Just overheard a conversation:
Lady: Hey, how are you?
Guy: Not too bad. You?
Lady: Pretty good.
Guy: (Totally unprovoked) You know, I was at church the other day...
Lady: (Visibly dies a little)
Guy: ...and when they asked me what I wanted to drink, I said, "Holy water"! (laughs)
Lady: That's funny.
Narrator: It was not funny.
As if small talk wasn't bad enough, you have to make it about church.
I think I would have been tempted to answer with Jonestown Koolaid and waited to see if he got it.