Agnostic.com

8 4

What if the United States had proportional representation instead of a winner take all system? Will this reshape the future of federalism?

#USA
Humanlove 7 May 29
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

8 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

1

I'm for parliamentary systems, similar to those in Europe. Everybody has a chance to have a voice at the table, and viewpoints are far more diverse and nuanced than in this two party system here. Plus, it is usually necessary to form coalitions to have a majority, so that means negotiation and compromise. The US would greatly benefit from a more equitable system.

2

I do not believe proportional representation fits into a democratic republic. I believe there is a better way to unsure equal representation. The popular vote works well at the state, county and city levels of government in the United States. We need to abolish the electoral college, too many candidates focus only on areas of the electorate they need to win the college. Bush and Trump both won because of this despite the popular vote totals.

I think first we need to fix the congressional districting. Independent committees with judicial review are needed to ensure no partisan tampering occurs.

Next we need to address campaign finance law. Abolish Citizens United and any non-individual campaign donations. Cap individual donations at $1000.00 each.

One other area of concern should be lobbying. Anyone elected should not be allowed to turn around and become a lobbyist. They need to serve their term then return home and work like the rest of us.

MarkF Level 5 May 29, 2018
0

Bring it on, the sooner the better.

0

It would change it, in some ways better, in some worse. I would love to find a perfect solution. Sadly, those entrenched in the status quo would never enable it.

1

I'm in favor of a system with several "at Large" representatives that are awarded to third, fourth, etc parties that achieve a predetermined vote tally. This might encourage more political parties.

2

I think this is a good idea. Our winner take all system ensures that the two major parties (controlled by special interests) keep a lock on our system. Proportional representation ensures that minorities have a voice at the table.

2

Would that not be a more parlimentary system? I think that would be better than were we are going now. I think the bigger issue is corporate mnoney and the very wealthy. We campaign WAY too long. Limit funding and time - 9 months before an election candidates can start sollicity funds and campaigning. Course the term campaigning will need to be narrowly defined.

0

I wish we had proportional representation here in UK. yes I think it would at least be a different political shape

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:93865
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.