I'm willing to cut folks some slack on this. They might have some kind of disability. Narcolepsy has pretty much made the idea of a career laughable for me. I wouldn't want to be shot down because of it, so I afford other folks the same chance.

I would be curious to why they didn't want to tell me, but provided they seemed otherwise reasonably normal I'd be content to let them tell me in their own time. They might, for example, have a job they don't feel very proud about - a lot of people look down on those who flip burgers or clean offices, for example, so that could be one reason. Alternatively, they might not have had a career for some reason: I have a friend who has been dating for the last five years and dreads that question because, despite having a master's degree in physics from a very prestigious university, he didn't work between the ages of 25 and 42 as between those ages he was a heroin addict. He's been clean for six years, is a decent guy and is currently completing a teacher training course but experience has taught him that more often than not a date is as good as over if he's honest about his past.

Depends how far in to the conversation you are and the general tone of how it’s asked. Some people come across as creepy when asking for personal information. Makes me second guess their motives.

I would think it was weird if I asked someone about his/her job and got an evasive answer. I don't see any reason to hide that kind of information unless you are an assassin, a drug dealer, human trafficker, or work for the Trump administration.

People as often ask what other
folks do for work to gague the level of respect due to that person.. think about that for a second.. Now take work out of the equation...
You have nothing to gague respect other than human being-ism-ness.
Just my thoughts on it...I'm not saying it's right...ideally we should respect each individual equally but, in all honesty, we don't.

I figger:
it depends upon how long y'all been exchanging words
how many words, and how often

Since "Fatal Attraction" smart men have been more cautious about revealing stuff.

There is no way to know if you are a real person, that you are actually as you have represented yourself, that you do not have a history of stalking, and what your true intentions are.

For purposes of dating or pre-dating I think it's entirely appropriate and fair game. Although outside the US, what one does for a living is not considered appropriate polite conversation or go-to ice-breaker topic, like it is in the US. In fact it's considered kind of boorish. You're supposed to ask about hobbies and interests, where one lives, but not work. But then again, that's for general socializing, not assessing someone as a potential life partner. For those purposes, it seems to me that if someone is withholding, then they're probably trying to get you roped in and committed before you find out about their former life as a mob enforcer.

Perhaps they work, as I do, in a sensitive place?

Personally, I might ask if someone works full or part time - or at all. But as to what they actually do, I don't mind finding all that out later. Often someone will voluntarily disclose details within a conversation.

Maybe they have been recently laid off and it's painful to talk about... Or sometimes people with well-paying jobs can be taken advantage of--- male or female... Or they could be creatures of the night?

A person's livelihood is their own business & if they choose not to tell people, then it shouldn't be a big deal......especially online.

You can refer to my post entitled "8 Questions to Ask Other Than "What Do You Do?"

This post was inspired by a question that preceded it, asking men their reasons for asking a woman this question right away. You might find some insight there, as I received many replies.

Research shows it's not the best thing to ask.

I love my job and am proud of it, but I despise the question when it's asked early in a conversation.

In many places around the world, it's actually considered a ride thing to ask. Me personally, I don't think it's rude, but I find it can sometimes be a loaded question.

I do not think it is impolite to ask. Maybe they're concerned that they won't measure up to your standards. Also possible that they're not proud of their work history. I would be a little suspicious but would probably keep talking to them out of curiosity.

Not impolite to want to know if you're chatting with a potentially opportunist bum. My red flag: wanting to talk or chat into the wee hours. They obviously don't have some where to be in the morning. Or saying they're a "contractor" one day, and the next day saying they work in the family business. Another is "I don't know but I feel excited when I talk to you. What if I move there? Would you date me then?". If all of that is coming from the same person - run.

It is useful information, and when someone will not answer the question, there is reason to wonder why he or she will not.

They who do not want to say, were incarcerated. Usually one can tell from the prison jargon evident in their posts. But not all of them. The white collar criminals are very articulate.

No,I do not see a problem,unless it's against the law.When Women ask me what I've done,I reply, "Give me a year, or time frame". Not doing so,would make me more than suspicious.......

I don't think its impolite.

I think it's a silly and irrelevant question. When someone asks me "What do you do ?"
My answer is: About what ?