations and proceeding as if there is a potential for a problem. Their training focuses on that control, rather than constructive interaction. Many police officers manage it anyway, but some don't and, unfortunately, they are often supported by their fellow officers when they don't.
I was in a protest some time ago where we occupied Senator Packwood's office in Portland, Or. A policeman walked into the room full of peaceful protestors and said, "I am in control and all of you will now leave the Federal Building." No one knew whether or not he had any authority but then 250 people sat down on the floor. The policeman got really mad and left to get the FBI. An agent walked into the room, introduced himself and asked that we stay as long as we wanted, we had the right to do so, and he was going to be having a talk with the previous officer. After the FBI guy talked about half of the people in the room left It was a fun day.
Thinking of anyone as a fungible group, where all the members are identical and indistinguishable, leads to prejudiced thinking.
There's a street or gang code "1312", which stands for "ACAB"; "All Cops Are Bastards". Certainly some cops are bastards. Others, I believe the great majority, are decent and hard-working.
Those who say "the good cops are complicit if they don't report the bad cops", well, for one thing, this is why we have body cams and dash cams; to protect everyone. And even these recordings aren't always clear as to what an officer experiences in the heat of the moment. Second, it takes a lot to stand up and call someone out for internal discipline. I've done it; I've felt ostracized for it, even though the officers involved were a hazard not only to the prisoners but to fellow staff.
And there has to be something tangible to report. Anyone can report an incident of excessive force, but there has to be evidence. Attitudes can't be reported for internal discipline. You can report discriminatory harassment and language, but it will be simply hearsay unless so many people report that there's a clear pattern. You can't really report "This officer is a racist".
Summing up my point: Anyone who's been in this situation knows it's extremely hard to be the first to speak up, but very easy to chime in after the fact and say "Someone should have done something."
I agree with your last paragraph. I'm not a policeman but as a serviceman and a civilian I've had to stand up for something or someone on occasion. If you have concerns,I think you have to air them.
@Paul_Clamberer I presume you know (and we've both been in the service) how hard it can be to stand out from the crowd, even when it's the right thing to do. None of the privates at My Lai thought of themselves as murderers; they had orders to follow.
Many police departments talk in terms of being at war with "the criminal element"; many people talk in terms of being at war with the police. When this militarized language is used, it's far too easy to fall into a mindset where "the enemy" is anyone who pushes back.
Even though it's fictional, End Of Watch is a good film to see how police officers cope with the day to day issues and see the actual reactions of people on the street to a uniform. Their interactions are almost identical to mine and my fellow officers in the prison setting. Some are friendly, some are neutral, some would like to see us dead, and it's hard sometimes to tell which is which; hence the stress and sometimes the anger.
It has become clearer in the past couple of weeks that the bad cops are by far in the majority. There is no outcry by the supposedly good cops about what their associates are doing. I've known law enforcement officers and they have been bigots and generally unenlightened.
I agree. There are plenty of good, conscientious cops. A good friend of mine is a retired Dallass cop. He is one of the most loved people on this island and is heavily invested in the program to provide seniors with food. I haven't seen him since the lock down and it will be interesting to hear his comments.
I think a big problem is large groups of heavily armed and armored men going against a large group of people. It is a mob control issue and the mob is not the civilians.
YES, i agree with you. Did you notice how the white supremacist groups march in Washington with faces hidden and armed.. and were not attacked by the police..and there were no record of any license to march at all
Where are all these "good cops" while people /journalist are being shot with rubber bullets? A Homelees Disable man IN a Wheelchair was shot in the face with a rubber bullet. He's now Blind in his right eye..yeah good cops..
@Charlene I agree but also realize that the bad cops and their horrible actions are what makes the news. We almost never hear of those doing a good job. I try not to generalize about people. We are all the same but also all different.
@AmmaRE007 No, but also understand the idea of mob rule. If one cop goes after a group often others will follow. This is the problem with many of the police groups. Too much armoring and heavy/terrifying weapons. They feel invincible and all in it together. Subtle intimidation (going against the crowd - meaning the police groups) often get people doing things of which they don't agree.
@Charlene Perhaps we need to look outside the places that are getting all the news. There have been a few where the cops (usually without all the armor and in small numbers) siding with the protestors.
No, you did not get that right. A race of people is not a corrupt professional organization. I used to be a police dispatcher & the corruption IS rampant in every police department. You SHOULD blame all the cops that refuse to speak out & routinely turn a blind eye - and even worse - actively work to suppress, harass, & bully anyone who tries to speak out. You SHOULD blame governments who know the systemic problems exist & refuse to undertake systemic reorganization. I quit being a police dispatcher because of the horrible shit that went on every single day. When I tried to bring it to the attention of my superiors, I was met with an organized response designed to harass & bully me into silence. Everyone knew exactly what was going on, & no one was willing to do anything about it. So yes, all people who actively participate in upholding a corrupt organization deserve blame, no matter how small their role in said organization. Sadly, most of our organizations are now this corrupt, but that's a story for another time.
I am definitely part of the white privlidge folks. I know this is true I can't do anything about it but I do try. I really posted this because I hoped that it will make some police officers and some racists think about how stupid it is to label everyone in a group with the same adjectives. The majority of people instead thought that I was trying to stand up for all policemen. I think very serious reform needs to take place in almost every police station in America and probably many other countries. I think black Americans have suffered through hundreds of years of unfair personal and government policies.
I think you don't know me if you think I am a racist.
I did not think you were racist from the post .This is the problem. First off, what is so horrible about standing up for good policeman in the first place .And second , dwelling on hundreds of years of being treated unfairly should not be placed on the backs of the people of today .
@bebe12 You feel bad about the charge of racism being place "on your back?" Try having a cop's knee pressing there! Oh, right! Your White Privilege protects you from that! And it helps create that sweet illusion of White Innocence, the illusion that the safe and decent life you have is not based on the continued exploitation and subjugation of others. It's so sweet to enjoy that you resent it being challenged...
POC are still being mistreated THIS VERY DAY! Are you honestly so naive you think once slavery was over everything was swell for freed slaves? No. Enter Jim crow laws followed by policies enacted to target and disenfranchise black and brown americans such as redlining of neighbourhoods, credit card denials or higher interest rates, lower wages earned, poorer housing options, poorer underfunded schools to attend, lower quality of healthcare, overrepresentation in jails for non violent crimes, the school to prison pipeline, longer sentences to the same crimes as whites, etc. etc. Nobody needs to dwell on 100s of years ago when shit has yet to be resolved or fixed RIGHT NOW.
Reposted from another post; When I was in Seattle, I knew a Field Rep from Southland. Steve Titus and I ran into each other once in a while. One day while watching the news, I read Steve had been arrested for rape. I was shocked. The facts started to come out
"On October 12, 1980, a 17-year-old girl was raped in an isolated area just south of the Seattle-Tacoma airport, and she described her attacker as a white man with a beard who was driving a blue car.
The same night, Steve Titus was out in Seattle with his fiancée, celebrating her 21st birthday, when he was pulled over by police. Titus, who had no criminal record other than a driving citation, agreed to be photographed by police after they informed him that a man fitting his physical description who was also driving a blue car had raped a teenager near the airport that evening.
Titus was not concerned by the encounter with police, but two days later, police officers showed up at his office and arrested him for the rape. Police informed Titus that the victim had picked his photograph out of a photo lineup. She reportedly said, “This one is the closest. It has to be the one.”
Read the whole story. They killed him. Wrong guy. I had also bought a new car that month and I lived four blocks from where it happened. Temp plates also. Two door import. I'm sure they looked at my car now. I was probably a suspect also.
[law.umich.edu]
There are far too many similar stories in the US!
"One Florida police organization has said it will re-hire those very officers accused of misconduct, and that offer is prompting outrage."
Did you not read this? They WANT officers that have commited crimes against citizens.
I read about it and it sickened me.
The police slashing Private owned vehicle tires all over this Nation!!!
Yes, by a few spread out all over this nation!!!
This Domestic Terrorism by those who are suppose to protect us and serve us from such criminal fascists activities!!!
This forum is largely populated by logical people. Logical people have strong emotions just like everyone else. I seem to have started a firestorm of sorts with this post. Please understand that if there is just one good cop in the world, it is not logical to say all cops are thugs and murderers.
If that one "good" cop fails to intervene in the inappropriate actions of their colleagues, they are as guilty as their colleagues.
Its a lot more complicated than that.
@PondartIncbendog no it's not..if I saw You attempting to hurt a child I'd kick you in balls..Thou knew what was happening and Did Nothing..
@Charlene What? That doesn't make any sense.
@PondartIncbendog misspelled Chauvin's partners last name..
@LovinLarge It is the important word in your statement. I agree that cops that support officers performing bad acts are complicit.
Not when fellow cops and their unions support their behavior no matter what. No.
My main problem is with the word all.
@Lorajay They are all in the same union. They are all culpable. This is a systemic problem.
Sure, however it does not seem like it is the behavior of a FEW cops, just look at how those cops who resigned because the two cops got put on no pay suspension, how they all clapped when they got out of court. What does that say.
Not all of them resigned and not all of them clapped.
@Lorajay "The entire Buffalo Police Department Emergency Response Team has resigned".
What I read in the Guardian is that the team resigned because the insurance company covering personal liability for the team stated it would not cover any exposure from oppressing demonstrators. This was supposedly because two of the team were charged.
@Theresa_N Surely when one is at work doing ones job you are covered by your place of work not special personal liability? Of course it is different if you bring a gun to work and start shooting people or in any other way harming them, but then your place of work is not responsible for what you have done unless they have instructed you to do so. It doesn't seem right what the Guardian is saying about the reason for them resigning.
Well, it doesn't matter, all that matters is the rest of the team cheered the two guilty of assault when they came out of the courtroom. They're all collectively guilty.
You got it right and here is a similar:
"letting a demonstration be judged by it's most violent participants but not judging a police force by it's most violent cops is the language of the oppressor."
that is true but irrelevant (not to the question, totally relevant to the question, but irrelevant to the current protests) because it is not the protesters who are violent. they are ringers.
g
( Clears throat ) Hi
Actual former law enforcement officer here and let me please start by saying that I would never attempt to tell a brain surgeon, airplane pilot or even a true social activist on how to do there job and that reason that I’ve never had to do what they do.
But and I do mean but I’ve heard from a lot people speculate as to how law enforcement is supposed to do theirs without ever trying.
Now before anyone decides to go all liberal nazi on me.
We need to clear up that unlike what jimmy Dore says not every cop is a bully or was bullied in their childhood.
But unfortunately they do exist and they’re are the only one’s that people remember and unfortunately the ideology of most law enforcement supervisors are that if people are complaining then you’re doing your job.
This is where the internal circle of protection comes into play.
Whenever a citizen complains about one of these officers the brass will immediately tell the D A that the officer is a good officer and is just doing their job and away goes the problem.
It’s not much different for an officer who files a complaint against another officer.
The supervisors will tell HR that the officer making the accusations is most likely retaliating against the accused because they were corrected by the accused for not doing their job right and then follows the outcasting and shit assignments.
If they go to internal affairs then you’re not safe at all and if you’re injured or killed they’ll ( I did ) or go to another department and hopefully the news won’t follow.
So what you’re left with are the bad ones, those who excuse themselves from responsibility because they’re not the ones committing the act, and those who are just trying to stay under the radar because they need the job and or retirement.
Even simpler way to look at this is that they’re humans with human behaviors both good and destructive the greater difference is whether or not their influences have been abusive and/or racist.
I guess that your friend was trying to make is that broad stroking law enforcement is actually no different than cops broad stroking certain segments of society because law enforcement is made up of all segments of society.
So my question is if we get rid of law enforcement as we have now then what’s going to prevent the human equation from affecting the perceived purity of the position.
I say perceived purity because after everything that you see and encounter especially when you take into account the times you go to court and you see actual evil get little to no time because the system allows their lawyers to negotiate with the government to overlook their actions because they’re not really that guilty just like the supervisors have done for their criminal officers.
I don't know what's going on in the world, I have my own life to deal with.i love everyone whatever their color or beliefs. I do find it strange that a responsible driver is pulled over 3000 miles from home,officers line the interstate, my car emptied along said interstate, because a simple silver necklace hanging from the mirror was an obstruction of view. He looked at my license and saw it was from West Virginia. He asked if I knew of the state police academy there. Many other officers falsely accusing me of being dead also graduated from the same school.
I completely agree that there are a few good officers out there, but there are way too many that have had their heart ripped out and are seeking promotion instead of offering protection.
@Holysocks Sadly the necklace was an excuse they used to stop you.
You were profiled as possibly being a drug trafficker and since you wanted to be cooperative they took it as they could to attempt to find what they believe is there.
They asked you a ton of questions and you were most likely asked the same questions by other law enforcement officers.
That was to get your story and to see if you would vary from it.
Big ass mistake that most honest people don’t realize is when they start asking you questions you don’t have to answer them.
You simply ask them what was their reason for pulling you over or stopping you while walking. If they tell you that it’s for an offense then you ask them for the penal code.
And if it’s not a felony then you simply instruct them to right you a ticket and end the conversation there. ( I don’t have to answer any of your questions and my attorney will help with this summons.)
If you see a second vehicle pull in then be prepared to be removed from your vehicle because now they’re gonna try to cite that they have reasonable suspicion.
And I can’t stress enough do not fight them, do not refuse to exit your vehicle this will only escalate the situation and will cement their suspicions that you’re hiding something illegal and they can then cite that you’re interfering with a police investigation and they will most likely tack on that you’re resisting arrest.
And if you do have something illegal then you need to tell them and let them have access to whatever it is and let your attorney take it from there. And go away with one charge.
Now if don’t have anything illegal you should still get out but you don’t have to give them consent to search your vehicle if you don’t want to but be prepared to be detained and harassed for at least an hour.
Also before you step out of your vehicle you should roll your windows up and as soon as the door is closed lock them.
They can’t just use the excuse of I thought I saw something.
You’re going to see more officers and a supervisor they’ll try nice cop and attempt to tell you that can’t do what you just did, that you’re going to jail and even use your kids and family to just simply let them have their way.
Once again you don’t have to answer their questions.
K9 will show up and if the dog states that there’s something there then they won’t need a warrant which is why I said if you’ve got it then just let them have it.
If the dog doesn’t sit then they have to get a warrant which will be difficult because their lack of evidence so they’ll once again attempt to intimidate you or convince you to just simply let them have their way.
The answer is “ no “ and am I under arrest.
They’ll reluctantly release you.
At which time you get with attorney and you lodge a complaint against them but don’t stop there contact your local government representatives by mail or email and advise them that their officers are profiling and you make sure that they respond to you just in case you begin to get harassed and then you go to the state attorney general’s office and repeat your complaint.
Now this is the most important thing that I can tell everyone.
If you’re pulled by law enforcement and you know for a fact that you weren’t violating any laws.
You need to let people know that you’ve just been pulled and if you can once you see the officer/deputy/trooper give your people their name and why the said they were pulling you over.
This creates a time stamp just in case their cameras aren’t “ working “ and The Who and why.
I say this because of the creative writing classes that law enforcement goes through can at times vary from what actually took place and if your family or attorney doesn’t any better then you might not win in court.
And just in case anyone here decides to use their phone or any other form of recording device please keep in mind that if used for your defense or to file a complaint against the officer that it and it’s contents are subject to review by their side.
So if you naughty things with phone, or if you’re cheating on your spouse this will be brought up in court.
If you have a recording device in your vehicle and they review all of your recordings which they will and you’ve committed any crimes while in that vehicle they can and most likely will charge for them.
So yes there are bad cops but they’re still operating within the guidelines given to them by our government.
And honestly the best way to solve our issues with law enforcement is to rewrite the guidelines as to limit their power over us and for the public to learn what they are and how they’re supposed to be carried out.